Putrino Lab Profile picture
May 4, 2022 22 tweets 9 min read Read on X
Ok. Another request, another 🧵. Today, we address the strained relationship between psychology, psychiatry and #LongCovid. Much of this may also apply to #pwME and other infection-associated chronic illnesses (h/t again @microbeminded2) and other “invisible” illnesses (1/n)
Psychology and psychiatry have a complex history with syndromic illnesses. Why? When illnesses are diagnosed on the basis of symptoms rather than “objective” tests, some clinicians will doubt the reality of the condition. Let’s start by psychoanalyzing them, shall we? (2/n)
This behavior is not justifiable, scientific or ethical. But it is also is not new: in the 1800s, tuberculosis was regarded by most physicians as the “disease of the sensitive” before tubercule bacillum was discovered, the “cancer personality” was touted for decades (3/n)
in “modern medicine”, before being famously called out by Susan Sontag in her book “AIDS and its metaphors” as she brilliantly concluded that we ‘metaphorize conditions that we do not understand’. Unfortunately this “clinical fragility” has continued into the present day (4/n)
Ask @Dysautonomia how many people with #POTS/#dysautonomia are diagnosed with anxiety prior to receiving an actual diagnosis of dysautonomia (years later)? Or how many #pwME in the #MECFS community have been actively harmed by the now-discredited-but-not-discredited enough (5/n)
“PACE trial”, which led to the famous statement that all people with #MECFS need to recover is “exercise and positive thinking”. We could go on, but suffice to say, there has been a legacy of horrific damage associated with the tendency to psychologize illnesses that are (6/n)
poorly understood on a physiological level. This is hard to recover from, and I think that #medtwitter treating #LongCovid and other infection-associated chronic illnesses need to be aware of the emotional labor they are asking of a patient when they refer to psych services (7/n)
as well as the rationale behind the referral to psych so that the person does not feel they are being “abandoned to psych” with no other treatment options being presented. With all of that said, what are some roles for psych services in #LongCovid?
1. Working through the (8/n)
emotions associated with the diagnosis of a chronic condition. FACT: #LongCovid is a highly debilitating chronic condition with (as yet) no cure. People with LC are likely to feel grief and other strongly negative emotions around this fact. Psychologists can be helpful in (9/n)
working through these emotions, assisting them with strategies for regulating these emotions (more on this later) and helping them with associated feelings of depression and anxiety that may develop in response to their diagnosis (psychiatry may be looped in here in cases (10/n)
where meds are indicated).
2. Helping people with #LongCovid navigate changes in relationships due to their diagnosis. One of the cruelest facets of #LongCovid is its ability to isolate those who live with it. Those with LC may look (mostly) like the same person, but (11/n)
they are not. One of the first things to go is socializing. For those without #LongCovid, let’s take a moment to acknowledge how stressful/draining it must be to manage 15+ intermittent, terrifying and uncontrolled symptoms whilst trying to engage in social interaction (12/n)
we can’t really ever understand, but suffice to say, most people with #LongCovid learn to avoid it right quick. There is a reason that those with #MECFS have championed the hashtag #MillionsMissing - because that is what these illnesses do: they put you on the missing list (13/n)
Families, friends, work colleagues, etc don’t understand: “you don’t *look* sick”, and this leads to near constant gaslighting. An important part of self-care in these situations is understanding that being equipped with emotion-regulation techniques in these moments can (14/n)
save you from experiencing a flare or crash as a result of the stress and emotional exertion that a negative interpersonal interaction that can bring about, which leads me over to 3) regulation, regulation, regulation: #LongCovid is indeed a condition of consequence. (15/n)
Exertion harms people with #LongCovid and exertion can take different forms: physical, cognitive and emotional, for instance. Pacing and regulation are *just as important* for your emotional labor as it is for physical and cognitive. A good psychologist can help you with (16/n)
emotion regulation strategies to help with stressors that you are hitting in your daily life that are causing setbacks for your health. Beyond these 3 main points on the role of psych services in #LongCovid care, I want to acknowledge that in very rare cases we have seen (17/n)
severe psychosis related to (we think) immune-mediated encephalitis which has required immediate and aggressive medical management, and that neuropsychologists can have an important role (re: my last thread) in assisting with #LongCovid-related cognitive dysfunction (18/n)
I also want to restate clearly that if a healthcare provider is psychologizing your #LongCovid rather than recommending psych services as *supportive care* to deal with issues that have been caused by LC, not the other way around, find a new provider ASAP. (19/n)
Finally, we must acknowledge that many cannot afford or access the psych services that they need and that is a shameful fact. To these individuals, I say embrace your community: the psychological benefits of peer support are incredibly robust and powerful. Every single day (20/n)
I feel grateful knowing that there are groups like @itsbodypolitic (and so many others!) out there who create safe and responsible spaces for people with #LongCovid to share their experiences and support one another through challenges. Please take advantage of peer (21/n)
support groups in the #LongCovid community, as there are few things more additionally damaging to a person with a chronic illness than social isolation. As always - apologies if I have left something obvious or non-obvious out of the thread. I hope this has been helpful 🙏🏻 (end)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Putrino Lab

Putrino Lab Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @PutrinoLab

Mar 25
Excerpt of an email received by a mentee of mine who is currently transitioning to independence as a career researcher. This is happening all over the country right now. The “equity research” my mentee was proposing was centered around novel neurotechnologies that increase the 1/ Image
safety, privacy and independence of people with disabilities. Canceling programs like this doesn’t make America great, it makes America weak, behind the times, not at the bleeding edge of innovation and just kinda mean. Canceling programs that uplift early career scientists 2/
doesn’t “cut waste” and put “America first”, it encourages promising scientists to leave because opportunities are better elsewhere and they can more easily do great science in another location. America loses out so that the 1% can thrive further by creating environments that 3/
Read 4 tweets
Mar 15
Two steps forward, one step back. For #LongCOVID awareness day today I had the honor of joining thousands of other New Yorkers in a peaceful protest to stand against many of the current administration’s recent damaging and thoughtless policies and executive orders. Let there 1/
be no misunderstandings here: many of the executive orders and policies being proposed and passed into law will erase entire populations of historically and currently excluded communities. Under the facile goal of “improving efficiency”, decisions are being made that not only 2/
harm the vulnerable, but weaken a nation by taking away its true strengths: diversity, morality and innovation. Today of all days, my ask of the complex chronic illness community to take heart: if it is the wish of this administration to start a constitutional street-fight, 3/
Read 8 tweets
Feb 20
A tumultuous 24-ish hours since our preprint was released yesterday. I mentioned that this was a fraught issue and I genuinely do understand that people have mixed feelings about the work. I wanted to take some time to respond to some of the concerns and comments that have 1/
arisen. First, and most importantly: #LongCOVID (LC) and post-vaccine syndrome (PVS) both exist. Anyone claiming that all LC or even *most* LC is actually PVS is unserious and is making up nonsense that is not supported by the consensus science. I cannot stress this strongly 2/
enough. While we're talking about Long COVID and its clear distinction from PVS, I'd like to remind people that my team was talking about persistent effects of acute COVID in April and May of 2020. By November of 2020, we pre-printed our first LC paper:
3/medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
Read 22 tweets
Feb 19
Grateful to continue to be able to do great work with the amazing team at @YaleMed, led by @VirusesImmunity and @hmkyale. Today one of our preprints dropped on what is a fraught and divisive topic: vaccine injury or post-vaccine syndrome (PVS). Before
1/medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
we dig into the results, I want to state a few things very clearly about the team that conducted this work:
- We firmly believe in the value of vaccinations. However, we also believe that drugs will always have side-effects in a percentage of the population. Holding these two 2/
beliefs are not mutually exclusive and so important for honest and transparent discourse with the community.
- We have been studying PVS for many years and listening to the community since PVS cases started to emerge. This is a hard topic to study. People don't want to fund 3/
Read 16 tweets
Feb 13
This is an amazing example of how certain things simply cannot be broken down to a magic pill or formula and I think this is a wonderful #scicomm learning opportunity.

Note the communication from @hubermanlab. 1) Makes a statement about how a key opinion leader says you can 1/
*dramatically* increase endurance and strength. 2) Makes the caveat (“start slow”). Simple, direct, informative. Right?

Ok, so what’s the secret?
- Once a week, jog a mile with a kettle bell that is equal to 30% of your own weight in a briefcase carry. Switch arms from time 2/
to time. Start slow.

As a performance guy, and in consensus with many of the other performance folks who have already commented: This is an insanely hard physical task to do. The average Joe off the street SHOULD NOT try this.

When challenged, the caveat was raised: “I said 3/
Read 10 tweets
Feb 11
Honored to be a part of the work led by @polybioRF and @microbeminded2 published in @TheLancetInfDis discussing actionable strategies to adequately address SARS-CoV-2 persistence in #LongCovid. This paper covers discourse on how to look for and measure severity of persistence 1/
so that it can be used as an outcome measure in clinical trials, discussion about promising antiviral and monoclonal agents: what has the best chance of working and when combination therapies should be considered, the critical need for more sophisticated clinical trial designs 2/
such as adaptive platform trials and guidance on the recruitment of diverse populations into clinical trials: these drugs affect people with different hormonal profiles and different genetic profiles differently. To offer true precision medicine for pw LC, representation in 3/
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(