Rabbi Mike Profile picture
Dec 12 25 tweets 6 min read
Well, even though Twitter is becoming a dumpster fire, I will continue to teach as long as I can until it is simply not worth it anymore. So with that, I'd like to do a #thread about the differences between Jewish and Christian thought processes and the ramifications. #threads
One of the greatest challenges I face in Jewish-Christian relations is the challenge Christians face in trying to understand Jewish thought processes and interpretations. They attempt to see Judaism through a Christian lens which, inevitably, fails. It's important to see why./1
Often I teach the phrase, "Judaism is about deed, not creed." Christianity has creeds. You believe this. You pledge that. This is the answer. That's it. Judaism does not. Any question to a learned Jewish person is inevitably answered with, "yes but..." meaning there.../2
...is a staunch complexity behind the answer. That is because Judaism cherishes the questions. The answers are, "well this rabbi said this, but this rabbi said that." or "The Torah said this, but some rabbis think this, and some think that..." etc. It is the nuance, yes.../3
...the nuance that gives meaning. It is why Jews have (or had, until Christians had their way) the largest libraries in the world. It is why we have the idiom "2 Jews, 3 opinions." The conversation, the study, the argument, the source material and interpretation, this is.../4
...what gives Judaism its beauty, its meaning. And, not to be too direct, it matches how the human mind processes ideas, with what is known as critical thinking. I shudder at Jews who say "this is what Judaism says." Judaism has never said one thing. And it doesn't now. /5
Learned Jews understand that yes there are majority opinions that have become put in place, but we retain the minority opinions because they may one day become relevant again. Times change, people change, the world changes, and the answers from long ago do not always work. /6
This is why Judaism continues to evolve and change, whether from Torah and Biblical thought, to cultic Temple rituals, to rabbinic and oral law, to halacha, agadah, commentary etc. Jewish study is to be done in "hevruta" at least with two people. Why? Because your thoughts.../7
...alone are simply not enough. In order to think critically, you need another mind, at least one other mind, to help you challenge yourself, the text, the interpretation.
Now, how is this different from Christianity? I do not mean to generalize, but having studied Christian /8
...history, thought, and canon, what jumps out is simple creeds of faith. This is what it means. This is what we belief. End of story. This has troubling ramifications internally and externally, the least of which is a failure to understand Judaism. What are some internal /9
...ramifications of creed, and short simplistic answers of faith? Well, for one, if you question something you are not praised, as you would be in Judaism. In Judaism, the question is what gives meaning. Christian creed and canon leaves little room for questions. Instead../10
...if you question, you are seen as someone diverting from the flock. Your faith must be weak. Something must be wrong with you. This is your fault. There are elements of shame, guilt, and toxicity that inevitably follow this mindset. Examples include ideas about.../11
...sexuality, purity, and the like. More simply put, when Christians want people to have "decorum" what they mean is they want "obedience." Obedience to faith is simply not a natural understanding in the human mind. Faith does not stand on a one sentence declaration. /12
Faith is complex, and it sits on a tower of sand. This leads to the external problems. Why did Christians (and still to this day) burn Jewish libraries, outside sources, and attempt to shelter their flock from the outside world? It is because the "faith" is not strong.../13
...enough to take criticism, nuance, and conflicting information. Christianity has for millennia relied up on "might is right," meaning that the faith is strong because so many people have it. I have been told this on multiple occasions in my discussions. "How can 3 billion/14
...people be wrong about something?" Well, if Christians were taught HOW their answers were crafted, they would understand. Most are taught simply, "this is what we believe" or "this is what Jesus said,"when really it was much later, perhaps a church father or a later writing/15
...that came from someone with a differing agenda, and it has now become canon, now become part of the creed. This brings fear and toxicity to the outside world, thus leading to the motivation to not only burn books and libraries, but to engage in genocide of "non-believers"/16
This is compounded by threats of eternal damnation, that if you break the "faith" or question it, not only is something wrong with you, but an eternity of torment awaits you. Think about what this does to the human psyche. Think about how one must shape their world to feel /17
...that this is an acceptable way to live. Then think of the trauma brought to so many Christians who express critical thinking towards the "faith." Think about those who ostracize their own children for being LGBTQ+ or atheists, those who are told they are wrong for thinking/18
...different thoughts. Think about the abusive words Christians have heard inside churches, that all blame is on you, you are worthless, a sinner, and only Jesus can save you from yourself, and if you don't fully give yourself to the creed, you will be nothing in the eyes/19
of a God that would happily send you into the arms of demons and the devil for eternity to suffer.
Now, think about why the antisemitic tropes exist about Jews "controlling the world." Why are there so many Jewish Nobel Prize winners? Christians are quick to say it must /20
...be rigged! It does not occur to them that Jews are built to be critical thinkers. To be creative. To ask questions, and find different ways to think about the world. Why are Jews so successful despite Christian laws in place to restrict them for 2,000 years? Because Jews/21
and all of Judaism teaches that we should find ways around things, think creatively, find success elsewhere and in different ways. The arrogance of the creed of Christianity leads to confusion and jealousy. A Christian thinks, "why am I not as successful? I do as I'm told." /22
It never occurs to them that it is the creed itself, the restrictions of "faith" that keeps them from their own success, that teaches them to obey rather than to find new creative ways to think and work. For a Christian, one must "break out" of the restrictions, whereas for.../23
...Jews, it is a natural occurrence.
Again, I speak of Christian canon and faith, and am generalizing. But if Christians truly wish to engage in talks with Jews, they must let go of the Christian ideals of obedience and creed, and enter our world of nuance. Come and learn.
/END

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Rabbi Mike

Rabbi Mike Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @RabbiHarvey

Dec 10
So I have to share this conversation I had with my son because it was quite a challenge to try to be respectful but also try to speak in 7-year-old terms. My son was in the car and passed some houses with Christmas decorations and when we passed a nativity scene he asked…/1
A: Abba, what’s that thing with all the poor people?

Me: What?

A: I see them everywhere, there’s people, in like a barn, they look poor, what is it?

Me: (thinks for a moment) you mean the scenes with the people standing around the baby?

A: Yeah! What is that?
/2
M: Well, remember how I told you about how Christians believe different things than we do. They believe that baby is the birth of their god.

A: No wonder there’s a baby in all of them. But if that’s god, who are God’s parents?

M: Oh, well. It’s actually their God’s son.
/3
Read 6 tweets
Dec 8
Well since Sodom is trending AGAIN and a ridiculous Christian nationalist CRIED on the floor of congress about allowing Gay marriage be a thing, let's talk seriously about LGBTQIA in the Bible. #Thread #threadstorytime #Threads
Let's start off with the obvious point. Whatever's in the bible, good or bad, doesn't matter. America is not a Christian nation, and representatives uphold the Constitution (a secular document) not any particular bible. So, that should be the end of it. Sadly it's not. /2
While Christians sure love to talk about how the Torah and its laws are something Jesus "fulfilled" for them so they don't have to obey anymore, they sure do like coming back to Torah law when it suits them. The Torah law was given to the nation of Israel, not to Christians./3
Read 32 tweets
Nov 21
Dearest Progressive Christian clergy,
Antisemitism is on the rise. It is being thrown at from all angles. From anti-Zionism, to Black Hebrew Israelites, from White Supremacists to Christian Nationalists. From charges of deicide to charges of Jewish conspiracies.../1
and blood libel.
While we cannot do much about those malicious and bent on destroying Judaism, there ARE things we can do to help those caught up in the unknown, who don't recognize the origins of antisemitism or where antisemitism lurks in the shadows of Christian texts.../2
liturgies, or beliefs.
It is for this reason that I wrote my book. It is for these people that I hoped to be the audience.
Please, PLEASE use your platforms on social media and on the pulpit to teach from my book, talk about my book, or reference it as a resource. /3
Read 6 tweets
Nov 21
A troubled young man who is caught in fundamentalist Christianity believes the Bible is "absolute truth" and that there are no contradictions in the Word of God. I know I'll never convince this poor man but I will use this as an opportunity to teach: #thread
Let's begin with Bereshit (Genesis). Chapter 1 of Genesis suggests that first the plants were created Genesis 1:11-12), followed by animals (Genesis 1:20-25), and finally man – male and female together (Genesis 1:27). /2
However in chapter 2, man is created first (Genesis 2:7) followed by vegetation (Genesis 2:8-9), with the text emphasizing that there was no point in creating plants prior to the appearance of man, and animals are created only in order to serve as a "helpmate" to man.../3
Read 16 tweets
Nov 20
Watching Munich - The Edge of War and a scene shook me to the core. It could be written in 2016, or in 2020. It is three friends in Munich in the early 1930s speaking about Hitler:
-I don’t want to go to this… this rally.
-Yeah, but I want to go to the rally.
/1
-[in German] You’re not going there.
-Pardon?
-You’re too drunk, Lena.
-I see. I’m too drunk.
-I’m going.
-Well, I won’t come. Not with you two.
-Okay, then don’t.
-[in English] Hugh will come.
-[sighs]
-Do I have to go?
-You have to actually see the man.
/2
-If he’s so ridiculous, why not just ignore him?
-Ignore him? We cannot ignore him. He’s dangerous!
-No, but this is fueling the fire, Lena.
-He’s…
-This is what he wants. Attention.
-He’s talking about things that matter!
-Oh, come on, Paul.
/3
Read 13 tweets
Nov 19
Join me today as I clean out my apartment preparing to move and ask you, twitterverse random questions to help me decide what to keep and what not to keep. For instance: should I keep my Boston Marathon 2004 windbreaker that I haven’t worn in 10 years?
Next question. I haven’t worn a tie since my retirement from the hellscape that is congregational work. I have designer ties (vineyard vines, Armani, Robert Talbots, Feragamo, etc) what do I do?
Okay esquire says a man should have a certain amount of suits. Black, blue, gray, pinstripe, etc. I have them all but haven’t worn many except black for years! What do I do?
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(