India's Vaccine Inequity - A Thread
On vaccination, the GoI has had to repeatedly eat crow. This is just another instance, despite the implied state-blaming in today's speech. The GoI must also withdraw the reservation of 25% doses for the private sector that is still in place
1/n Till 31 May 2021, India had covered only 12% of its population with at least one dose. Even by its own classification of vulnerability, only 43% of the 60+ age group had been partially vaccinated. Most of them in urban areas
2/n Of the 45-60 age group, only 25% have been given at least one dose. This is only 4% for the 18-44 age cohort. The variation across states persists. UP, BR, AS, and TN have covered less than 10% of their eligible populations. See figure for state-wise coverage till 31 May.
3/n Less than 60 million doses were administered in May 2021. At this rate -100% of eligible population will be covered only by August 2023. If 60% of monthly doses are first doses, it will be January 2023 till we cover the entire eligible population even partially (with 1 dose)
4/n BR, CG, JH, TL, UP will take more than 3 years to cover their entire population at current rate. To cover all eligible person by Dec 2021, as claimed by GoI, the monthly vaccination rate has to increase by 4 times from its current rate. It has to be 238 million doses/month
5/n GoI has claimed that this increase will happen. But vaccine production capacities, their actual supplies and availability are unknown and remain shrouded in opacity. Projected increases highly speculative and fantastical. See table.
6/n Shortage is likely to continue in the near future. Plans for increasing production and strategy for allocation and distribution have to be transparently communicated. All this remains a mystery even after today's speech.
7/n The 25% reserved doses for the private centres, is likely to further exacerbate existing inequities. An excelled report by @tabassum_b in the IE showed that 9 corporate hospital groups cumulatively bought 50% of the doses procured by private hospitals in May.
8/n "The balance 50 per cent of the vaccine stock was procured by 300-odd hospitals, located mostly in the country’s urban centres, with hardly any of them serving regions beyond the Tier-2 cities" indianexpress.com/article/india/…
9/n This inequality is seen across states. See figures for district-wise coverage of population (with at least 1 dose) in 4 states with the highest covid case loads - MH, KN, KL, and TN. Except in Kerala, distribution is inequitable.
10/n There is no alternative to UNIVERSAL FREE VACCINATION. We need: Efforts to increase production+ transparent and fair criteria of allocation to states+ local strategies to ensure equitable coverage +plan to maximize effectiveness since shortage is likely to last for a while.
@threadreaderapp please unroll
On vaccine inequity also see this excellent piece by @parthpunter ruralindiaonline.org/en/articles/wa…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tejal Kanitkar

Tejal Kanitkar Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @KanitkarT

12 May
THREAD ON THE ELUSIVE SECOND DOSE
1/n In the months of May and June, India will need to administer at least 125 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines as SECOND DOSES alone. If vaccine supplies are not augmented, many risk missing their second dose.
2/n As of 30th April, about 152 million vaccine doses had been administered, of which 82% were first doses. So from 1 May onwards, at least 125 million doses had to be reserved as second doses, to be administered in the months of May and June assuming a 8-9 week gap between doses
3/n Contrast this with the production capacity - According to the GoI's sworn affidavit to the Supreme Court, SII has a capacity to produce of 65 million doses/month. BBIL's capacity is 10 million doses/month.
Read 12 tweets
21 Apr
Thread On the Supply-Need Vaccination Gap: At the current rate of vaccination, this will happen only by November 2022. If India wishes to cover 60 to 100% of its eligible population by December 2021, the current gap between need and supply is about 70 to 170 million doses/month
1/n: 69% of India’s population is above 18 years of age in 2021, i.e. technically eligible for the COVID-19 Gap (as per estimates of the MoHFW). This varies between 60% in Bihar to 76% in Tamil Nadu.
2/n: To cover 100% of the eligible population India will need a total of 1878 million doses of the vaccine, assuming each person requires two doses. To cover 80% and 60% of the eligible population, this requirement reduces to 1502 million doses and 1127 million doses respectively
Read 19 tweets
9 May 20
Thread: What does "learning to live with COVID-19 mean? What percentages hide.
1/The "herd immunity" (not through vaccination) argument is making a comeback as people either get tired of the lock down or think HI the only way to save the economy.
2/Some may be genuinely worried about people dying of hunger because of the lock-down. But to argue for herd immunity so people don't die of hunger, is akin to cutting off one's nose to spite one's face. Here are some numbers that illustrate why:
3/It isn't yet clear whether immunity to COVID-19 is achieved after being infected, or the degree of that immunity, or it's longevity. But let us put that aside for now. For HI to kick in 60-70% of the population will have to be infected (could be higher also).
Read 12 tweets
6 Apr 20
Thread:
Those who are scoffing that "nothing went wrong with the grid yesterday" should be enormously thankful instead of smug. The POSOCO report on the PM's event yesterday evening shows quite clearly what an "unprecedented challenge" it was (their words not mine).
POSOCO had advised all regions to ensure that the black start units were in good condition. If that does not signal how worried they were, I don't know what will.
posoco.in/wp-content/upl…
The entire system through which supply is dispatched had to be modified.Generators with fast ramping capacities, i.e. hydro units, had to be used at full capacity at that time so their use at times otherwise advised (typically to manage peaks) was curtailed.
Read 5 tweets
3 Apr 20
According to the Saubhagya dashboard there are 21.3 crore households in India of which only 18,734 households are un-electrified. Which means 21.29 crore households use and pay for electricity. Assuming that 50% of all electrified households participate in the PM's call
Assuming 2 LED bulbs (to be conservative) will be shut for 9 mins in each households for this. Assuming average cost of energy to be Rs.2/kWh since many households using electricity for residential use may be paying BPL rates also.
This would mean a loss of Rs. 64 crore for the electricity utilities in just 9 minutes. Since this is only residential lighting demand, grid stability wont be an issue. @naukarshah since you asked. Bhakts of course will say this much money is okay to blind the virus or something
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(