THREAD: The Pitfalls of Believing Ourselves Good Men
-Men who consider themselves good men but who instantly default to a defensive posture when challenged by women should self reflect on why we’re so obsessed with being right instead of learning more. medium.com/remaking-manho… /1
Often, I mess up on Twitter or in an article. I get called out. I own it. Apologize. Learn. Tis human. /2
As men, we can never fully comprehend the vast and nuanced ways women get silenced, spoken over, harassed, abused, assaulted. Too many times I’ve spoken up without understanding the tone, context, wider implications of the moment. This is where most of my learning takes place. /3
My blind spots also apply to race, sexual identity, gender non-binary folks, immigrants, other religions and so on. If these are not my lived experiences then I’m never going to completely understand, I can only attempt to. /4
Yes, it’s embarrassing to try and be supportive of a woman’s Tweet, statement or article, and then find out from women that we’ve just added to the problem. But too many times I’ve seen men flip to anger instantly in that moment. Those men have a LOT of personal work to do. /5
Some of mistakes I make? 1) Restating the same thing a woman said in a long winded way thinking I’m helping. (A version of talking over.) 2) Implying I understand something a man can never fully understand 3) Engaging when a woman is traumatized and JUST. NEEDS. TO. VENT. /6
I’m confident women can better list “good man” mistakes. I remain blind to many of them. But I’m learning how to de-center myself and be a witness to what women are trying to tell me. Translate that to what BIPOC, LGBTQI+ people, even what my own child is trying to tell me. /7
We’re never done becoming “better men.” There is too much in our culture daily dragging us back into dominance-based masculine behaviors. The best we can do is a daily practice, a mindfullness that centers connection and relationships over roles and status and dominance. /8
So, as a baseline: Learn to listen first, brothers. Prove we can. Foster trust. Be invited in. When we misstep in those spaces, admit it. Offer an apology. State what you learned. It’s not so hard. Exchange humility for our fear of ever being wrong. Take a breath. Grow. /9
It’s a beautiful world if we just stop trying to dominate every interaction. /10
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD: When Women Say “No, Thank You” to Our Offer of a Date
Recently, a woman friend told me about being asked out on a date. It is a story from more than twenty years ago... medium.com/remaking-manho… /1
She was sharing it as part of a larger conversation we were having about relationships. It’s not a dramatic story. It isn’t a story that was difficult to tell. Which makes it all the more instructive because it is so innocuous. /2
Twenty years ago, a man she didn’t know well asked my friend out. “Would you like to go out to dinner?” he asked. They were closing up at the end of the day at a conference where they and others had been working together. My friend said, “Thank you, but no.” /3
The history of the world is one in which men have been taught to leverage our dominance over women – power granted simply by virtue of our being male. /1
For my father’s generation, men didn’t learn to negotiate as equals in their relationships because they controlled the economic power in the family. Men didn’t learn to deal with the daily uncertainty of not knowing because they were free to declare how things should be. /2
Whether we openly leverage it, this legacy of privilege has been handed down to us. Accordingly, developing our more nuanced relational capacities faltered or failed utterly, preempted by masculinity's habitual assertions of dominance. /3
How we are encouraged to think about Billionaires in America. --> Last time I checked, billionaires have feelings too. When you tax a billionaire, how do you think they feel? How do you think it feels to get taxed when you’re a billionaire? You just think about that. /1
Some people think it’s a good idea to tax billionaires. Well let me tell you something. If we tax billionaires we might as well just go ahead and tax ourselves. Keep your hands off my billionaires! /2
Also, what if the other Russian billionaires Make fun of our American billionaires if they have to pay taxes? Do we want Russian billionaires making fun of our American billionaires? I’m sorry but I can’t live that way. /3
Gun violence by police and mass shootings are both rooted in our dominance-based culture of masculinity which, beginning at birth, strips boys and men of expression/connection leaving dominance as the only way to validate our masculinity. /1 medium.com/remaking-manho…
Our dominant culture of masculinity, also called man box culture (a term based on the pioneering work of Paul Kivel and @TonyPorterACTM ), enforces a performance of masculinity that has zero upper limits on the assertion of male dominance. /2
@TonyPorterACTM Man box culture is a bullying, hierarchical power structure. It trains boys and men to accept bullying from those above them and to dish abuse out to those below (or lose status increasing the number above us.) Victimize others or be victimized are our options. /3
THREAD: Gun rights folks clamor for us to individualize gun violence, to pin it on individual shooters' mental illness. NO. Our larger culture is at fault. Our dominance-based culture of masculinity's obsession with guns, violence and power over others is the "illness." /1
Mass gun violence is an extreme expression of dominance-based masculine culture, which trains boys that power over others is the ultimate expression of masculinity. Gun violence is dominance culture being expressed. It's disconnected young men doing what they've been taught. /2
The obsessive political movement which holds gun rights as the ultimate expression of manhood, promotes a version of masculinity which is utterly lost in individualism, dominance, disconnection and shadow. /3
THREAD: Atlanta mass murderer Robert Aaron Long is one of us. Because we’re raised in man box culture, all men contain fragments of masculinity extremists’ world views. His beliefs are not separate from ours, they are just more extreme. remakingmanhood.medium.com/were-all-incel… /1
Lately, I’ve been writing about Incels. The more I consider them, the more I realize they are not so far removed from the rest of us. The incel world view arises from the roots of the same tree, our larger culture of masculinity, where all our ideas about manhood originate. /2
Mr. Long's supposed "sex addiction" narrative is one example of the victimhood narrative which is central to MRA, INCEL and MGTOWs; to all masculinity extremists' world views. "Look what you made me do." /3