Putin is expected to give a televised address shortly #WatchThisSpace
Likely will announce recognition of DNR and LNR per unanimous recommendation of his Security Council. Will Western leaders keep on with diplomatic efforts after such move?
Speech in progress now:
So far, a history lesson on the Soviet Union and what Lenin did or did not do 100 years ago
He is blasting Lenin pretty hard for setting up Soviet Republics and allowing them to leave the Union
Yet: ‘I don’t blame anyone. The situation back then was very hard'
Putin: ‘Ukraine was created by Lenin. He is its author and creator’
Putin: No one thought about the future in the 1920s (Ed:I mplication is that, unlike Lenin, Trotsky and Stalin, Putin actually thinks about the future)
Is Putin trying to set a Guinness record for the longest invasion announcement in history?
Putin is a pretty boring history lecturer ...(to say nothing about his accuracy)
This is an incredibly long-winded attack on Ukraine's right to exist as a state. Is he really going to finish it up with just a declaration of DNR/LNR independence? Would seem like a huge rhetorical letdown...
Now he is talking about water, gas and electricity prices in Ukraine. First invasion announcement ever to mention these things? H/T @pwnallthethings
I think I figured out Putin's master plan! He won't invade. He will just put all Ukrainians into permanent sleep with this speech
Boy does Putin seem to hate corruption (maybe just in Ukraine though) according to his speech. Just a regular Eliot Ness...
Now he is talking about the shutting down of TV channels and harassment of Rada members in Ukraine. Reference to his close friend Medvedchuk
Putin: 'Radical islamic organizations' are used by foreign intelligence agencies to terrorize Crimea
Putin: Ukraine is trying to create its own nuclear weapons, which they have Soviet-era expertise for. It will not be hard for them
Oh boy...
This speech is really not about the Donbas...
Now Putin is talking about a threat to Russia from NATO 'air forces' deployed from Ukrainian bases
Is anyone keeping track of the number of pretexts used so far for invasion? I've lost count long ago
Now he just added another - taking down of monument to Russian General Suvorov in Ukraine
Putin: 'Ukraine joining NATO is a direct threat to Russia'
So do invasion skeptics listening to this speech still think Putin will declare victory after declaring DNR and LNR independence and pull back troops?
Putin doing the obligatory reference to 'Not one inch' on NATO expansion. He is trying his best to help @e_sarotte sell some more copies of her (truly excellent ) book...
Putin asks the West: 'Why are you trying to make Russia into an enemy?'
Then answers himself: The West wants to destroy Russia
Putin makes another obligatory reference to 4-5 minute US missile flight time to Moscow
I have to say - among all possible pretexts for invasion - I never once imagined they would use the old 'Ukraine is building nuclear weapons' excuse...
Putin: The position of the West has not changed. They are trying to blackmail us with sanctions, which they would put in place on Russia regardless of what happens in Ukraine. The goal - to curtail Russia's economic growth. Only because we exist
I think he actually does believe this and that's why sanction threat were never an effective deterrent
And just 52 mins later he is finally getting to the Donbas...
Another genocide reference
And here we go: Putin moves to recognize DNR and LNR
Putin demands Kyiv to end all military actions. 'If they don't, Ukraine will be solely responsible for all future outcomes'
Speech finally over
And Putin now signs the LNR and DNR recognition statements with leaders of both regions
Quite an anticlimactic end to an hour long speech. But he ended it with a clear threat of response if 'Kyiv continues military actions'
Pretext is in place. War can be launched at any moment
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
A few thoughts on Putin, Lenin, Soviet Union and the Czars…🧵
In his speech yesterday, Putin directed a fairly large amount of hate towards Lenin for ‘creating’ the Soviet Union republics and giving them an option to quit the Union. It was quite a spectacle
And I wonder if by doing so, he is actively trying to diminish Lenin’s role in Russia’s history and, in the process, turn himself into a much more consequential historical figure in comparison
I’ve been convinced since early December that Russian invasion of Ukraine was highly likely. The Biden administration is now assessing that it is ‘imminent’
There is a lot of current discussion about the types of severe sanctions that the US would place on Russia in the event of invasion, but not as much about how Russia can hit back at the US and European economies in response 🧵
Western sanctions on Russian oil and gas industry (except for NS2 pipeline), as well as blacklisting them from SWIFT bank payment system, seem to be off the table reuters.com/world/europe/s…
Sanctions on NS2 seem to be a certainty but they are not going to matter much to Putin in the event that Russia actually brings Ukraine into its sphere of influence with military force
I’ve been convinced since mid December that the RU invasion of UKR is very likely. But I recognize that a lot of people disagree (not least of all, many in UKR government — at least publicly)
It is always good to reevaluate your assumptions so let’s red team the alternatives 🧵
I have heard 2 predominant theories of why Putin might not invade:
1. He will recognize the significant risks and costs of an operation and pull back at the last minute
2. This was a bluff from day one and he was never planning to invade
Let’s evaluate both systematically
First, the pullback theory
Essentially, some people seem to believe that Putin—who, whatever else you want to say about him, is no dummy—launched a massive troops buildup (and not recently, but back last spring) and only just now realized that it is not going to work