The contrast is stunning. The proud Ukrainians think that Putin will lose his war of aggression against them, while the Western observers overwhelmingly think Russia will win. Having studied the Finnish Winter War I am all with the Ukrainians.
I am no military expert, but Putin possesses no precondition for victory in Ukraine. 1. His soldiers have no motivation or moral. Even at high command level, they have not been told that they are to fight a war in Ukraine. Putin has given no plausible explanation. They give up.
2. Putin's commanders have fought in Chechnya & Syria. they are used to extreme cruelty and all crimes of war, but can you fight people who Putin calls "Russians" like that? Does not make much sense to anybody, least of all to the soldiers who are asked to do so.
3. Putin's two favorite troops are Kadyrov's cruel islamist killers and the free-wheeling Wagnerites. They are now supposed to attack Kyiv after having suffered heavy losses. The ordinary Russian military, the FSB & the SVR cannot like that. Their rivalry is serious in Russia.
4. An elementary observation is that the Russian military appears utterly corrupt. It used to be considered a human right to steal and resell half the diesel. Apparently it still is, because Putin has not fought against corruption anywhere.
5. A large part of Russia's armaments industry has been monopolized in the giant Rostec, which was awarded to Putin's chum from KGB in Dresden Sergei Chemezov, who has never shown any industrial ability, while he is good at enriching himself. That is what Putin wants.
6. The Russian military forces are not large, contrary to Western disinformation. Russia has 190,000 troops allocated for Ukraine, according to good US intelligence, while Ukraine has an army of 250,000 and vast reserves. Russia has only 280,000 in reserves of poor quality.
7. To everybody's surprise, we have learned that many of the Russian troops were young conscripts and poorly trained. Many POWs were even policemen from Siberia. The Ukrainians proudly state: Don't send your poor boys to our meat-grinder! Clearly the Russian army is a mess.
8. The single advantage the Russian armed forces have is their many rockets, mainly Grad or Stalin organs, old awful killers of civilians. Russia also has worse bombs, chemical, biological and nuclear arms. To judge from the primitive Putin propaganda they intend to use them.
9. To judge from the Ukrainian Defense Ministry's numbers, which are the only plausible numbers we possess, the Ukrainians slaughter about 1,000 Russian soldiers every day, now 12,000 killed. In Afghanistan, the USSR lost "only" 15,000 soldiers in 9 years & that was a disaster...
10. During Desert Storm in Iraq in 1991, Colin Powell taught us that you need massive overweight for shock and awe when attacking. Russia had none of it. The Russian military don't know what they are doing.
A stunning FSB document has said exactly that. facebook.com/vladimir.osech…
The Ukrainians, by contrast, seem to have done most things right. They have won the information war hands down by being honest and providing information. They have made no foolhardy offensives, but waited for the fools to attack them and then killed the aggressors.
President Zelensky has stood up for his nation and unified it showing impressive courage, while the killer Putin obviously wanted to murder him as he usually does.
Ukraine needed a lot of hardware. Given how well Ukraine has showed its case, it has already received an impressive amount of that hardware, stingers and anti-tank weapons. The patriotism, courage and loyalty among all Ukrainian forces is truly impressive.
Just as in the Finnish Winter War, I think that the defender, Ukraine, is likely to surprise the world, but given that Ukraine is so much bigger, has so much more soldiers and arms, Ukraine may soon go to the offensive and clean up these aggressing Russian conscripts.
The problem is that bunker Putin is then likely to use ever more illegal and awful arms to bomb his brother people into the stone age. The West must not allow that! Is NATO an ngo or a military alliance? NATO will be next. NATO must set up a no-fly zone over Ukraine.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Today, the EU sanctioned 160 Russians, 146 members of the Russian Federation Council (well-deserved) & 14 oligarchs as well as their family members. Are these really the right people? No, the top & worst people are not sanctioned, mainly the second level. eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/…
The people who should have been sanctioned are 1. Roman Abramovich (too well-connected, with Chabad). 2. Iskander Makhmudov, truly terrible. 3. Suleiman Kerimov, US sanctioned, fronting for Putin on a big scale. 4. Oleg Deripaska, US sanctioned. 5. Boris Rotenberg, US sanctioned.
6. Leonid Mikhelson, co-owner of crony Timchenko in Novatek & Sibur. 7. Putin's 4 cousins that have gained at least $0.5 bn each according to Russian Forbes. 8. All Putin's childhood friends who hold money for him.
It is unfortunate that all these people have been omitted.
Rethinking Russia sanctions: 1. The threat of sanctions on Russia failed as a deterrence, because the West was never credible. Western politicians talked about "sanctions to hell" ever so often but did nothing. Putin concluded that nothing would happen.
2. Putin and all his bankers claimed the sanctions of 2014 were ineffective, while @MSnegovaya and i argued that they shaved off about 2.5% of GDP each year 2014-20. Nobody cared about reality, but Russia's GDP did not grow for 7 years. atlanticcouncil.org/wp-content/upl…
3. Before invading Ukraine, Putin thought that Western sanctions have little impact and that the West will do little in the future. He was completely wrong on both accounts. The West, especially Europe was shocked by his stupidity, lawlessness & cruelty & did everything.
Garry Kasparov makes absolutely brilliant interview on Ukraine. All right & highly eloquent in Russian. A few ideas:
Putin will go as far as he can. He must be stopped by Western force. He will continue beyond Ukraine otherwise.
The Russian people today have very little information and are therefore inert. They need to see how harmful Putin is. The best way of doing so is to impose maximum sanctions on Russia and to show Putin's war crimes.
The best hope that Putin is taken out is that the generals who do not want to die together with him realize that he is a deadender who cannot win and can only endanger them. Therefore, the West must do as much as possible against him. The war has already started.
The essence of the Budapest Memorandum of December 1994: 1. Russia, the UK & the US "reaffirm their commitment to Ukraine"...to respect the independence and sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine" web.archive.org/web/2014031718…
2. Russia, the UK & the US "reaffirm their obligation to refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of Ukraine, and that none of their weapons will ever be used against Ukraine."
4. Russia, the UK & the US "reaffirm their commitment to seek immediate [UNSC] action to provide assistance to Ukraine...if Ukraine should become a victim of an act of aggression or an object of a threat of aggression in which nuclear weapons are used;"
How to understand Putin's war in Ukraine. 1. It is not about Nato, EU, USSR or even Ukraine. Putin needs a war to justify his rule & his swiftly increasing domestic repression. 2. Putin is today's Hitler & 24 Feb 2022 should be seen as 1 Sep 1939. Ukraine is Putin's Poland.
3. This is an all-out war. Putin will not stop or de-escalate. He will escalate & proceed until he is stopped by someone at home or abroad. 4. If Putin succeeds in succumbing Ukraine (which I don't think), he would proceed to other countries, perhaps in Africa or Europe.
5. Exactly as with Hitler, the war will only end when Putin is defeated, ousted or dead. 6. It is really all about Putin, not about neo-imperialism, Russian nationalism or even the KGB. 7. Given what Russia does, the West/US/NATO can hardly avoid getting into this war.
The US has just issued new Russia sanctions. Two real oligarchs have been sanctioned, Alisher Usmanov & NIkolay Tokarev, just sanctioned by the EU. Good. Already sanctioned Yevgeny Prigozhin has been sanctioned with family. What difference does it make? home.treasury.gov/news/press-rel…
The a whole lot of disinformation agencies and agents from MID, SVR, GRU & FSB have been sanctioned, but none of them is senior or even publicly known, unlike the dozen top disinformers just sanctioned by the EU. Very disappointing. The US: get serious about disinformation!
ABC claims that 19 oligarchs and Putin's chief disinformer Peskov will be sanctioned, but the Treasury has only named two oligarchs so far, Usmanov and Tokarev. Hoping for more. abcnews.go.com/Politics/us-an…