Per previous thread: I don't use "elite" pejoratively anymore than I use "grassroots" positively. "Elite" describes those in a community w/ greater access to $, education, & opportunity. "Grassroots" means those who have significantly less. Of course, neither is monolithic.
Unlike some, I don't rage against social hierarchies mostly b/c I think they're unlikely to change. Different hierachies just replace each other--this is the human condition. What I do expect is that those w/ more will act responsibly toward those w/ less.
Unfortunately, class groups are increasingly isolated from each other. Neighborhoods are not integrated & elites cluster together. This sets up a "Who is my neighbor?" conundrum that catches good, well-intentioned people.
I honestly don't think it's wrong for elites to converse amongst themselves about the best way to live faithfully as an elite. How do you use your resources to love others well? How do you use your unique opportunities to benefit the most? How should you use your education?
That most of us can't imagine being privy to such conversations is precisely the point. Unfortunately, we're so class blind in the US that *all* of us think we're engaging in the same conversation when, in fact, we're not.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
So I think I finally figured out why the Babylon Bee is so funny to some people & completely unfunny to others. More often than not, the BB isn't satire; it's sarcasm.
Satire takes a more objective posture, poking fun in a way that reveals foolishness but isn't necessarily interpersonal. Sarcasm, OTOH, is *primarily* interpersonal b/c the joke depends on the reader having a shared (negative) emotional perspective.
In satire, everyone can laugh b/c even if a joke pinches, it's not about the person so much as the foolish/funny behavior. But sarcasm is laden w/ interpersonal & emotional baggage & as a result will only be funny to those who already share similar frustrations.
Do you all know of Christian colleges that meet need? Not "help you get loans to afford it" or "apply for this competitive scholarship" but actually prorate tuition to match FAFSA expected family contribution?
In unrelated news, my daughter is a senior & we're in full swing of college mailers/applications, etc. It's been fascinating to see how different schools approach financial aid & who their target student is.
E.g. One flier from a Xian school advertised itself via 3 main bullet points:
>95% career outcome rate
>alumni earnings top 12%
>#X Best Career Services Office Nationally
The accompanying text was about the value of studying in community with others who share your values.
Good addition to the conversation about "evangelical elites" HOWEVER... I want to share a brief observation about this conversation from the grassroots
I live btwn 2 worlds. I've spent majority of my entire life in the working class but have a college degree & write for mid-upper class readers. I grew up poor & have lived on small church pastor's salary for 15+ years. But I've also traveled the world & move in academic circles.
For years, I taught conferences Fri-Sat in mid-upper class churches only to fly home to worship on Sunday at my rural church of >100. I've spoken at international conferences while some of my neighbors have never seen the ocean. (We can talk about imposter syndrome later.)
I think it's important to remember that hospitals are full b/c we have the ability to save people from an otherwise horrific death. They are full b/c modern medicine has kept patients alive long enough to have a chance to continue to live.
This must be factored into all our discussions about mandates & safety. Because, even if unconsciously, we are already factoring it into the risk/reward calculus of resisting such protocols. But this is not a freedom shared by those in the developing world.
Which helps us evaluate our own calculus--not of risk & reward--but of rights & responsibilities. What responsibilities do we have *because* we have access to lifesaving modern medicine when others don't?
Just left a comment on a FB post related to COVID vax. Saints, pray for me.
BUT on a related note... someone needs to look into how class divides are affecting people's confidence in vaccines. It's not about "trusting the science" so much as whether you know people you trust who are doing the science.
If you exist in a socioeconomic class that includes doctors, chemists, researchers, clinicians etc, you're more likely to have personal proximity to someone whose work you trust b/c you trust them.