2/ Yes, it's a huge breach of #SCOTUS confidentiality, unlike anything I've seen in my 25 years of following and writing about the Court. (And it's a huge scoop for @alexbward and @joshgerstein of @Politico; whoever leaked to them put a lot on the line.)
3/ Please note: my post is about the leak itself, not the substance of the opinion or underlying issue of abortion.
For a reader's guide to the opinion, here's one by @EdWhelanEPPC, with page references to different sections:
4/ Please note the UPDATES I have added to my post since it went out as a @SubstackInc newsletter, mentioning the midterms and linking to a @guardian roundup of reactions (incl. a statement by @RickGarnett that I totally agree with).
6/ And additional comments from Chief Justice Roberts, stating that he has directed the Marshal of the Court to launch an investigation into the leak, via @ShannonBream (thread).👇
1/ I realize @ProfDBernstein is speaking tongue in cheek, but I do like how district judges sometimes share draft dispositions with the parties and let them point out factual errors, analytical issues, and the like. #SCOTUS#appellatetwitter
I do think this presents some logistical challenges, including crazy lobbying after the release of initial drafts in controversial cases, but it's an interesting thought experiment.
1/ A thoughtful thread by @LeanLawStrategy about the recent free-speech controversy at Yale Law School that raises an important, largely overlooked consideration: what does this say about legal education?👇👇👇
2/ Let's remember that @YaleLawSch is a LAW SCHOOL (at least in theory; I sometimes joke about my alma mater, which has a reputation for being theory-focused, that it's "a Ph.D. program where you can take the bar exam at the end").
1/ THREAD. I have appended an update/correction to my Original Jurisdiction post from yesterday about the March 10 protest at Yale Law School.
The disruption was much worse than I originally reported. Here's the text of my update on @YaleLawSch.
2/ It wasn't just the event that was disrupted.
Classes were disrupted too, including Federal Courts (Judith Resnik) and Advanced Legal Writing (Rob Harrison).
The latter was in Room 121—the room farthest away from Room 127, where the event took place.
3/ Students in Federal Courts, across the hall from the event, reported that "the floor was shaking" and Professor Resnik asked on-call students to "yell" so they could be heard over the din.
1/ THREAD. Sigh. Here are my thoughts on recent free-speech controversies at @UCHastingsLaw, where @ishapiro was shouted down, and @YaleLawSch, where a @YaleFedSoc event was disrupted (but at least not "canceled").
2/ Some folks think I'm overly critical of law school administrators and faculty on these issues.
So I'd like to take this occasion to give props to Dean @DavidFaigman of UC Hastings and Professor Kate Stith of Yale Law for how they handled tough situations.
1/ THREAD. Good news: my #COVID19 antibody levels are literally off the charts. On a test where >0.79 is positive, my titer is >2,500.👇
2/ But I believe the test I took, Elecsys® Anti-SARS-CoV-2 S, measures antibodies to the spike protein, i.e., from vaccination. So I think I’d need to take a nucleocapsid antibody test to learn if I had Omicron. bit.ly/3Glx7Xo
3/ I think I might have had Omicron in December 2021, but I never tested positive on either a PCR or antigen test (perhaps because I didn’t get tested until having had symptoms for 5-7 days).