I've watched with growing disgust as the intolerant right-wing, and increasingly the militant left, seize on any cause and identity to attack Justin Trudeau and the Liberal Party. It isn't the criticism that offends me, it's the coopting of identity and issues. #cdnpoli 1/9
Whether it's blackface, Indigenous rights, women's issues, or anything really, Twitter trolls and even ordinary activists seem to discover deep wells of concern for identities they don't share, and issues they've never cared about, whenever some opportunity presents. #cdnpoli 2/9
Like I said, it's disgusting. Beyond disgusting, really. Whatever the issue may be, it isn't improved by being flung gleefully around by idiots who are milking someone else's pain, someone else's identity, and talking over someone else's voice in a public debate. #cdnpoli 3/9
I've restrained myself, with difficulty, for a long time. Because I don't share these identities either. Yes, I'm cis, white, male, and majoritarian in most ways. The fact that concern trolls are counting on my silence doesn't change that my silence is called for. #cdnpoli 4/9
Here's the thing. My family died in the Holocaust. My direct relations. That's my identity. And I am sick and fucking tired of seeing people milk Chrystia Freeland's grandfather's history, whatever it may be, to throw the word "Nazi" around like it's nothing. #cdnpoli 5/9
Actual God damn Nazis killed my family. Rounded them up, put them in concentration camps, then in gas chambers. This isn't a jab to throw for political gain. It's real history. And it's mine, not yours. If you can't understand that, what the hell is wrong with you? #cdnpoli 6/9
I don't believe Freeland, or anyone, is responsible for what their grandparents did. We need to confront the past honestly, to move towards healing and reconciliation. We can learn a lot from First Nations on how to approach this. This crap on twitter isn't that. #cdnpoli 7/9
This is my identity, finally. And I feel exactly how I've always assumed everyone else must feel. It's more offensive to have my identity turned into a punchline than anything else. If I don't have a problem with Freeland, who are you to have a problem on my behalf? #cdnpoli 8/9
If you're trying to an ally, be an ally and let the people you're trying to support do the talking. It isn't easy, I know. If you just want the political debate, restrain yourself, please. And if you really don't care at all - I suspect most don't - just go to hell. #cdnpoli 9/9

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jeff Rybak🍁

Jeff Rybak🍁 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JeffRybak

8 Oct
Recently, I added some criticism to the pile on Jagmeet Singh, for his announcement of the NDP's intentions in the coming term. I believe the criticism was warranted, but also deserves nuance. So here's what I really think about the NDP and what needs to change. #cdnpoli 1/12
First, let's acknowledge the NDP are in a tough spot. Justin Trudeau is leading a big-spending, left-leaning Liberal government - unlikely to offer any plans or legislation the NDP really opposes. The NDP may want more and to go farther but that's a different issue. #cdnpoli 2/12
When the NDP threaten to abstain it's no threat at all. Remove 25 NDP votes and there are 313 votes remaining. Of those the 160 Liberals are a majority. The NDP can't stop anything by abstaining. The only real threat is to vote against things they mainly agree with. #cdnpoli 3/12
Read 12 tweets
11 Apr
The Covid pandemic is a dress rehearsal for challenges that await us in the near-term future, notably climate change, population expansion, ballooning wealth inequality and more. Mostly we've failed - not everywhere and in all ways. But we haven't done well. #onpoli #cdnpoli 1/10
The good news is that we've rediscovered our ability to make rapid, large-scale changes when needed. Many things seem impossible until they really need to happen. Previous generations - anyone who lived through a war - knew what's possible. Now we know too. #onpoli #cdnpoli 2/10
The bad news is even in response to temporary changes and sacrifices, selfishness kicks in far too early - particularly in wealthy, western nations. For every act of heroism and compassion, there have been petty, selfish, and stupid acts in counterbalance. #onpoli #cdnpoli 3/10
Read 10 tweets
6 Feb
I have a confession to make about Universal Basic Income (#UBI). I'm late to the party and was initially very skeptical. It's not because I don't believe in the research or the important equity issues. I just thought people couldn't swallow it. I let cynicism win. #cdnpoli 1/12
As a double confession, I felt the same way about legalizing marijuana. I thought well, of course I support it. Makes good sense on many levels. But it's too hard to sell. People won't get it. Basically, I succumbed to the dark side of centrism. #UBI #cdnpoli 2/12
The pitch for #UBI is complex. It goes far beyond issues of social justice and equity. Of course common decency alone says we should allow everyone dignity, inclusion, and stability. But it isn't just about being nice and fair. It's also good social policy. #cdnpoli 3/12
Read 12 tweets
3 Feb
A few days ago I wrote at length about how wealth inequality is the defining issue of our time - undermining our ability to solve every other problem. It was well-received, but several people asked what to do about it. So I'll attempt a follow-up reply. #cdnpoli 1/10
There's no single solution to inequality in society, just as there's no single cause of it. What we need is a variety of measures aimed at stopping the slide in one direction, and nudging it back on a trajectory pointed the right way again. So here's a short list. #cdnpoli 2/10
A tax on actual wealth to start, and not just income. We're on track to see trillionaires in a few decades. That's insane. No one needs so much personal wealth that every descendant of theirs for 26 generations never needs to work. No one. #cdnpoli 3/10
Read 10 tweets
1 Feb
It's still too early to invite post-Covid deconstruction of what Covid really means, beyond many families suffering losses, massive disruptions in our lives, isolation, etc. But this latest snowbird controversy has pushed me to it. We need to talk about privilege. #cdnpoli 1/12
The widening gap in economic reality is the defining issue of our time. "We're in this together" isn't just a Covid slogan. It's the binding promise of society. As long as it's true, we can act together to solve our problems. When it stops being true, we're screwed. #cdnpoli 2/12
The only way we all have an equal stake in society is if we all have a fair chance to enjoy its rewards. And that's the promise, isn't it? Work hard, do well, dash of luck, and you too can be one of the winners. Even if you started from behind. Pull yourself up. #cdnpoli 3/12
Read 12 tweets
31 Jan
Far better informed people than me have commented on the actual winners and losers associated with #GameStop and the #RedditArmy attack on the stock market (see @StephenPunwasi to start) but what fascinates me is the political angle. Which is real, but also completely absent. 1/9
This incredible movement of dollars, headlines, and memes is fundamentally driven by frustration with elites winning endlessly in a game perceived to be rigged. Leaving aside whether the response is productive or destructive, the motivating force is clear, pure, and real. 2/9
This movement has been compared to everything from Trump-inspired insurrectionists to violent Antifa activists. Such comparisons, from every side, are unfair and miss the point. Because this movement hasn't taken any side politically and hasn't come close to breaking any law. 3/9
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(