The movement to bring #CO2 sensors to school empowers parents, students, & teachers to advocate for their health; Reveals invisible factors of air quality & helps see how well ventilation is matched to room activity.
2/ If you are able to buy or borrow a CO2 sensor, stick it in the mesh water bottle pocket of your kid's backpack, pin into their shorts, or send in their lunchbox. Be creative. Make sure it isn't sealed away; the more airflow the better the reading.
3/ A key goal of #COVIDCO2 monitoring is to understand how well ventilation is matched to room activity & occupancy. Share the data with your school. If CO2 rises above 800 ppm, interventions needed to reduce build-up of aerosol & risk.
4/ In particular, scroll to point 9 (CO2 monitoring) on the #CDC page on Ventilation in Buildings under their COVID guidance.
"If unable to get below 800 ppm, increased reliance on enhanced air filtration (including HEPA air cleaners) will be necessary." cdc.gov/coronavirus/20…
5/ The main source of CO2 indoors is either combustion (flames) or people exhaling. So if CO2 is building up, you can assume the invisible respiratory aerosols are too.
6/ Gathering CO2 data is often discouraged, however: “It’s possible that the school district may not be all that happy with this because I think it gives us a window into the fact that they may not actually be treating ventilation as seriously as they should be,” Dr. Huffman said
7/ As @EmilyAnthes points out in the NY Times article above, many parents have seen backlash against sending CO2 monitors. Some of those brief parent stories are here:
8/ I've been encouraging parents who want to send a CO2 sensor with a child to make sure they don't push a child past their comfort zone. Make sure the sensor won't be a distraction during the day. And it's important that the parent, not the student, bear the responsibility.
9/ There are lots of creative ways that people have been using as they send CO2 monitors:
10/ Once you've collected your data, make sure to share using the hashtag #COVIDCO2 and peruse for further ideas & support (Thx @mdc_martinus!). Some have also used #SchoolCO2.
12/ Several sites allow people to share their CO2 data for the public to see. For example, see the site put together by @ariccio or the work that @SchoolAQFund is now beginning.
13/ I've gotten a lot of question about what CO2 sensor to buy. I use the #Aranet4 sensor extensively, but at ~$200+, it's not cheap.
[Aranet coupon: naltic.com/aranet4coupon.…]
15/ This is a summary of a somewhat more technical perspective on using CO2 as a proxy for airborne viral aerosol risk indoors, with great additional info gathered by @jljcolorado:
16/One way to think about indoor CO2 concentrations is to consider the "rebreathed fraction". For every ~400 ppm above the baseline (usually also ~400 ppm), 1% of your air is '#rebreathed' from someone else's exhaled air. E.g. via @CorsIAQ:
“More specifically, clinic employees did not monitor storage unit temperatures for vaccines at all times and failed to use equipment and practices that comply with guidance from the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the news release said.”
“It is unclear if the Colorado Medical Board, which regulates doctors and other licensed health providers, or any other state or federal agency will take action against Dr. Moma clinic leaders.”
2/ Given that N95 supply has been reported fine for months, strange the CDC article comment was that “CDC continues to recommend that N95 respirators should be prioritized for protection against COVID-19 in healthcare settings”
Preprint: "Echoes Through Time: The Historical Origins of the Droplet Dogma & its Role in the Misidentification of Airborne Respiratory Infection Transmission"
3/ If you want to digest aspects of the story in deeper form, spoon-fed via Twitter thread, this is a long 🧵 that @jljcolorado put together in May along similar lines:
Well, imagine my shock that school districts in Colorado requiring masks have lower COVID transmission. How much lower if they also used good ventilation, HEPA filters, outdoor lunch, etc. (1/x)
2/ @CDPHE data via @johningold showing COVID cases for school-age kids in #Colorado districts w/ mask mandates (blue) are lower than those w/o mandates (orange). Yellow bar shows in-person school return.
But 6-17 yr cases very different at county level, so these wrap together.
3/ More data from @CDPHE via @johningold. Overall, COVID cases in 0-5 & 6-11 yrs age groups (no vax approval yet) still hovering near their peak levels as a Colorado state average.
🔥 by @DrAliceVirgil1 in @PsychToday. She argues indoor school meals are not only dangerous during COVID, but further destabilize a sense of truth and reality among gaslit students.
2/ "The term gaslighting comes from the 1944 film Gaslight ... invalidating her reality and understanding of her experiences."
"Trust in the person or entity doing the gaslighting is essential for it to be an effective tool to undermine a person’s entire perception of reality."
3/ "Yet, every day in countless lunchrooms across America, as both the New York and Chicago school districts have noted, children are eating and talking loudly, unmasked, in crowded indoor spaces without proper ventilation."