All the mistakes were made in Afghanistan are being repeated re China.

1. We are blindly following the US in order to ‘make them like us’. By doing so we both empower them to pursue a reckless unilateral policy, and lose our chance to be a moderating influence.
2. We are (ostensibly) trying to influence domestic policy of a sovereign country (Human Rights) by threatening their sovereignty, and dropping bombs on them.
We have no workable plan except propaganda, and sending lots and lots of military hardware into the region which will then (magically) kill ‘the bad guys’ if they don’t do what we want, but spare the ‘women and girls’
Despite or claims for being motivated by high morals and democracy, the execution of our plan will involve bribery of officials, allying ourselves with anyone, no matter how odious who is not ‘them’, torture, and murder.
Despite the plan being no more advanced than a caveman ambush, it will receive universal support from the major media outlets, and the fact that we are going ‘backwards’ will be covered up by both military leaders, politicians and media. Everything will be painted as ‘success’.
We will actually achieve the opposite of a claimed goal, because (just as in our own country) attacks by enemies don’t destabilise the reigning Govt; they act to entrench it. All our sabre rattling will make the CCP stronger. Our propaganda will backfire, showing us as liars.
All efforts at diplomacy and reason will be ridiculed as ‘appeasement’, no matter how credible their makers are. Dissenters will be hated, silenced and if they persist, jailed.
When the truth about why we are really there becomes apparent over time (to help ourselves not the people we claim to be ‘saving’) even the locals will come to hate us and see as only as ‘foreign occupation forces’. They will frequently give their lives to attack us.
After 20 (or maybe 200) years of bloody conflict leaving a million dead, we will leave, blaming the Taiwanese, or Uighurs for ‘not helping themselves’ and establishing the CCP as ‘saviours of the country from a foreign invasion’
To add insult to injury, after we leave the ruined country we will refuse visas to anyone that helped us, claiming we can’t trust them that they aren’t ‘terrorists’ who want to harm us. If they try to come they will be out in jail, along with the dissenters of this ‘Great War’
We will give out medals for dubious actions (we won’t fact check good news stories) and give positions of honour to military leaders who completely failed in their duty to actually do the right thing by the nation, as opposed to Govt. ‘Yes Men and Women’ only will be promoted.
Any questioning of Govt policy will be met with either personal attacks on the speaker, or drowned out with emotional but empty slogans such ‘what about the Chinese women and girls’ ‘rights for Muslims’ ‘Freedom!’ ‘Human Rights’
Whichever party is the most belligerent will be elected. There will be more spending on polling and advertising than planning.

Within a year on two of the disastrous campaign ending, another will be talked up. There will be no accountability for strategic failure.
A few people who make aircraft, missiles, and concrete shelters will be very wealthy.

We will hold lavish funerals for our dead, but shrug our shoulders at the mention of the thousands more killed by our bombs as simply the ‘price of freedom’

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with David McBride

David McBride Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MurdochCadell

20 Sep
These guys were Afghan Special Forces drawn from the Hazara population, who, as the descendants of Genghis Khan’s invaders, were both a distinct racial and religious group (Shia). They were fearless and effective.
It demonstrates our duplicity as allies however that despite our claims of ‘steadfast brothers in arms’ we not only abandoned them but won’t allow them to emigrate to Australia.
Many of them will die at the hands of the Taliban (they are instantly recognisable), and many have already drowned trying to get to Australia in leaky boats.
Read 5 tweets
18 Sep
Ironically, by provoking a war with China that was never necessary we risk creating a situation we claim to be preventing.

Like giving into any overblown fear, it’s the inability to control our fear that causes the outcome, nor the actual danger.
Just as our twenty year war to ‘rid the world of the Taliban’ actually made them stronger and more entrenched than ever.
Our war in the 1960s and 1970s to stop the spread of Communism in Vietnam?
Read 7 tweets
14 Sep
I woke (even earlier) this morning and I’m in a mischievous mood, so I’ll give my supporters something to laugh about in these ‘difficult times’ with this thread

1/7
Many of my haters still proclaim:
“You shouldn’t have leaked to the ABC, and should have let Defence internal mechanisms sought things out! (traitor!)’

(Apart from this demonstrating a complete ignorance of the facts of my case) I’ll give you a quote from my book:

2/7
‘I was faced with a stark reality. Our ‘heroes’ often weren’t heroes. Our villains often weren’t villains. Our claimed justification for the war were lies, and our claimed ‘progress’ was simply a lie made each year…
Read 8 tweets
14 Sep
Role models can appear when you least expect it. For all the great and good you meet at University this man was a stand-out. Percy Lewis emigrated to Britain from Trinidad and joined the RAF.
He eventually became a pro boxer, and bookmaker, but possibly his greatest achievement was changing people’s lives. He spent about 40 years coaching the Oxford Boxing team. He never his a training or raised his voice, but also never taken for granted.
Few people that came in contact with him didn’t revere him. His boxing weight was around 58 kgs, yet I don’t remember him ever not being the ‘biggest person’ in the room.
Read 4 tweets
22 Aug
The US Govt paints itself as ‘The West Wing’ but in reality it’s ‘The Sopranos’.
But less likeable.
If Trump wants to ‘go back’, the US should let him. He can take Bush, Cheney, Petraus and Pompeo with him.

They can show the world how good they are with ‘geopolitics’.
If there is going to be an Afghan War re-match, it’s only fair that the Washington Suits, and armchair experts fight it.

Soldiers have suffered enough at the hands of idiotic politicians and NeoCons whose only experience of Asia is fighting over a bill in a Lebanese restaurant
Read 4 tweets
11 Jun
Ben Roberts-Smith claims being awarded the VC in 2010 made him a target for ‘jealous people’.

But the first time it was alleged he murdered a child was three years before in 2007.

BRS claimed his accuser was ‘weak and hopeless’.

But only after the accusation was made.
Ben Roberts-Smith twice changed his story about what happened in 2007, claiming there were two boys, and they were armed. Before ‘remembering the truth’

BRS put it down to a mistake of memory.

But he had been awarded a Medal of Gallantry for that day. You’d remember that.
The above facts were in a book by one of Australia’s most respected journalists who spent years researching it.

They have never been challenged.
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(