Mere hours till the #RingsofPower finale. I'm trying to keep my expectations in check because I just don't know if it's possible to wrap this up in a way that will truly satisfy me (YMMV, of course). Naturally, the (potential and thoroughly teased) Sauron reveal has me on edge.
Before the show actually aired and we were getting short clips and stills my suspicions about The Stranger were tempered by the fact that it just seemed...too obvious. But the idea that Galadriel happened to be, unbeknownst to her, lost at sea with the very person she was hunting
Well that was kinda wonderful. I've always liked the idea of the show keeping us guessing on who Sauron might be. As I've said before, it's a literalization of something going on across the history of the texts that's been transformed into narrative. I like it. It's clever.
Sticking the landing though...
Then the "lost king" plot dropped and Halbrand started to go some places that didn't quite work for me assuming he *were* actually Sauron in "hiding" or "fleeing his past." If he isn't, there's some terrific irony that will be lost.
Around the same time I started to get the impression that all the Sauron misdirection was, in fact, misdirection meant to keep us from looking at the obvious: Annatar was already in Eregion or working his way into Eregion, whispering in Brimby's ear, influencing GG's decisions.
But then Adar dropped his confession. He didn't just "kill Sauron," he "split him open." Well that's an odd choice of words. "Split" implies division, though "open" implies exposure or even release. Assuming it's not just flowery language, there're a lot of places that could go.
Release from what? Some kind of spiritual captivity? Exposure of what? Some inner nature or truth? Split... into somethings? Or someones? I would never have even considered it before, but I don't know that a Sauron whose eala was split into multiple parts would shock me now.
So who knows.
Maybe "Annatar" is already in Eregion but some other part of Sauron is galavanting around calling himself "Halbrand." I'd still call this the longshot possibility. I think H=S OR S is already in E is more likely. As to which... well...
Considering the preview clip we got today (Brimby suggesting he *could* have had it done sooner), combined with that shot in the latest trailer of something blowing a hole in the side of Brimby's tower, I am more convinced Annatar has already been there...
Offered to help in some way (perhaps by using "the powers of the unseen world") but was rebuffed by GG, at which point GG and Brimby turned towards the idea of using "Silmaril light infused" Mithril. In this case the general idea that will lead to the Rings is Brimby's...
(Circular shape, portable object, etc.) I'm gonna guess that Brimby is going to try to use their tiny bit of mithril to craft this "crown" he mentions in the clip during the ep and it's not going to work (hence the hole being blown in the side of the tower).
Left with no choice
Either someone is going to relent and call on this "Annatar," or it's going to turn out "Halbrand" happens to have similar knowledge (perhaps on how to do this without mithril). How Adar's statement about S never acquiring the knowledge he needed will play into this I'm not sure.
But if "I'm a smith, let me help" Halbrand happens the moment this "crown" idea doesn't work out, I think we'll have our answer.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
If there is any one thing I can't forgive #Tolkien for either not writing or not preserving, it is the mysterious "Sauron: Arising and Fall of Men" that is referenced in the essay "The Awakening of the Quendi" in #NatureOfMiddleEarth. I have *thoughts* on this.
@MichaelFKane@7stars7siblings@srwestvik@Tolkien_erklart There was a long period before NoMe was published where portions of fandom—at least where and when I was involved—assumed the being described in the Anthrabeth must have been Sauron due to the timeline conflict...
To know that that is the direction Tolkien seems to have been going in his own mind is interesting. I don't know if he simply never wrote the piece he references here (with the being explicitly being Sauron) or if it was lost, but I dearly wish I could read it!
Sometimes I do vector illustration, often as a part of my graphic design work to create promotional pieces. This was used on the poster for a theatre production... 3/
a.i "Nothing is evil in the beginning" is the first line of this series, and I couldn't wish for a better one. In LotR this line is about Sauron and how far it is possible to fall when starting with good intentions.
2/ a.ii How the show intends to use this line is unclear. It's possible it could be as simple as describing life in Valinor: what was (or seemed like) an Eden—the rest of the monologue describes the world in terms of youth and innocence. But of note is the first montage we see:
3/ a.iii A group of children in white play a variation on Blind Man's Bluff, where each except the "blind man" appears to be making noise, some by tapping sticks on stones, to lead (or mislead) him. It feels idyllic and possibly is a metaphor for what will be Galadriel's quest
Twelve Days of Sauron, collected here all in one long thread. Like the Twelve Days of Christmas, but with fewer birds and more deception and torture. #12DaysOfSauron#TheRingsOfPower#Sauron
On the 12th Day of Sauron... a list of the things that I hope The Rings of Power gives to me, most of which have to do with Sauron, Galadriel, metaphysics, and moral complexity. #12DaysOfSauron. 1 day until the premiere of @LOTRonPrime 🧵1/24 #TheRingsOfPower#Sauron
You've probably noticed I like Sauron. Not that I'd want to have tea with him or anything—that sounds like a bad idea—but I mean I enjoy him as a character, which is something a lot of people find odd, because they see him as one-dimensional or without need for complexity... 2/24
or because they don't understand why anyone would find a villain—any villain—interesting. Certainly no one is obliged to, but if modern fandom is any indication, it's not really such an unheard of thing. Villains *can* be very interesting, especially (I think) their Falls. 3/24
On the 11th Day of Sauron, linguistics gave to me: Sauron's actual, real—no joke—original name and the fact that it means things like "admirable, excellent, splendid, and... precious". #12DaysOfSauron. 2 days until the premiere of @LOTRonPrime 🧵1/13 #TheRingsOfPower#Sauron
In a bundle of linguistic notes dated to between 1955-1960, containing work on a list of meanings of names and words in LotR, and published in the linguistic journal Parma Eldalamberon in 2007, we learn that Sauron's original name was "Mairon" meaning "The Admirable." 2/13
This comes from the primitive Quenya root MAY- meaning ‘excellent/admirable.’ Related roots include (A)MAY- (‘suitable, useful, proper, serviceable, right’); it’s inverse, PEN- (‘lack’); and MA3- (‘serve, be of use‘ but also ‘handle, manage, control, wield’ and ‘hand’). 3/13