1/ Thoughts on the emergency #bced COVID-19 briefing, called by #DrBonnieHenry & @JM_Whiteside on Oct. 1, 2021, after 3 major districts mandated masks for K-Gr. 3…
Whereas BC has no ventilation document at all. Just a page in their “Communicable Disease Guidelines for K-12 Settings”, August 24, 2021.
Link: www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/edu…
Compare the language used, Ontario to BC. Whose is closer to #COVIDisAirborne science?🤯
1/ To @JM_Whiteside:
You are in a highly-charged position right now.
What to do about #bced schools?
- delta v 📈
- K-Gr.6 kids unvaxxed
- crowded classrms
On one hand, you have parents clamouring for more safety. On the other, “back-to-normal”.
Let’s talk about balance.
🧵⬇️:
2/ “Balance” is the term that seems to persist in @bcndp’s pandemic response. It hasn’t gone well so far. Multiple waves, highly preventable, w/ premature openings & late masking being a common theme.
But do we “balance” our approach to other harmful health hazards?
3/ Take smoking, for example. We tried “non-smoking vs. smoking” sections in restaurants & airplanes. But now harms of second-hand smoke have led to laws *banning all indoor smoking & outdoors by public entrances.
Do we “balance” the “right to smoke” w/ “right to clean air?” No!
July 29, 2020. @bcndp@DrBonnieHenry reveal the 5-stage reopening plan for #bced. Surprise! Stage 2 has been revamped to include a FULL return to classes; no 50% capacity for G.8-12 as previously planned. Cohort model, no masks, limited online options. @bctf not consulted.
There are immediate concerns with the #bced plan for the 20/21 school year. Twitter explodes with teachers, staff & parents noting several issues with it. Many concerns are summarized in this article here:
What if @bcndp@CDCofBC are approaching this pandemic all wrong?
Drs Henry & Gustafson say fear of “stigma” is the reason for not releasing data.
Boom. There it is. The underlying driving force behind many #Covid19BC decisions.
But does it have to be this way?
A thread:
1/
Attaching stigma to an illness is a social construct. That means we have control over whether we do that or not.
There are many illnesses, even communicable ones, that have no stigma attached. Flu, colds, chicken pox, measles.
No one is “at fault” for catching/spreading.
2/
We also have illnesses where stigma *has* been attached. The HIV virus comes to mind. And that stigma proved to be damaging in so many ways. It’s taken many years of activism to reduce the stigma there.
How is it that public health has not learned from that experience?
3/
BC media, please understand why #bced feels abandoned by DBH’s “Be Kind, Be Calm, Be Safe” slogan.
If DBH was KIND to school communities by listening to concerns & working to make schools SAFER, we would be CALM. But she has ignored evidence and gaslit us instead.
A thread:
First: DBH claims that “in-school transmission is low” and that school cases “reflect the community”.
Yet several studies have proven otherwise.
Study 1) Montreal study, explained by 🇨🇦 epidemiologist:
Study 2) Belgian study shows much higher prevalence in young children, once they started testing schools more (catching previously-missed asymptomatic cases).
New Z epidemiologist reports: