🧵🧵
1/ While two-dose vaccine series have been shown to remain exceptionally protective against #covid19 disease, especially in younger age cohorts — we know that vaccine effectiveness against #SARSCoV2 infection has decreased.

Booster doses can help reduce onward transmission.
2/ As I think about this more, this is especially important for the many immunocompromised patients that we are treating as healthcare providers.

These are patients in whom vaccines don’t work quite as well to induce an immune response.
3/ Similarly, reducing transmission to children is an important goal, even if it deserves examination of many trade-offs.

The best way as of now to protect kids is to minimize risk of transmission from adults. Vaccines are one part of that equation.
4/ In addition, many remain unvaccinated. The best way to protect them is to vaccinate them— but the second best is to ensure that those around them are vaccinated.

These “unvaccinated people” are still loved ones like mothers/fathers- protecting them is still important.
5/ Reducing overall infections in the community is important also because we are still trying to understand the longer term risks of getting mild or asymptomatic infections.

This last point I think is harder to defend largely bc CoV2 will not be eradicated and..
6/ everyone will likely have exposure at some point— this is the reality of a virus that transmits this well.

But — we can still continue to prevent severe disease.

And there are many new therapeutics & prophylactics on the way.

Buying time is still important.
7/ While not the focus of this thread, I can’t talk about boosters without talking about vaccine inequity.

I really do think it is a zero sum game more than many are acknowledging.

Saying that doses will never reach other countries is becoming a lazy argument…
8/ Especially when it isn’t coupled with any possible solutions as to how we can change that situation moving forward. I fear that the reason these solutions aren’t being considered is bc of complacency that we can keep boosting/ protecting ourselves here in the US indefinitely.
9/ I want to acknowledge that boosters will play an important role in reducing community transmission.

They are not the only way to do this.

& they also present a $$ opportunity for pharma that may disincentivize trying to get first 💉💉 to other places instead for less profit.
10/ More organized thoughts on these many moving parts coming out soon.

//

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Abraar Karan

Abraar Karan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @AbraarKaran

15 Oct
1/ It's difficult to study #SARSCoV2 transmission in the real world bc of many confounders

In our study of hospital roommates, we studied this in a relatively controlled setting

We found that the virus transmits efficiently beyond 6 feet & despite a curtain in between roommates
2/ We were examining a number of cases that turned positive but whose initial tests were negative (so early incubation period) so they were roomed with other patients in shared rooms

This allowed us to explore a window into exposure when index cases are most infectious
3/ We found that for those with cycle threshold values <=21 (meaning high viral load), 11/18 transmitted to their roommate (61%)

Roommates are 7 feet apart (head to head in bed) with a solid curtain in between

If transmission was primarily droplets, we wouldn't expect this
Read 13 tweets
12 Oct
1/ There have been so many propositions of “if we just do x y z, the pandemic would be over”

Far fewer have dug deeply into why x, y, z is never actually done

Namely how our political, public health, & economic systems are not designed to ensure x, y, z gets done
2/ This matters because it can become another form of gaslighting

Proposing ideas without any means of them being executed & then sticking by those ideas anyways

“Focused protections” was one version of this
3/ In theory it was a good idea to protect older people (although never a good idea to let the young get sick)

But there was little to no attention as to how this would actually have been implemented

And no accountability when that plan did not hold up to scrutiny
Read 6 tweets
10 Oct
1/ At our hospital we use airborne precautions if someone has active #Covid19 infection

We did at my previous hospital too

Because the virus is airborne

And we wear N95 masks

Because it’s airborne
2/ Hospitals have better ventilation

They have better masks

They have better testing

They have all the protections that are needed to prevent transmission of the virus

(& still have nosocomial outbreaks)
3/ And in hospitals we are often seeing patients when they are even less contagious than they were when they’re in the community or in their homes

Yet we have done far less to prevent community spread esp before vaccines were available
Read 5 tweets
24 Sep
A few things on my mind
🧵🧵
1)
-#SARSCoV2 is spread by aerosols at short and long range— not sure why there is still debate about this. Seeing tweets from Canada that this is still up in the air- no pun intended cc @DFisman @kprather88 @linseymarr
2)
-global vaccine equity is an afterthought for rich countries; this is exactly how we thought this would go— for pharma, it’s about $$ & always was. Charity won’t solve this issue. It’s a structural problem cc @ThomasPogge @amymaxmen @RanuDhillon @rajpanjabi
3)
Boosting fully vaccinated folks w/ mild co-morbidities won’t stop the epidemic here — fully vaxx’d transmitting much less

Need to vaccinate the unvaxx’d— still far too many holding out cc @MonicaGandhi9 @Craig_A_Spencer
Read 5 tweets
20 Sep
From @linseymarr excellent piece in @IDSAInfo CID journal, re transmission of respiratory viruses

"This dichotomy overlooks the reality that respiratory droplets of all sizes, incl aerosols, are most concentrated close to the source (i.e., the infected individual) and that..."
"exposure at all but uncomfortably close distances is dominated by inhalation rather than the impaction of large droplets that are sprayed onto mucous membranes"

Why does this all matter? Because functionally it changes the type of protection that is most needed
And it is critical to acknowledge that there has a been a paradigm shift on this topic.

At my old stomping grounds @BrighamWomens our excellent infection prevention team shifted their views over time, as more evidence emerged that short-range aerosols contributed the most
Read 8 tweets
18 Sep
1/ At the FDA meeting— the topic of global vaccine equity was pushed away as an irrelevant consideration to their decision making

This is reflective of a deeper problem— wealthy countries truly believe they can win if they just continue to protect themselves
2/ while the US is going to be purchasing “hundreds of millions” more doses to donate— winning a pandemic that hinges on the generosity or altruism of wealthy countries w/ histories of exploitation is problematic & likely short lived.

washingtonpost.com/health/2021/09…
3/ The global vaccine supply issue & need for more decentralized production + technology transfers for scale up is likely the most urgent global dilemma facing the world.

Is it being regarded with the same level of urgency?

It doesn’t seem or feel like it but hard to say
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(