Thread by @barandbench

Delhi High Court will hear Covid related petitions today.

A Bench of Justices Vipin Sanghi and Jasmeet Singh to hear the cases.

#DelhiHighCourt #COVID19India

Delhi High Court hearing PIL by a doctor seeking probe into medical mafia- politicians nexus.

Govt seeks 6 weeks time. Court takes exception to govt stance

"This is not acceptable. By 6 weeks this issue might not exist. Political parties have no business to turn this pandemic..

They have no business to hoard medicine while others are paying high prices"

#COVID19India

Advocate Virag Gupta says different MPs, procuring it and hoarding

Cites example of Gautam Gambhir.

No action taken yet.

Court says political leaders have no business to hoard stocks. If their intention is to do public good, then they should give it DGHS and he will distribute it to the needy

How did Gautam Gambhir get such large quantities from chemist during such shortage, asks Delhi High Court.

Govt says it will seize it.

#DelhiHighCourt #COVID19India

Court says it won't direct seizure since it is legal exercise to be carried out by police.

Court asks Govt to ask leaders to correct themselves.

Order: We hope and expect Delhi police to conduct proper investigation into the hoarding of medicines

Status report to be filed.

We hope and expect that medicines are not hoarded for political gains.

We expect that these medicines be surrendered to Director General of Health Services for distribution to govt hospitals

Matter to be heard next week

Citizens are suffering due to this. You owe a duty to people. This is not the way: Delhi High Court to Delhi Police.

Political leaders should not hoard COVID drugs for political gains: Delhi High Court takes exception to Gautam Gambhir, others stocking medicines

#COVID19India #DelhiHighCourt

barandbench.com/news/litigatio…

Various petitions filed by hospitals before Delhi High Court citing Oxygen shortage are being withdrawn by the hospitals since the supply has now stabilised.

Delhi govt counsel @TheRahulMehra and other lawyers thank Delhi High Court intervention in the Oxygen matter.

"Your Lordships intervention saved countless lives. My Lords sat even on Saturday and Sunday."

#DelhiHighCourt #OxygenCrisis

Fixation of price of Oxygen Cylinders

It cannot be demand and supply, there has to be govt intervention, there has to be a ceiling..... : Justice Singh on

#OxygenShortage

Correction: oxygen concentrator***

Landed price is ultimately determined by the exporter. It is in their hands. If Lordships are suggesting that we fix a price now, because there are diff concentrators, it is not possible....There are diff concentrators with different prices, sizes and names.... : Kirtiman Singh

Why can't you fix a formula..... : Bench

There is a confusion on MRP....Prices keeps changing...by exporter : Singh

This is not an answer...work around it. We can't throw our hands in the air and say it can't be fixed. How can you say MRP is not fixed : Justice Singh

People should be able to afford it, they cant be taken for a ride. Shortage cant be taken advantage of.... Should you ( govt) not think of the Consumer? : Justice Vipin

#OxygenShortage
#DelhiHighCourt

There is a global shortage.....if I fix a price today, the suppliers may not supply whatever they are supplying now : Kirtiman Singh

Monitoring is with regard to fluctuation : Kirtiman

We are saying you fix the principle on which it (oxygen concentrators) will be charged, you fix the formula : Bench

#OxygenShortage

We are not asking you to fix a price on Rupees and paisa...fix a formula : Bench

Your lordships may give me time till tomorrow : Kirtiman

Kirtiman: Suppose I get one concentrator from America for Rs 100 and one from China for Rs 50. Then I need to fix 2 prices.....But i cannot fix two prices for the same drug...

Kirtiman informs Court of an advisory informing people on minimum standards of COVID concentrators to be used in Covid care centres....

What to buy, how to use, there should be info. You should come out with these ads. Why is that not happening in these times? Why should you not use audio-visual media? Bench

Aarogya setu app used widely now because of the Centre's wide campaigning : Kirtiman

@SetuAarogya

1031 callers, we did test run today.... The people who handle calls need to be sensitized to that effect : Rao

RahuL Mehra : We are giving them in house training...it is work in progress.

Karuna Nundy: Status report will be submitted.

Nundy: The app, delhifightscorona, the linkages have not been made. The COVID kits, the govt had to consider.

Bench: We have only asked them to consider, let them consider...

According to medical experts, it is much better for patients, if saturations going down below 90, much better to go to hospitals than have oxygen cylinders or concentrators at home : Rahul Mehra

#DelhiHighCourt
#Oxygensupply

The numbers speak for themselves. If anyone is put on ventilators, it is less likely that they will return. I have been told something that is why I am calling for that data. The data on how many made it after placing them on ventilators is shocking. : Mehra

If this is true, you as a policymaker should decide on how many ventilators are required : Justice Vipin Sanghi

#OxygenShortage

I think we can close the hearing for today. Unless there is anything urgent, we will hear the matter on Thursday : Bench

Abhay Gupta : You can make exclusions.... Prices have to be fixed, it can't be that hospitals charge whatever they want. Cites example of Kerala govt

If State of Kerala has fixed hospital charge cap, then that model may be looked into it. If it works in Kerala, then why can't it work here? Bench

You cant give a covid kit and keep charging for things.. : Justice Vipin Sanghi

Rahul Mehra: Hospitals are the only institution doing business. You should cross-subsidize. You (Hospitals) should give your services for free during this time

Matter to be taken up next on May 19.