Five years ago, Dulles Airport, the first night of the #MuslimBan. A night that shifted the direction of so many lives, mine included. What our community endured (and continues to) has been recorded on the Wall of Shame.
A year into the next admin, and guess what? Not much has changed. I remember 5 years ago how the stark visibility of prejudice-I felt so alien-successfully jammed up the fragile mechanisms of due process. We all blamed the admin, as if change is measured in 4 year terms.
But as our Black friends were trying to tell us, that prejudice has been around a long, long time. I today remember the words of Judge Hassan El-Amin of PG County Circuit Court, speaking to a mostly immigrant Muslim crowd after 9/11: "We're right here. All you gotta do is ask!"
The more things change, the more they stay the same. I've bit my tongue for the past year, despite promising to never again sip platitudes out of a pitcher of Kool-Aid. And you know? I still have to fight to squeeze due process out of this system.
Biden has actually defended Trump-era policies. Sure, blame COVID, blame Trump, blame Bush, blame Republicans. WHERE IS THE CHANGE?
The only thing that's really happened is a "Under New Management" sign has gone up. Why can't they do more?
Wrong question.
If you want something done right, you gotta do it yourself. Or more correctly - we gotta do it ourselves. It doesn't matter whether we ever see the fruit of our labor or find out if it's working: that's not why we do it.
We do it to serve. My Syrian client whose case is now moving forward, delayed for years by the Muslim Ban. The countless Afghans stuck in legal limbo, some inexplicably detained by ICE *after being brought into the US on military evac flights.*
The Central Americans still languishing in squalid tent cities south of the border. The Haitians Biden has continued to deport.
Still, reminders are good. That's all Trump really was: a reminder of a system that has not changed. None of us can be judged on whether we succeeded in changing, but we can be judged on whether we tried.
Keep building. Nothing began 5 years ago, and it won't be done in the next 5, either.
The real work is changing hearts and minds, because contrary to popular belief, that's where bills are actually introduced.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
#TantonPapers Update - We're inching closer to breaking the seal!
Thank you to our lawyer @olcplc for a well-argued Motion to Compel yesterday before the Michigan Court of Claims.
Watch the hearing here (starts at 15:25):
At issue: @UMich has lost all of their "blanket" defenses to disclosure of the #TantonPapers. Only the personal/privacy exemption remained, which exempts info that constitutes a clear invasion of privacy (such as SSN).
So they had to go through 25,000 papers 1 by 1.
They were supposed to list everything in a Vaughn index, but they did such a poor job it didn't help the Court determine whether the exemption applied.
(They said it would have cost them $200,000 to do it, at 2 min per page. Do the math.)
In November, we successfully obtained an index prepared by @UMich of the sealed #TantonPapers. The first glimpse of the papers I've fought to see for 5 years now.
Oral argument 1/12; if you're just getting here: here's why these papers are important:
As a practitioner, I can tell you that immigration law is complex. It frequently doesn't make sense, exalts form over function, and when misused, works against people.
So long as you're not calling on ICE to pick up undocumented people brave enough to speak out, we're allies.
We've been listening to white supremacists & allies for far too long.
The Trump years were just a peek at what they would've done if they were in the driver's seat. But a year in, they've still got their hands on the wheel.
Who in particular am I talking about? Glad you asked!
Groups:
Federation for American Immigration Reform
Center for Immigration Studies
NumbersUSA
Immigration Reform Law Institute
Progressives For Immigration Reform
Funded by:
Colcom Foundation
Pioneer Fund
Sidney Swensrud Foundation
Weeden Foundation
Foundation For The Carolinas
Scaife Foundations
Implemented by:
Stephen Miller
Jeff Sessions
Steve Bannon