Happy Pride Month! Because I am a no fun trans femme buzzkill, here's a THREAD of tech related battles that directly affect LGBTQ+ folks, especially trans women of color and sex workers, that are largely being ignored by the mainstream gay rights movement.
1. FACIAL RECOGNITION: this uniquely dangerous form of surveillance supercharges government and corporate oppression, automates racist policing and social control, & could easily be used by hate groups to target and out queer people. LGBTQ+ groups should join the call for a ban.
2. ATTACKS ON SECTION 230: politicians from both major parties are increasing their misguided and disingenuous attacks on Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, a foundational law for free expression & human rights. The last major change, SESTA/FOSTA, got people killed.
3. ATTACKS ON ENCRYPTION: one of the more recent proposals to change Section 230 was the EARN IT Act, a bill that also attempts to criminalize end-to-end encryption tech like Signal and iMessage. These attacks on privacy and security disproportionately harm vulnerable queer folk
4. CALLS FOR CENSORSHIP: liberal groups in the US are increasingly calling for social media platforms to simply remove more content faster in the name of addressing hate speech and disinformation. Without a human rights based approach this just means marginalized ppl get silenced
5. APPLE'S APP STORE MONOPOLY: wait but Tim Cook is gay, right? Sigh. Apple refuses to allow people to install software on their phones except through their highly restrictive app store, which regularly rejects apps with LGBTQ content, or censors them on behalf of governments.
6. "GENDER RECOGNITION": alongside facial recognition there is a growing array of artificial intelligence surveillance tech that claims to be able to identify things like gender and emotions based on someone's voice or appearance, see Spotify for example: stopspotifysurveillance.org
7. AMAZON'S SURVEILLANCE EMPIRE: more surveillance means less safety for the vast majority of LGBTQ+ people, and Amazon is hurtling us toward a total surveillance state, from Ring camera partnerships with police to AI-powered surveillance on their fleet of delivery vehicles.
8. DMCA TAKEDOWNS & ABUSE: ok i know it's hard to see copyright law as a major issue with everything else going on in the world, but the fact is that the censorship regime created by DMCA and copyright maximalism is regularly weaponized against LGBTQ+ content creators & streamers
9. DEPLATFORMING SEX WORKERS: beyond social media, more & more online services are actively discriminating against sex workers, many of whom are LGBTQ folks. Payment processors, apps like Patreon, major credit cards are caving to pressure from law enforcement & religious groups
10. BIG TECH MONOPOLIES: the Internet can be a force for connection & liberation for LGBTQ+ people, but as it becomes centralized into monopolies built on surveillance capitalism & algorithmic discrimination, it's becoming a force for oppression & violence. We have to change that
There are obviously a ton of other crucial battles & a lot more to say about each of the ones above, but the bottom line here is that any movement claiming to fight for queer & trans people needs to be paying attention to the ways that technology specifically impacts LGBTQ+ folks
That doesn't just mean companies hiring more queer software developers or giving us a new emoji for Pride month. It means actually listening to the concerns of the most vulnerable members of the LGBTQ+ community, and prioritizing the issues facing those most impacted.
If you run a progressive organization that claims to support LGBTQ+ folks & you're not working on any of the issues above ask yourself why. If your organization is calling for changes to Section 230 & you haven't considered the impact on trans folks & sex workers ask yourself why
The Internet has given queer & trans people more of a voice in mainstream society than ever before. But visibility doesn't necessarily translate to justice and liberation unless we fight for it. Let's not repeat our mistakes. Let's fight for EVERYONE. washingtonpost.com/outlook/2018/1…
Surveillance is an LGBTQ+ rights issue. Some countries are already using facial recognition to enforce not just laws but social norms. Surveillance is about controlling our bodies and expression. Fighting surveillance should be a core value of any org fighting for LGBTQ+ folks.
Privacy is not just about what we have to "hide," it's about our ability to evolve. If the US government had ubiquitous facial recognition surveillance just a few decades ago when queerness was criminalized in most states, could the modern LGBTQ rights movement ever have formed?
Far right groups have increasingly attempted to co-opt the framework of free speech, even as they lead a massive a campaign of legal discrimination and violence to suppress trans and queer people's ability to express ourselves, our genders, and our sexualities safely.
We should not allow bigots who want to silence vulnerable people to claim to be the true defenders of free expression. Those who support LGBTQ+ folks need to speak clearly & oppose careless attempts to "sanitize" the Internet without regard for the collateral damage of censorship
I don't want Big Tech monopolies with a rainbow flag. I don't want surveillance and weapons vendors that hire trans women. I don't want corporate festivals sponsored by companies that routinely violate human rights. I don't want assimilation or acceptance. Liberation NOW!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
NEW: after protests organized by @fightfortheftr and widespread backlash from civil rights groups, Amazon Ring is making some significant changes to the ways they allow law enforcement to request footage from their massive network of surveillance cameras gizmodo.com/amazons-ring-w…
Ring will no longer allow the cops to send requests privately to camera owners. Now they’ll have to do it publicly through the neighbors app. They’re also putting some limits on how often they can request footage, the geographical area covered, and for what purposes.
Let’s be extremely clear: Amazon is only doing this because of the tremendous work done by grassroots digital rights and racial justice activists (as well as journalists!) who helped expose the widespread discrimination & abuse enabled by these corporate surveillance partnerships
Happy #TransDayOfVisibility! But trans people need more than visibility. We need housing, safety, food and justice.
Today I'm releasing a video for my song "The Tyranny of Either/Or," made from archival footage of key moments in trans resistance history
Instead of making a lyrics video or whatever, I decided to make this music video into a mini history lesson about the trans and queer liberation movement, from the Compton's Cafeteria Riot to Sylvia Rivera's iconic speech at Christopher St Liberation Day
NEW: here is @fightfortheftr's argument for why private and corporate use of facial recognition surveillance poses just as much of a threat to human rights as government use. We're calling for an outright ban. fightfortheftr.medium.com/why-we-absolut…
There are numerous ways that corporations and even private individuals can use facial recognition to do enormous harm, exacerbating and automating existing forms of oppression and exploitation. Schools, hospitals, retail stores, sporting venues and more are already experimenting.
Our friends @EFF have suggested that an opt-in consent based regulatory framework is sufficient to address this harm. eff.org/deeplinks/2021… We disagree. Biometric surveillance is more like lead paint or nuclear weapons than firearms or alcohol.
Let's start with Miss Major Griffin-Gracy, a veteran of the Stonewall uprising, AIDS activist, prison abolitionist, feminist, and trans liberation organizer.
Now on to Wendy Carlos, trans woman musician who helped invent the popular Moog synthesizer. She composed the scores for A Clockwork Orange, The Shining, and Tron, as well as "Switched on Bach." An absolute legend and godmother of electronic music.
Marsha P. Johnson. Activist. Performer. Drag queen. Stonewall veteran. Sex worker. Founding member of the Gay Liberation Front and co-founder of Street Transvestite Action Revolutionaries (S.T.A.R.) Later an AIDS activist with Act-Up. Consistently fought for the most vulnerable.
Before they take it down, here's the video Amazon circulated internally to roll out what amounts to the largest expansion of corporate surveillance in human history: using artificial intelligence enabled cameras on their fleet of thousands of delivery vans theverge.com/2021/2/3/22265…
Had to split it into 3 parts. Here's part 2. These cameras will not only monitor Amazon drivers but also constantly record video to the front and both sides of the vehicle, and analyze it with AI. Amazon says openly they plan to use it to "investigate" things like "package theft"
The AI claims to monitor for things like "distracted driving." We know systems like this that track eye movements exhibit systemic racial bias. We also know Amazon uses "productivity monitoring" software so invasive workers have gotten UTIs cuz they can't take bathroom breaks
There are a lot of great academics doing super important research about Big Tech, content moderation, and freedom of expression. Their perspectives are important.
But journalists also need to talk to ACTIVISTS, who have actual lived experience using social media for organizing.
Your perspective on things like disinformation & deplatforming change dramatically when you have actually experienced getting deplatformed or algorithmically suppressed or incorrectly flagged as spam just as a campaign is going viral. Even if it's fixed later, the damage is done.
Your average sex worker or Palestine activist knows more about Big Tech power and content moderation than pretty much anyone with a PHD. Sorry not sorry