Whoa here is a map we have not seen for a *while*
Guesses?
So, Delco may still have some mail in ballots left to count, & I suppose others might as well? But as of today, at least, this is where the Nov 2021 PA Dem top of ticket (Maria McLaughlin) improved over Joe Biden, and where she lost ground.
Sorry, realized that was ambiguous. Everywhere in blue here saw Maria McLaughlin improve over Joe Biden's vote share. Everywhere in red saw Brobson improve over Donald Trump. [But note Delco mail-in vote count not yet complete: could end up a lighter shade of red...]
Meanwhile, in ballots reported as of today Nov. 4, here's the change of each county's total ballots cast within the statewide total. Bucks & Erie, 👀
All of which is to say, most of this Tuesday's statewide results could be predicted by taking Joe Torsella's narrow Nov 2020 defeat as the baseline for partisan allegiance within PA moving forward...
Update: After spending an obsessive evening with Dept of State data @GianniHillPA helpfully pointed me to, it looks like there are at least ~69,000 timely mail-in ballots statewide not yet tallied, concentrated in Philly & Montco but spread widely, & ranging fr 60-85% Dem. So!
@GianniHillPA Calculating by county suggests statewide Dem candidates may net 35-45,000 more votes from these mail-ins (range bc possible undervotes, missing signatures etc). #CountEveryVote people, ain't over til it's over. So as not to contribute to a misleading early closure I redid my maps
@GianniHillPA & here's the swing from Trump to Brobson, w/not-yet-tallied mail-ins modeled & added. In blue counties McLaughlin 2021 outperformed Biden 2020, in red vice versa. No, I have no idea what's up w/Mercer (wondered first if Brobson was fr there but no, that's Lycoming: also visible!)
@GianniHillPA And hmm, what if Nov 2021 in PA doesn't look like a grim new omen for PA Dems but more like... 2017?
@GianniHillPA and because I know you were about to ask, here's what relative turnout shifts from previous year's presidential looked like in 2017
(btw please note that whatever comparison you look at, @eriedems just absolutely killed it in 2021. @jim_wertz! )

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Lara Putnam

Lara Putnam Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @lara_putnam

5 Nov
Would be great if the new coalitional politics undergirding this major move👇 were receiving as much weight in 2021 elections post mortems as all the handwaving about whether "CRT"/DEI doomed Dems in the suburbs [Narrator: It didn't]
With impressive timing this hit my mailbox this morning. This is what strategic synergizing of electoral, community & labor organizing looks like. Are you a national reporter interested in the post-pandemic, post-Trump-presidency landscape for org'd labor? Time to book a flight
Read 5 tweets
3 Nov
ok, a few more minitakes. 1) It's not going to draw much noise bc it doesn't fit national tea-leaf reading or intra-Dem point-scoring BUT: The pace at which PA elected officialdom is diversifying is quite something, including now in big towns in non-diverse counties
We saw this already in 2018 & '20 on the GOP side, w/ women & some non-white candidates running & winning state legslature seats & statewide office. (I think hardcore Dem/progressive activists may underestimate how much this shapes/moderates the GOP image among regular voters...)
One might have been concerned that PA Dems would embrace "casting against type" in a parallel/mirror way & double down on only nominating white men. I'll sidestep the question of whether insiders tried (ymmv) but Dem primary electorates were having none of it in May 2021
Read 23 tweets
3 Nov
I am trying hard not to break my never-tweet-while-votes-are-still-being-counted rule but people, these Allegheny County numbers are... something else.
Like, in 2017 Dem PA Supreme Court nominee Dwayne Woodruff carried a net 55,000 vote advantage out of Allegheny County. Today Dem Supreme Court nominee Maria McLaughlin is already carrying a 70,000 net vote advantage out of Allegheny County, and 1/4 of precincts are yet to report
& in the face of incredibly contentious schoolboard politics—& some ugly campaign tactics—Dem candidates who are going to bring unprecedented racial/ethnic diversity are winning schoolboard races in northern & southern suburbs alike. Not winning all of them: but in *tough* places
Read 15 tweets
15 Oct
An indicator of how the intensity of schoolboard conflicts ramped up this summer/fall: I know several cases PA of center/left teams running write-in campaigns now, in districts where back in Feb local grassroots weren't organized/outraged enough to get recruits on primary ballot
Yet another suburban school board write-in campaign👇 School boards are really the races to watch nationwide this Nov, to see whether it's the RW backlash, or the backlash-against-the-backlash that's capturing the engaged-enough-to-vote suburban center...
Wow, must read👇account from small town SCPA. So much strategic insight on display— frankly, so much more in touch with real people & how they are swayed than anything on offer from any side of the Great Dem Pundit Messaging Wars #onhere in recent weeks,! organizingupgrade.com/not-in-our-tow…
Read 5 tweets
17 Jul
This👇 by @ed_kilgore is both worth reading in itself, & mentions a precedent that has been on my mind, & that I've come think is important, even crucial.

We should start to recognize the anti-CRT push as the Swiftboating of youth-led antiracism. [a🧵] nymag.com/intelligencer/…
The key dynamic in the original swiftboat smear was it took something that Dems had (appropriately!) anticipated as an authentic source of strength—their candidate's record of military service in Vietnam—& made it so toxic that any effort to draw strength from it was neutralized
.@holden has been writing brilliantly re the importance of a "field of evidence" for participatory propaganda, & the insight fits more broadly. Where is the field of provocations that get spun up as "CRT" in local schoolboard after schoolboard coming from? hapgood.us/2021/06/12/par…
Read 45 tweets
17 Jul
Philly Dem ward comttee internal vote drama (which is very much my jam) has me noticing that (a few) ward cttees in Philly have twitter accounts. AFAIK none in the city of Pittsburgh do. Which is striking as much for what it says about twitter as for what it says about Dem cttees
You might think that a platform that skews heavily Democratic & politically engaged would be a natural fit for entrepreneurial local Democratic organizations seeking to grow. But that hasn't generally been the case: and I'm not actually saying it should be. In part it's a good
reminder of just what a non-representative slice *even of very highly engaged Democrats* twitter captures: political twitter is decades younger, way more highly formally educated, & less female than the folks who make up the Democratic action-taking base even in big fancy cities
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(