Without looking it up,

What is Rt in Arkansas right now?
Rt is actually 1.2 (0.98-1.5). It is taking 12 days (4 generations) to double

here's some math

If Rt (aka Reff) was 5, it would mean that it would go up 5*5*5*5 = 625 TIMES in 12 days, not 2x

epiforecasts.io/covid/posts/su…
3/ Now, we aren't living in an R0 world. Even though it may feel like it sometimes

People are vaccinated (despite breakthrough infections)
People are infected (despite reinfection risk)
People have changed behaviors

But "Delta variant is as transmissible as Chicken Pox"(R0~9)??
4/ Let me blunt.

I think that's nonsense.

Delta is more infectious. Maybe it's 3.5 as initially estimated. Maybe it also has a shorter incubation period. Maybe it's as high as 5. That's bad enough.

it's not 9.
5/ The reason we are in another surge has as much to do with our shift in behaviors as it does in some "contagious as chickenpox" boogie man.

We snapped back too fast, when there were still not enough people vaccinated.

You know what tells me that?

RSV
6/ Last year, we saw a near complete suppression of respiratory viruses, including influenza and Respiratory Syncitial Virus (RSV).

But RSV is now back, off season, with a vengeance.

Took off, starting in April.

This isn't because there was a different covid variant
7/ So what's my takeaway from all this?

*Let's not be &^*ing fatalistic. Exponential growth at Rt 1.2 is a small nudge away from exponential decline with Rt <1.

That can be vaccinations, or behavior change, or by default, waiting for infections to get us there.
8/ If part of the upsurge is due to Delta having shorter incubation period and faster generation times, then that could mean an even smaller R0, and correspondingly quicker reversal of the surge, as we saw in the UK.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Farzad Mostashari

Farzad Mostashari Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Farzad_MD

31 Jul
1/ Here's another quiz for budding epidemiologists

The Guandong Delta outbreak was meticulously investigated. Initial report of 1000x viral load came from there

A finding that hasn't been discussed much is the seeming shorter incubation period (panel b)

virological.org/t/viral-infect…
2/ In 2021 delta it was only 3.7 days (vs 5.6 days for 2020 outbreak).

This would have an impact on a key transmission dynamic factor we often look for: "serial interval periods" (time between symptom onset for index case vs subsequent case in a contact tracing investigation)
3/ What you are trying to estimate from observable symptom intervals is underlying mean generation time.

tangent: If you find negative serial intervals as in COVID, it's a sign of asymptomatic and presymptomatic spread.
Read 6 tweets
30 Jul
1/ Like many others, I've been frustrated that we haven't seen the data behind the CDC's new recommendations. Parsing exact wording in transcripts is🤦

We're told there will be a release tomorrow but thanks to the @washingtonpost there's an internal CDC document to parse tonight
2/ The article by @yabutaleb7 @carolynyjohnson @JoelAchenbach is here:
washingtonpost.com/health/2021/07…

TY @bijans for spotting the "full pdf" download button.
3/ what do we learn?

The mysterious "other data" for high viral load in breakthrough cases came from a 4th of July outbreak in Provincetown (Barnstable, Mass) where the “vast majority” of the new cases were among fully vaccinated individuals

cc @zeynep
thehill.com/homenews/state…
Read 16 tweets
28 Jul
1/ What percent of vaccinated people who get infected with covid will have long-term symptoms?

I don't know, but I highly doubt that it's 19%.

Here's why I say that, and what the *right* study design would be for answering that question.
2/ when I was an Epidemic Intelligence Service Officer at the CDC, I investigated lots of outbreaks, and every one would have a symptom checklist

A surprisingly high number of people with a diagnosed infection will say YES to a variety of symptoms

Fatigue?
Headache?
Fogginess?
3/ many of these reported complaints would have absolutely nothing to do with their infection.

But recall bias is super powerful, and respondents often feel like they're supposed to say "yes". So they do.
Read 7 tweets
7 Jul
1/ Our national quality/value program (MACRA) is broken

Most people just complain about its shortcomings, but @Travis_Broome comes up with an elegant, grounded way to fix its biggest flaws

Apply behavioral economics, use virtual groups, lay path to APMs ajmc.com/view/macra-has…
2/ MACRA was a true milestone, and a concept that I still support- instead of artificially capping medical inflation (and then not having the guts to actually see doc pay cuts) lets create 2 paths- a "pay for performance" base and an incentivized alternative payment model track.
3/ But 3 seemingly technical details fundamentally sapped the potential impact of this huge bill.

classic behavioral economics- the impact of an incentive is not just proportional to its size, but also its cost, uncertainty, and delay

MACRA stunk on all counts here.
Read 14 tweets
19 May
1/ "Federal antitrust oversight has proved inadequate at preventing anticompetitive effects across the health care sector" per @commonwealthfnd

What else can the federal government do, given the difficulty of passing healthcare legislation?

Plenty.
commonwealthfund.org/blog/2021/fede…
2/ in this article, Joseph Kannarkat and I break down all the tools that the Biden administration and @SecBecerra have to address competition beyond antitrust reviews

jamanetwork.com/journals/jama-…
3/ first of all, if the Biden administration chooses to elevate health care competition as a priority, it may garner rare bipartisan support.

This is an issue that has support from left (@ZekeEmanuel) and right (@Avik) thought leaders and legislators.
Read 8 tweets
11 Apr
1/ in our continued COVID field epidemiology series

"What's the question?"

April 2021 edition: "Are the vaccines effective against the variants?"

We have wet lab data, (limited) clinical trials reports, but what about field epi?

What epi design/surveillance would answer it?
2/ Why do I think it's "The Question" of this moment for field epi to try to answer?

I'm going to be joining @Bob_Wachter @cmyeaton @inthebubblepod tomorrow in our continuing "Safe or Not Safe" series, and Variant vs Vaccine will make all the difference

3/ I am 100% certain that everything I am saying here is much better understood by city/state epidemiologists @CSTEnews and @CDCgov experts.

But they are too busy to tweet, aren't free to talk openly, and may not control their own work/ resources.

And that's exactly the problem
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(