THREAD: Gun rights folks clamor for us to individualize gun violence, to pin it on individual shooters' mental illness. NO. Our larger culture is at fault. Our dominance-based culture of masculinity's obsession with guns, violence and power over others is the "illness." /1
Mass gun violence is an extreme expression of dominance-based masculine culture, which trains boys that power over others is the ultimate expression of masculinity. Gun violence is dominance culture being expressed. It's disconnected young men doing what they've been taught. /2
The obsessive political movement which holds gun rights as the ultimate expression of manhood, promotes a version of masculinity which is utterly lost in individualism, dominance, disconnection and shadow. /3
Bullying dominance-based masculinity leans heavily into power over others. It fluidly aligns with male and white supremacy, with religious extremism. It aligns with autocratic authoritarian leaders. It sees women as less, to be used, to be controlled. It sees BIPOC as less. /4
A mass shooting is never just one individual's mental illness. That gun violence is men's response, not women's, signals the clear role of our culture of dominance-based masculinity. It is boys' and men's trauma playing out in our children's schools, our stores, our homes. /5
Man box masculinity strips boys of emotional expression and connection, leaving them isolated, disaffected, angry and alone, susceptible to recruitment by extremists. Our epidemic of gun violence is masculine domination and disconnection playing out on a culture wide scale /6
The solution? Men creating a masculine culture of connection and compassion. Men's work brings men back into balance and connection, to process our disconnection and trauma, to come in from the cold of creating power over others to the warmth of creating power with others. /7
Gun rights folks want us to see mass shooters as mentally ill lone wolves while they march in our streets waving assault rifles. This is dominance-based masculine culture challenging us. The very same culture that breaks boys and then points them toward violence as validation. /8
If you're a man who's tired of feeling disconnected, who's looking to do their men's work to create genuine community and connection, reach out to organizations like @mankindproject, @_evryman, @BetterManMvmt, @HUMENorg and many others. /9
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD: Atlanta mass murderer Robert Aaron Long is one of us. Because we’re raised in man box culture, all men contain fragments of masculinity extremists’ world views. His beliefs are not separate from ours, they are just more extreme. remakingmanhood.medium.com/were-all-incel… /1
Lately, I’ve been writing about Incels. The more I consider them, the more I realize they are not so far removed from the rest of us. The incel world view arises from the roots of the same tree, our larger culture of masculinity, where all our ideas about manhood originate. /2
Mr. Long's supposed "sex addiction" narrative is one example of the victimhood narrative which is central to MRA, INCEL and MGTOWs; to all masculinity extremists' world views. "Look what you made me do." /3
THREAD: The Atlanta shooter is one more example of the direct correlation between white supremacists and male supremacists. These populations feed into and recruit each other's members. You can not be one without being the other. medium.com/remaking-manho…
/1
In our dominance-based man box culture of masculinity, we teach boys a narrow and limited set of rules for being a man. The primary message man box culture teaches boys is “women are less.” We do this by policing boys’ and men’s masculinity via the denigration of the feminine. /2
The bullying and policing of boys and men begins shortly after infancy and goes on continually. "What are you, a girl? What are you, a sissy?" This denigration of the feminine takes place not weekly or daily, but hourly, designed to continually police us back into the box. /3
Until men aggressively police other men's violent words and deeds towards women and girls, we will continue to be collectively responsible for the billions of violent sins committed daily.
In the The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that “Approximately 1 in 5 (21.3% or an estimated 25.5 million) women in the U.S. reported completed or attempted rape at some point in their lifetime.” /1
Given that most sexual assaults and rapes go unreported these estimates are likely very low. /2
THREAD: Where men need to get to on #MeToo
In the The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that “Approximately 1 in 5 (21.3% or an estimated 25.5 million) women in the U.S. reported completed or attempted rape at some point in their lifetime.” /1
Globally, that number is much higher.
There are some men who will insist that these numbers are inflated. Some among us will debate how many millions of rapes are actually taking place. Is it actually fifteen million? Ten million? /2
What kind of culture of masculinity is capable of hosting a debate on rape framed in terms of how many millions are actually being raped, instead of how to stop it?
THREAD: Why I Primarily Track Other White Men as Threats
Our anxiety inducing culture of masculinity has always driven white men to bullying and violence. And it’s getting worse, the most damaged among us becoming white nationalists or mass shooters. medium.com/remaking-manho… /1
As a white man, I track other white men as the primary threat. They are the ones I watch to see if they are going spiral into anger, to bully, to lash out and hurt others. A lifetime spent around white boys/men taught me this. /2
And even as white cultural dominance is collapsing, even as our society is moving towards full diversity and inclusion, the threats and violence from some white men are getting worse, the most damaged among us becoming white nationalists or mass shooters. /3
The aggression playing out in social media is rooted in our culture of hierarchical, dominance-based masculinity, playing out minus the countervailing moderation found in personal interactions (we know you, we will see you again). In this way, social media is a Rorschach test. /1
Social media's lack of accountability, (very few face consequences) means that men and women, bullied and socialized into aligning with dominance culture use highly abusive language, mirroring their own abuse. In this way, social media reveals a persons level of early trauma. /2
This dangerous space allows people to calcify and express abusive racist and sexist frames in relative anonymity. Any remaining social restrictions dissipate. They are drawn to communities that mirror that language. It feels like belonging. /3