@1s2atomexit Yes, it should
ethical norms of psychiatry & psychology, counseling too
The entire, so called, "mental health" sector, need to be rewritten
In fact, there shouldn't be a "mental health" sector, at all
That in itself is manipulation, deception, domination, deprivation of options
@1s2atomexit The very first step for anyone who decided to seek support for some temporarily or long term circumstances they are finding disabling should be to be fully informed of their rights under CRPD Guidance, to ensure they understand them
@1s2atomexit Every guilds offerings, constructs etc need to be presented fully and honestly, as nothing more than optional constructs & ideally there should be *independent* deceion making support available to decide what things people wish to choose
@1s2atomexit This comes under the umbrella of support of will & preferences free from undue influence and Pressure for full inclusion and participation
It is under the rights based model of disability, not the medical model aim is not to try to drive the person's unaccommodated diversity out
@1s2atomexit They have the right to make sense of what they are going through in their own time and access reasonable adjustments to any lack of accommodation of their diversity
This gets cheaper and cheaper for government to achieve the more flexible to individual needs & circumstances
@1s2atomexit That the society is, in the first place
For example: a society that expects people to work 60 hours per week to put food on the table and a roof over their head, doesn't really accommodate anyone 🤷🏻‍♀️
So people who find they can't keep up with that, or are even injured by it
@1s2atomexit Are going to be much more expensive to accommodate
Whilst if the culture is for some much more flexible arrangement
Let's say at the other extreme it's more dominated by macroeconomics for community and life based economy
@1s2atomexit Not a rat race to produce status and money, waste & environmental damage
There might be something like a universal basic income standard with a job guarantee
So that we all do part of the contributing to what the community needs as we are able
But there's plenty of room
@1s2atomexit For times when we aren't
There are, of course, many other different ways that societies and economies can be organised, as well
But there should never, ever be such a thing as "diagnosing" a "mental illness"
That's just deception, manipulation, domination, deprivation of options
@1s2atomexit Especially as doctor-patient has long been recognised as a presumed relationship of undue influence!
So much so a contract between a doctor and their patient is presumed to have been formed under impaired consent!
@1s2atomexit So psychiatrists & GPs practicing reification of a symbolic, philosophical ideology likening some kind of emotional suffering to bring sort of like being ill
Or worse, some kind of diversity as a "mental aberration" to eliminate
Really, reallY should be malpractice!
@1s2atomexit They can offer the idea, honestly, for ppl to choose or not
But they definitely don't get to gatekeep access to support
Or differentially appoint rights
@1s2atomexit medical model gatekeeping and reification of medical models of Psychosocial disability (all of "mental health") is explicitly against CRPD guidance, already 🤷🏻‍♀️
@1s2atomexit Sorry for length, again!
Reader below
@threadreaderapp unroll

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Travel Foreigners

Travel Foreigners Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TraverseFore

18 Dec
@12butterflysfly @DrJessTaylor @Jaimi_Shrive Where do I start?
Perhaps it's easier to start by explaining what should be met?
CRPD was ratified by UK around 2010
International disability alliance was funded by several ratifying states to draft recommended steps after Ratification
internationaldisabilityalliance.org/resources/step…
@12butterflysfly @DrJessTaylor @Jaimi_Shrive By now, every stakeholder (anyone who may affect or be affected by policy) should know & understand their individual rights under CRPD guidance, their consequent responsibilities to respect others' rights
should understand the spirit too: individual rights, not "best interests"
@12butterflysfly @DrJessTaylor @Jaimi_Shrive So there should be a really careful and transparent process that all people providing disability services
Those services people with disabilities might choose to use in exercising their individual right to support for full inclusion & participation
Read 29 tweets
18 Dec
@HengartnerMP Well, you have already started practicing manipulation, deception, deprivation of options & domination @HengartnerMP
By making statement your intent is to "help people with mental health problems"
Convention on Rights of Persons with disabilities is new nondiscrimination treaty
@HengartnerMP So I understand, people don't yet realise their unconscious domination, manipulation, deception, deprivation of options.
They may actually believe there is such a thing as inferior people to them, people whose mentality needs "help" becoming as their own, purportedly superior one
@HengartnerMP That's common, in fact it's the norm, throughout the history of post colonial western social development: the prior social development was on basis of an assumed "natural order" of inferiority and superiority, where the inferior obey the superior, and the superior rise in status
Read 26 tweets
18 Dec
@justamom1st @1s2atomexit Actually, people have the right to freedom of thought and belief
So they can choose any religion, philosophy or ideology they like to make sense of their own psyche
This right has historically been deprived from people with disabilities
@justamom1st @1s2atomexit So we negotiated the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, a multilateral UN treaty that has now been ratified by 80% of the UN
A treaty like this is a promise by ratifying states to stop discriminating against people with perceived or actual disability
@justamom1st @1s2atomexit What is disability? Good question. The #UNCRPD preamble specifically states that disability is not defined because it is an evolving construct however CRPD has been negotiated to implement the rights based model of disability
Read 19 tweets
14 Nov
@jonathanstea @SameiHuda I think problem, whether psychologists or anybody else, is that we have not had any space to logically, fairly, and reasonably discuss the complex issues of the balancing of rights and responsibilities in an unprecedented pandemic. Furthermore vaccines have been overrelied upon
@jonathanstea @SameiHuda In wealthy, developed countries, there was no excuse not to use border control, quarrantine and a host of other measures to stamp the virus out, with vaccines & subsequent medicine technology forming one tool in a toolbox based on traditional safety management
@jonathanstea @SameiHuda ( like in other controlled diseases)
Antivaxx propaganda been run on a pyramid scheme of manipulation, has been arrogance and theorising by people who have no idea how these manipulation pyramids work, or are themselves perpetrators (or victims, or both) of them in other domains
Read 5 tweets
12 Nov
@ClinpsychLucy @CMHLvic I'm disgusted @ClinpsychLucy
You flew to my country& state of origin
Specifically to work on ingratiating your ridiculous framework
With people who have not got their head around CRPD rights or its importance
That's an act of power against a marginalised diverse group of people
@ClinpsychLucy @CMHLvic We need these actors focused on understanding our painstakingly negotiated human rights treaty guidance & the wise and considered steps and guidance for its implementation, to bring Psychosocial disability in line w/ wider disability in understanding of rights & responsibilities
@ClinpsychLucy @CMHLvic There is a world of marginalisation, that unfortunately even our representatives and representative structures are not fully understanding.
It's incredibly difficult to have conversations about it, too
Because it's easily misinterpreted
There's already been a difficulty
Read 13 tweets
12 Nov
@threadreaderapp @Exnihil80688795 @Rufusmay Because if you *do* mean to imply jumping up and down trying to get people to understand & respect rights is pushing individual "view" or "belief"
Really saying we *don't* respect needs or viewpoints of anyone but our group & when people ask us to, we regard then as an imposition
@threadreaderapp @Exnihil80688795 @Rufusmay Why do you think people have to jump up and down?
If not purely because not only are their own needs, will & preferences being respected, but there's a whole system of marginalisation, wherein if you are similar enough to get accepted into one of the cliques you get heard there
@threadreaderapp @Exnihil80688795 @Rufusmay So long as you keep your needs concealed and only express those narrow enough to fit the group persona, and the group's narrow little focus on piddling places of inclusion in the context of a society excluding & gatekeeping by design
And so long as you are willing to shun
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(