Five things you need to know about today's Budget/SR. Do read my full analysis if/when you have time. It's in this link. But if you're pressed here's the quick 1,2,3,4,5: news.sky.com/story/sunaks-b…
1. The forecast contained some BIG changes: much higher growth. Look how much higher the dark blue line here is than the yellow line (last forecast). Also much higher inflation forecasts. This has a bearing on the fiscal numbers, so... Image
2. The Chancellor got a MASSIVE windfall thanks to these forecast changes. Higher growth/inflation both push up net tax receipts. Roughy £35bn a year each year, thanks to higher tax receipts (even after the extra cost of benefits/debt interest). That is a LOT of money.
Here's another way of looking at it.
Light blue bars = impact of OBR forecast changes, bringing LOTS of money into govt.
Dark blue = policy decisions (mostly spending review).
Look how much bigger the light blue bits (money in) are than the dark blue bits (money out), meaning... Image
3. @RishiSunak pocketed the majority of the windfall.
Let's add a line showing the net impact on borrowing of this windfall vs Budget decisions equation.
Look at the black line. Borrowing down in every year, a lot. Is Sunak saving this money for a rainy (election) day? Image
4. In terms of new fiscal decisions TODAY, this Budget was a bit of a damp squib. This graphic breaks down ALL next year's Budget decisions for you. The striking thing: most of this was announced last month.
Really only a few billion of these policies were new. Image
This is not to suggest the policies today were insignificant. The decision to change the UC taper rate in particular feels like a big move. But it's tiny, fiscally, compared with the announcement on health last month.
Again, this won't come as a surprise, but worth noting the size of the UK tax burden, now def heading for the highest sustained level in most of the post-war period: Image
Anyway, the number 5 thing you need to know about today? It was not a green budget. If anything it was an anti-green Budget. The net impact of freezing fuel duty and cutting Air Passenger Duty will almost certainly be to raise emissions, not lower them, ceteris paribus.
One can entirely understand why the Chancellor has done this. Why penalise motorists when they're facing the highest prices on record? But coming the very week ahead of COP29, a summit all about turning environmental promises into actions, it is jarring, to say the least.
Anyway, as I say, do read my full analysis, which you can find on the @SkyNews website, or watch our coverage tonight. Lots from me, @BethRigby and the whole team on everything Budget related. If you can stomach any more... news.sky.com/story/sunaks-b…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ed Conway

Ed Conway Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @EdConwaySky

27 Oct
Half an hour left til Budget. Here are a few nuggets to ponder. Let’s start with a claim @RishiSunak may make (tho am hoping he doesn’t): that UK is fastest growing economy in G7.
It’s true if u look at Q2 alone (chart 1).
But look at GDP since covid and UK is mid/low table (ch2) ImageImage
There’ll be lots of talk about fiscal responsibility and keeping the public finances in order.
All very well but by far the biggest issue in the coming decades is health-related costs which massively outweigh net zero. What does this govt do in the face of that? Image
After all, this govt has already set aside a large slug of the extra spending review money to health. The real question is what happens to other depts. Do they get real terms Budget increases? Does the era of austerity live on in certain corners of Whitehall? Image
Read 9 tweets
26 Oct
🧵Few things to look out for in tomo’s Budget/Spending Review.
First, economic growth forecasts
They will almost certainly be raised - but by how much?
As you can see we are already running above the levels forecast in Mar. But when if ever do we get back to trend (dotted line)?
Given it’s a Budget we’ll doubtless have more taxes. But actually most of the action on this front has already happened. The Corp tax and NICs increases represent the biggest combined tax increase since the early 1990s. Seems unlikely anything tomo will change this big picture
It’s already been leaked that @RishiSunak will freeze fuel duty.
One can understand the rationale given soaring petrol costs.
But it’s a v hard one to square with govt’s green pledges. This is the UK’s biggest green tax!
Read 13 tweets
20 Oct
OK that’s enough cross-country comparisons. How is the situation in the UK re cases, admissions and deaths? These charts tell some of that story. In short, the vaccines seem to be doing their job. Back in the late 2020 wave, look how correlated those lines were. Not any more.
I say the “vaccines are working”. But hang on: in that case why are even more vaccinated people dying of COVID now than unvaccinated people?
The answer comes back to CONTEXT, which is all-important here. Consider the latest data from English hospitals… assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/upl…
In the most recent period (13 Sept - 10 Oct) there were 2,805 Covid deaths in this database.
2,136 of them were fully-vaccinated.
Only 557 of were unvaccinated people (NB by unvaccinated I mean no doses at all).
Easy to assume from that the vaccines aren’t working. But hold on
Read 16 tweets
20 Oct
I really REALLY didn’t want to have to do another Covid thread. Really. But given the numbers are on the rise - along with the inevitable hot takes (we’re heading for disaster! The vaccines aren’t working!), I’m dipping my toe back in the waters. Hopefully not for long. 🧵
Let’s start with this chart. You’ve prob seen it elsewhere. This Scary Chart shows that the UK’s COVID situation looks UNIQUELY terrible. Just look at that red line compared with other countries!
But that chart 👆misses out the most important bit of context: for better or worse the UK is doing far more Covid testing than almost any other country (first chart here). Put those two datapoints together to see positive tests as a % of total and UK situation looks less dramatic
Read 17 tweets
19 Oct
If net zero is going to happen we need to re-do the industrial revolution all over again.
It’s hard to express how big a deal this is.
But I’ve had a go here:
edmundconway.com/the-industrial…
The point is the Industrial Revolution wasn’t just about steel or textile manufacture.
It was a chemicals revolution
A concrete revolution
A glassmaking revolution
An aluminium revolution
A metals refining revolution
Plastics, silicon, fertilisers, batteries… I could go on…
And, guess what, ALL of those processes emit carbon. Sometimes via energy (OK so we can power them via renewables)
But also invariably carbon is emitted as part of the chemical/industrial process itself.
This chart from today’s HMT review of net zero underlines it.
CO2 EVERYWHERE
Read 4 tweets
18 Oct
Here’s a thread abt a few of the most important things you need to know about getting to net zero and eliminating carbon emissions, but before we get stuck in let’s begin with a question.
How much do you suppose governments around the world are spending on research into energy?
If you’re anything like me you’re probably assuming they’re spending more than ever before. After all, they say they’re serious about averting climate change. They’ve pledged to eliminate emissions by 2050, right? And to do that we’re going to need serious tech breakthroughs…
This is an @IEA chart that underlines that need for tech breakthroughs. These bars show you how the world eliminates CO2 emissions by 2050. The key thing to focus on is the yellow bit.
Nearly HALF of all the emissions reductions are due to “technologies under development”
Read 30 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(