The Indian #COVID19 response lacks many things. Among them,
1-Twitter is full of people posting lateral flow tests where they found relatives positive at home. Don’t see that happening in India.
Interpretation: either the tests are not available (freely and low cost) OR 1/n
Equally likely - most Indians think the responsibility of their health is of the government aka health system. Like most things we outsource things we should be doing.
2-Lack of transparent funding and/or approval of research. The Covaxin trial is a prime example. 2/n
Check the sites that did the trial and you find very few sites that are known for high quality research. How the sites were selected isn’t known. In fact many in the area of some sites didn’t know such a hospital did research. Our proposal for community based early detection 3/n
Of #covid is stuck in govt red tape for six months.
3-Barely any collaborative research. I know of govt faculty telling me explicitly that they were not being allowed to do research or publish data from government hospitals. This is well known and no faculty 4/n
Will say this openly as their careers will be jeopardized. Many get transferred or suspended for flimsy reasons and if the system wants to get you, you are done! The govt system (politics does not matter, bureaucracy does) can harm you even if they are trying to help you. So, 5/n
4- There is hardly any concern for #LongCovid or doing anything about it in India. Either among the policy makers or even private entities. Zilch discussion about it despite being a problem.
5-Children vaccination should have assumed a prominent role in the discussion 6/n
At least a few months back. We are now into the third year and we have no public data on the vaccines available for them and no plan in place. They constitute 40% of the population. While 🇬🇧 delayed kid vaccination they ensured that they got a better dose vaccine 7/n
Which has got approved this week. We have typically shown the least concern towards kids vaccines (and by extension schooling and education). Blaming the govt will not cut it as I see very few in the ‘civil society’ discussing it. Govts take action when votes matter. 8/n
6- The postponing of the #neetpg2021 the poorly construed new rule and subsequent postponement of #neetpg2021counselling has hurt those who have contributed the most. It signifies that neither the society or govt is concerned about its own health (even in pandemic times) 9/n
While medicine as a field is exciting, practicing it in 🇮🇳 is a pain if you are in the public system.
Interpret freely as I find many can’t even understand simple tweets. (Reason why govts have gotten away for last seven decades - health takes time)
10/n and End.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Prof. Dr. Somashekhar Nimbalkar, MD, PGDPH, FNNF

Prof. Dr. Somashekhar Nimbalkar, MD, PGDPH, FNNF Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ProfSomashekhar

28 Dec
The trouble with social media is that you can’t pick up fake accounts from serious accounts.
NEETPG got postponed multiple times and we are in this mess now playing with the future of not only the students but also the patients they will manage in their career. 1/n
In April the #postponeneetpg was trending with @ShashiTharoor too supporting it.
Feel free to use the above hashtag and go though how many are not bothered about what is happening now. Most are not even doctors. So likely paid accounts. 2/n
Here is one account.
Then it was “we are worried”
Now it is adverts and YT accounts. Total only 66 tweets. 3/n ImageImageImageImage
Read 4 tweets
23 May
In 🇮🇳 we have had the benefit of research conducted in the west. Masking, Dexamethasone, Lockdowns, Toci, etc have helped us manage the #COVID19 pandemic. But we like to do jugaad so we added to the mix Steam inhalation’s, multiple antibiotics, zinc, Vit C 1/n
Then there are kadhas, 💧 neeti, IVM, HCQ and so on and so forth. We have a high diabetic population which means we have a even higher prediabetic one which when sick with COVID19 can fiddle with our glucose homeostasis. This has probably resulted in a heady mix. 2/n
The west has given us #COVID19Vaccine to protect against #COVID19 We don’t yet have phase 3 data for the really 🇮🇳 one. Whether we like it or not our medical care depends on research done in the west - at least most of it. Now we have the #BlackFungus problem that no one has 3/n
Read 6 tweets
19 May
The budget director Ayush in 2021 is roughly 2300 crore rupees as compared to Health Research which is 1900 crore (2020). How has that worked out in pandemic times. Why am I doing this thread on Ayush and COVID19?
Last year when the pandemic began govt distributed 1/n
The GUJ govt distributed preventive Ayush meds across #Covid19 hospitals and healthcare workers as well as contacts were encouraged to utilize it. Mild cases also got it and the Principal Secretary Health actively promoted it as @narendramodi had endorsed it. 2/n
Initially it was fun for me as I saw colleagues take it and the sceptic in me could not be more sarcastic. As we hit the first wave and people began dying I almost forgot about this till April 2021 when my kids tested positive. I was shaken when the local PHC 🚐 pulled 🆙 3/n
Read 20 tweets
16 May
The cost of non Evidence-Based treatment is phenomenal. When you add one extra drug in the ICU that has no value, it means preparing the drug, injecting it, thrombophlebitis, etc. Now multiply that by 500 patients and fewer doctors and nurses. This is one hospital. 1/n
Now make that drug expensive (Remdesivir), difficult to get (plasma) and imagine the energy that goes into procuring it and failing which guilt that might accompany it. Not everyone can afford these and many are selling their livelihoods to obtain it. 2/n
There are families with two individuals in the ICUs and another two infected at home. Those are home are also receiving drugs which are useless and might put them into hospital. Such as steroids at high doses when not required (in viral replication phase). 3/n
Read 4 tweets
11 May
Thank you @DrBinoyVShah for the post. We are all thankful to many for guiding us in our career. These relationships are wonderful and develop over time. I have had the benefit of many and everyone guides you in different ways.1/n
We all remember our school teachers. Many who took time out to teach from regular schedules. I remember visiting Prof Ganihar many Sunday for class at his house (not paid tuitions) - used to have 🥗. Then we had many mentors in med school including seniors. 2/n
Some mentors have connected throughout and i still keep in touch with them. Academically and Professionally I have done much better than my mentors and many of my mentees have already done better than me. As my mentors are proud of me, so am i proud of my mentees. 3/n
Read 11 tweets
10 May
Story from 2014 I think.
Was in a neonatal conference in Ahemdabad when a consultant from Canada was delivering a lecture on neonatal therapeutic hypothermia. In response to some question he gave an answer that was not consistent with available evidence at that time. 1/n
I was shocked and was not sure whether I should counter since he was an invited speaker. As I was debating with myself one young pediatrician (post DCh - vadodara and neo fellowship) got up and quoted figures from studies and told him point blank that he was wrong. 2/n
Eerie silence ensued and the chairperson tided over it saying (we can discuss in break) and that was it. Felt quite proud that a young student was able to say something which many would hesitate to do (I would hesitate even today). 3/n
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(