Thread about MAGA violence and calling it out. MTG's comments aren't just about Nazis. Her words are in line with a narrative of Trumpism: endorsing violence or threat of violence for political gain, a throughline from 2016 to 1/6 to disenfranchisement efforts. 1/
Greene is disturbed. She is also promoting a familiar violent narrative meant to incite. Greene is equating those who support masking with Nazis. That's obvious. But it is more than horrifying. It is code. If we are Nazis, then violence towards us is justified. Wink and nod. 2/
It's a technique Trump mastered; promote violence without saying so, a sophisticated use of stochastic (inciting for random acts of violence) terrorism. "Liberate Michigan!" and they tried to kidnap the Gov. He would deny it. Just a joke, his people would say.
3/
"Stop the steal" the same. How exactly is the steal to be stopped when the language Trump used was "fight"? So his people tried on 1/6. He didn't really mean fight, they now say, but the violence and threat of it remain with every use of the election lie. 4/
Election suppression efforts are also a threat, the threat of state approved criminal punishment for just wanting to vote. Our history of violence towards voter registration drives and African Americans asserting their rights is recent enough that the point is not lost. 5/
Tucker Carlson has picked up on it. The embrace of "great replacement theory" isn't just about white supremacy; that's too benign. By definition, it is about violence to justify your own perceived annihilation. It was explicit, and shocking. 6/
I've written of this enough, that violence is the connective tissue linking Trump to 1/6 to voter suppression, all done to undermine democracy and diversity. It isn't all the GOP, but those who do not address it can not claim innocence. @TheAtlantic theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/…
7/
And we -- commentators, reporters, etc -- risk muting what is going on if we simply call it words like racism or white supremacy or anti-semitic or crazy. They are also about violence; Nazi references just an addition to the Trump code. Biden gets it. 8/
MTG's comments sounded familiar. On Thursday, I opened a strange letter addressed to me -- no name or return address -- sent to my home. It was a copy of my tweet with a graphic of a mask with a swastika superimposed, suggesting I'm a Nazi. That's all. No explicit threat.9/
I wrote the tweet last week, it got picked up by blue check MAGA apologists and conservative personalities. CNN, where I am an analyst, was accused of endorsing forced vaccinations. I do and did not, and CNN doesn't endorse. 10/
I know the drill: contact authorities, tell CNN (they have been terrific), monitor things, etc. It's not fun, but it isn't the first time. I don't use twitter for righteous indignation (though I'd be justified!). And I was going to say nothing publicly. On that, I changed. 11/
There are reasons to ignore folks like Carlson or MTG; they feed off oxygen. They also feed off silence. Maybe shaming doesn't work, who knows. But maybe we can stop feeling uncomfortable naming the brutal reality of what they promote. Violence. 12/
Violence or the threat of it -- hunt the home address of a mother the least disturbing of those mentioned -- is what defines an element of a political movement hellbent on the win. They aren't hiding it. They are at our front door. 13/13
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The "vaccine wall" I've been describing is distressing but also not surprising. We go from riding a wave to walking through molasses as we hit demand issues related to access and hesitancy. Requires comms and delivery shifts at tactical level. Big is no longer best. 1/
.@erictopol is pointing out here the reality we knew was coming. So we pivot. There are other commentators (not Eric!) freaking out about this, saying the WH is trying to spin the numbers. I don't get that "take" however satisfying it may be for folks to just complain. 2/
Every major logistics challenge follows the same path: rough start, oil to the engine, then a surge and wave, then molasses. Thankfully, the WH got us to this slower stage sooner than we could have ever hoped under Trump. 3/
To science friends: @ScienceMagazine@hholdenthorp asked me about public health comms and lessons learned. As a mere consumer of health intelligence to guide things I do -- assist state, local and private entities and public how to respond -- I have some (hard) takes. Thread. 1/
Health intelligence is like other intelligence: imperfect, changing as we learn, looks solely through one lens. It provides insights into the "what," but the ultimate decisions often have to take into account costs and benefits that aren't necessarily "scientific" in nature. 2/
Thorp's editorial from the interview lays out the key takeaway: in a national crisis, there are many lanes, all relevant for a nation suffering. We could blame Trump and, while correct, that is too easy. 3/ science.sciencemag.org/content/372/65…
The "replacement theory" isn't just Tucker's usual racism. It is different. The theory -- that space is limited b/c displacement is occurring -- is used as justification for violence to protect a limited resource. It is a promotion and defense of violence. 1/
Also known as "the great replacement," the ideology was first introduced in France about fears of Arab and Muslim immigrants who were allegedly overwhelming the "elite." But Tucker clearly is focused on Hispanics, Jewish Americans and other minorities here. 2/
Tucker is coy because he is also correct in one sense. Replacement is occurring. Young white men today are the last generation of Americans born when Caucasian births outnumbered those of nonwhites. This trend will continue and it animates the racist violence. 3/
THREAD: Robert Pape's @washingtonpost essay about his study (that provides more details than a comment in a @nytimes story) is actually INTERESTING. The racism propelling the "protect the vote" insurrection and subsequent GOP voter suppression strategy are known to Pape. 1/
It would be too bad to lose this data based on a strong research agenda, then condensed to a column, that was written about by a reporter, only for Pape's quote to be criticized on twitter b/c he decided to have some fancy rollout only tomorrow so no one has seen the report! 2/
For me, though, some data from what Pape has released is interesting: "Those involved are, by and large, older and more professional than right-wing protesters we have surveyed in the past. They typically have no ties to existing right-wing groups." "In the past" is operative.3/
Given the lack of live performances for so long, the whole thing -- voices over theatrics, music in the round, the artists sitting and grooving to other artists, the first three selections -- is just a joy to watch. #GRAMMYs
This is such a neat touch and I hope they keep it; artists talking about their careers and how they think about their music. It's just interesting. Plus #BlackPumas are just so good. #GRAMMYs
WHITE GOP MEN AND VACCINES. As I noted before, every cohort of past vaccine resistant pops has shifted towards yes (to "now" or "yes, but not first" category).
Vaccinations beget vaccinations.
EXCEPT GOP men and Trump supporters remain unmoved. Trump continues to harm. 1/
Trump did not announce his vaccination, no photo, no former Pres PSA video. He is hostile to Biden's successes in the roll out. It's tragic, really. FOX could help. But data shows that people can be moved by family and friends too so talk to them, don't shame, one at a time. 2/
Minority and vulnerable populations face access issues, but it is incorrect to call that hesitancy or hostility. Different problem and one that needs to be fixed. Indeed in African American and even Hispanic communities (though latter is still high), hesitancy dropping fast. 3/