Because of recent wrong assumptions about "separatism"🧵

86% of Ukrainians want to become member of the EU (rating group poll) 79% in Eastern Ukraine, 84% in Southern Ukraine.

Let's take a look back at 2014, when Ukraine seemed far less united, and get ready for some surprises
Source KIIS survey 2014

"Do you support the idea, that your region should secede from Ukraine and join Russia? "

Zaporizhia region 17,5% rather no & 64% no
rather yes 4,0% or yes 2,2%

Kherson region 11,1% rather no 73,5% no
rather yes 2,5 or yes 1,0%
"Do you support the idea, that your region should secede from Ukraine and join Russia? "

Luhansk region 20,6% rather no, 31,3% no vs. 17,1 rather yes, 13,2% yes

Donetsk region 17,3% rather no, 34,9% no vs. 15,6% rather yes and 11,9% yes
"Do you support introduction of Russian troops into Ukraine?"
It is reasonable to say, that in 2022 these figures are much higher in favor of Ukrainian unity, cause we know that the support for EU membership was smaller back then.

2022 May (67%) & October (79%) pro EU in Eastern Ukraine (Center f Insight in Survey Research / Rating group)
In Donbas there was an area ("DNR/LNR") controlled by RU🇷🇺 proxies. People within these territories and in government controlled areas were asked about their opinion in 2019.

Not even the residents flooded with RU-propaganda and disinfo for years answered in favor of separatism
Do you remember, when armed Russian proxies and warlords occupied administrative buildings in Ukraine and proclaimed "people's republics"?

"Do you support actions of those, who with arms capture administrative buildings in your region?"
Conclusion:

In 2014, there were different ideas in Ukraine about the geopolitical orientation, but this does not mean that there was a relevant separatist movement. After the Russian aggression in 2014/2022, Ukrainian identity & pro-European orientation developed significantly.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dietmar Pichler 🇪🇺🇺🇦

Dietmar Pichler 🇪🇺🇺🇦 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DietmarPichler1

Oct 5
In Österreich ist das Z Symbol noch immer straffrei, ich habe hier zB eine Person bei einer Querdenker-Demo mit "Z" T-Shirt gesehen, ein ukrainischer Journalist berichtete. @ReinholdLopatka
@HBrandstaetter @PetraBayr
@dziedzic_ewa @Alma_Zadic

Siehe🇩🇪⬇️
taz.de/Sachsens-Justi…
Das Z kann auch keine andere Bedeutung gehabt haben, weil darunter auch noch steht "Armija Rossija", also "Russische Armee".
Ich hab mich bereits im März bezüglich einer gesetzlichen Handhabe gegen Z-Kriegspropanda angefragt, bisher aber ohne Erfolg. Danke aber nochmal an die @Stadt_Wien für sie Entfernung von Z Symbolen, in der Leopoldstadt war ein ganzer Hof damit beschmiert, wurde alles übermalt.
Read 4 tweets
Oct 4
Some observations, I can't say exactly to what extent they influence the discourse.🧵

1) "Eastern Europe experts" are usually focused on Russia's affairs. Sometimes they have even adopted Russian points of view, but even a bigger problem is, that they have rarely studied Ukraine
2)
The myth of "Moscow's legitimate sphere of influence": people socialized in the Cold War era are grateful that the nuclear threat from the USSR is gone, that the Berlin Wall has fallen, but they do not have much empathy for the countries that regained independence in 1991.
That applies even to Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia, EU memberstates since almost 20 years. Even so called historians or "experts" ignore their experiences and expertise as "based on their history", and "not objective", or not "up to date".
Read 7 tweets
Oct 3
"Z" and Mullahs united #IranProtests

I have already seen several profiles spreading pro-Iranian disinfo/conspiracy theories alongside Russian propaganda.

They fantasize about a "US coup", as if these brave women don't have every reason to fight for their rights and freedom. 🧵
The goal is to discredit the movement that supports the protesters: "It is another color revolution staged by the CIA and the Zionists" or "the protesters we see in Western countries are Jews and not real Iranians."

Anti-Semitism is a constant part of the narrative
Iran is an ally of Russia and also a weapon supplier during the war against Ukraine. Rallies by Iranian civil society in support of Ukraine were suppressed by the Mullah regime. Russian press agencies are spreading the view of the Iranian regime about the protests...
Read 4 tweets
Sep 30
Putin's speech disinformation & propaganda 🧵

He implies again that people were not allowed to speak Russian in Ukraine. Putin claims the borders after 1991 were random, people were not asked. This is also false. Referenda in 1991 were recognized by the international community.
He asks for a minute of silence for Sachartchenko and Arsen Pavlov. Arsen Pavlov was a war criminal from Moscow and leader of the ultranationalist Bataillon Sparta. Sachartchenko once said, "we should conquer Kyiv, Berlin, England and restore the borders of the Russian Empire".
Putin speaks about sovereign nations (implies that EU/NATO countries are not sovereign nations). In reality of course, Russia does not accept sovereign nations in his neighborhood.
"The masters of Ukraine are in the West" #Conspiracytheory
Read 8 tweets
Sep 26
A little guide to avoid #bothsidesism & #victimblaming in the context of Russia's war against #Ukraine (thread))🧵

Civilian casualties -> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
🇷🇺War crimes-> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
Energy&food crisis-> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
Destructions in🇺🇦> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
FIN🇫🇮 goes NATO-> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
SWE🇸🇪goes NATO-> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
Sanctions vs RU🇷🇺->cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
🇷🇺Infiltration camps > cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
Diplomatic isolation of RU🇷🇺> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
New visa policy for 🇷🇺citizens> cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
Arms supplies to Ukraine🇺🇦 > cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
Cultural and sports boykott > cause: Russian invasion of Ukraine
Read 4 tweets
Sep 24
Kuriose Querfrontdemo in Wien: Linke Splittergruppen, MFG, "Friedensbewegte", Russlandaktivisten.

Tenor: "Plandemie", "böser Hygienestaat", raus mit den Sanktionen, "Frieden mit Russland", Alternativmedien statt "Systemhetze", böser Westen/Nato/EU hat Russland attackiert🧵 Image
Es wurde betrauert, dass es KenFM und RT so schwer gemacht wird. Menschen ohne Maske, gegen Waffenlieferungen und Sanktionen und gegen die Impfung würden diskriminiert werden...
Wir würden an Zensur leiden, nicht sie Wahrheit zur Ukraine erfahren.
Wieder wird eine völlig verdrehte Sicht der letzten 8 Jahre verbreitet, "wir brauchen Frieden und Freundschaft mit Russland", die "USA erlaubt es aber nicht".
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(