Today, a friend & fellow Tesla owner and I enjoyed a 2 hours test-drive with a #Polestar 2. Great fun 🤩

Our verdict: It doesn’t come close to a #Tesla for a number of reasons, but it’s by far the best non-Tesla #EV we’ve experienced. Image
What we liked about the #Polestar 2:
- build quality
- hatchback
- good acceleration
- great recuperation on drive pedal incl. #OnePedalDriving capability
- good responsiveness of touch screen

2/8
However, our #Tesla's are or feel better in nearly every aspect, from slightly better till massively better. Here a few examples what we didn't like so much about the #Polestar 2:
- good recup, but weaker than a Tesla
- middle console is huge and takes a lot of room,…

3/8
…so it felt tight on both the driver and the passenger seat
- not a lot of room for little stuff and cups in front (despite the huge middle console)
- some cheap plastic outside (e.g. grill) and inside
- too little headroom for tall people on the backseat

4/8
- Android Car OS felt kind of messy, and there are settings all over in several sub menus which are hard to find.
- sound system didn't blow off our shoes (despite Harman Kardon)
- not a lot of in-car-entertainment options
- rather small screen

5/8
- approx same size as a #Tesla #Model3, but weighs about 20% more
- Very heavy! #Polestar 2 LR with approx same battery size as a Tesla Model3 LR, but substantially lower range: 249mi vs 353mi EPA
- P LR's consumption 52% higher than a Tesla Model3 LR: 38kWh vs 25kWh EPA

6/8
- NMC pouch cells (for EVs, NMC shouldn't be used in pouch form)
- only charges with 150kW (Tesla: 250kW)

Biggest concern was the driving assist: While it does an ok job on the highway, it's rather unusable on other roads. Furthermore, the cooperation with the…

7/8
…driver is just plain dangerous: There's NO acoustic alarm when it can't handle a situation or suddenly switches itself off!!! When intervening with manual steering, it stays activated and might just try to take over again if it feels like.

8/8

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Roger Rusch, ceo plus (Leadership, Teamwork, EVs)

Roger Rusch, ceo plus (Leadership, Teamwork, EVs) Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ceo_plus_ch

May 8
Gestern an einer Gewerbeausstellung. Organisiert von @_electrosuisse 👏 boten diverse Händler #eAuto-Probefahrten an. Die inzw. grosse Auswahl an Stromern ist eindrücklich & schön. @Tesla leider nicht anwesend.

Ich bin 5 #BEV‘s kurz probegefahren. Hier meine ersten Eindrücke:
1) #BMW #i4 M50:
+ enorme Beschleunigung
+ flüssige Bedienung
- Fahr- & Bremspedal sprechen zu schnell an -> sehr ruckliges & unangenehmes Fahren
- Rekup via Fahrpedal eher schwach
- sehr hoher Verbrauch
- Motorengeräusche 🤦‍♂️ (abschaltbar)
- hoher Preis für nen elektr. 3er
2) #Mini #Cooper SE:
+ geht gut ab
+ gute Rekup
- schlechte Traktionskontrolle (Durchdrehen beim Beschl.)
- erbärmliche Reichweite (183km EPA)
- überraschend kleiner Kofferraum
- störendes Plastikteil für HUD
- Bedienung fühlt sich Old School an
Read 7 tweets
Jan 9
#CarMarketSwitzerland 2021:

Compared to pre-pandemic year 2019, entire market down by -14%. Only a few manufacturers could increase sales, #Tesla's the strongest with +37%. Ø hit of the players in the red was a whopping -29%, #Ssangyong the biggest victim with -95%.

1/15 Image
#CarMarketSwitzerland 2021:

Comparison of Q4 shows that market decelerated towards end of year: Q4/21 down -31% compared to Q4/19. Ø hit the manufacturers in the red had to suffer was -39%, e.g.
- Audi/BMW -30%
- Ford -50%
- Mazda/Subaru -63%
- Mercedes -35%
- VW -38%

2/15 Image
#CarMarketSwitzerland 2021:

In the 'battle' of the propulsion types, we could see 3 historic events in 2021:
- after May, #BEV's startet to leave #PHEV's behind for good
- in August, BEVs overtook the Diesels
- in December, BEVs overtook the plugless hybrids (#HEV)

3/15 Image
Read 15 tweets
Nov 30, 2021
A friend of mine is interested in a #Ford #Mustang #MachE GT, so I did some research and learned of the following issues:

- There is currently a recall going on for the Mach-E regarding the windshield and the panoramic roof possibly flying off.

1/5
- Opening doors with phone or keyphob seems to work very unreliably.
- Unstable Bluetooth connection, so that phone-based functions (e.g. music, navigation via Apple Carplay) are often unusable.
- At CCS fast-charging stations, the #MachE charges only up to 80% with…

2/5
…fast DC, then it switches to slow AC charging (11kW). This is not adjustable and means that on road trips you effectively only have 200 miles of range instead of the promised 270.
- The #MachE's fast-charging limit of 150kW (DC) is rather underwhelming nowadays, in…

3/5
Read 5 tweets
Jan 5, 2021
This might help explain #Tesla’s valuation:

Excl stock-based comp, I estimate a Q4/20 operating profit (EBIT) of approx 1.7b. FY 2020 non-GAAP EBIT would amount to 4.2b.

Comparison with #VW's Passenger Cars division (25 models) 2019:
- 12 times Tesla’s deliveries
- LESS EBIT! Image
If you compare revenue and operating profit (EBIT) on a per vehicle basis, the difference between #Tesla and #FossilAuto blows your mind!

How would the incumbents profitably sell #EV’s when their current profit margin with gas-guzzlers is only 600 bucks per car??? Image
Note: #Tesla‘s 2020 revenue and EBIT in the 2 tweets/charts above are my estimates. Tesla has not yet reported any financials of Q4/2020 and FY 2020. This will happen at the next earnings call by the end of Jan.
Read 4 tweets
Jan 3, 2021
1/15

#CarMarketSwitzerland 2020:
After the great news that #Tesla achieved 500k global deliveries, I dug a bit into the 2020 car market data of🇨🇭and could discover really amazing facts.

Highlights:
- BEV market share Dec 20: 16%
- Tesla with huge push in Q4 & Dec

(Thread)
2/15

#CarMarketSwitzerland 2020:
Compared to Q4/2019, the market is down by 14.6% in Q4/2020, with declines of up to 64% (Lexus). #Tesla increased its sales by nearly 30%.
3/15

#CarMarketSwitzerland 2020:
Compared to 2019, the entire #COVID19 year is down by 24%, with declines of up to 55% (Opel). With 6’042 deliveries, #Tesla could keep the 2019 level.
Read 15 tweets
Oct 18, 2020
Bin gestern mal in die Tiefen der Spezifikationen des #VW #ID4 und des #Tesla #ModelY getaucht und habe Euch diesen Feature-Vergleich zusammengestellt.

Bitte auch Fussnoten beachten.

Comparison in english -> next tweet.
Yesterday I dove into the depths of the specs & features of the #VW #ID4 and the #Tesla #ModelY. Even found some time to compile this feature comparison for you 😉

Please do also check the footnotes.

Feature-Vergleich in deutsch -> vorgehender Tweet.
In case you‘re wondering how the #ModelY can have lower #TCO than the cheaper #ID4:
- Teslas hold value better than other #EV‘s -> residual value after 10y assumed 10% for ID4, 20% for MY
- ID4 has 2y maintenance interval
- ID4 with higher consumption and higher fast-charge cost
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(