Who exactly has been advising #Brazil's ex-president?
7/ Extreme-right playbook, 2020s edition:
Lose the election?
❌Claim it was stolen.
❌Cast doubt on the electoral process
❌Attack the institutions of democracy.
Social media plays a huge role in making this possible.
8/ #Bolsonaro slinking away to Florida in weepy self-pity seemed odd.
Anyone know where he is this afternoon?
IF he's outside #Brazil, he has conveniently put distance between himself and & immediate legal consequences for whatever role he's just played in the #Brasilia siege.
9/ Remember, we know that Steve #Bannon & Jason Miller have been advising #Bolsonaro since he lost the election.
17/ Pro-#Bolsonaro rioters appear to smash cameras from the ceiling during #Brasilia siege.
18/ UPDATE: #Brazil's democratically-elected president #Lula orders security intervention to stop pro-#Bolsonaro siege of capitol #Brasilia.
19/ Democratically-elected President #Lula's address:
- Federal security intervention in #Brasilia
- Identified rioters will be punished
- Complicit Police & officials will be punished.
- Investigation will target financing for the siege
20/ NOW: Flashes & heavy crowd control gas clouds seen as authorities work to clear grounds #Brazil's National Congress building in #Brasilia.
21/ NOW: multiple government buildings including National Congress, Palace & Supreme Court cleared of pro-#Bolsonaro rioters.
Intense crowd control on the esplanade in front of National Congress in #Brasilia.
Still a large group remain in vicinity.
Reports of. 30 arrests.
22/ Arrest totals keep rising as night falls on the scene. 150 and counting per Globo.
Brazilian media commentators already talking about a failure of intelligence.
Large group of rioters currently remains West of the Palace of Justice.
23/ Police bus with smashed out windows carries off restrained rioters.
33/ Claimed to be the original of Brazil's 1988 constitution.¹
Which ended 21 years of dictatorship.
Makes me sick to my stomach.
¹OSINT: Maybe? Same cover. Original kept in museum section of the Supreme Federal Tribunal. Which was attacked today.
34/ "I have always been within the four lines of the Constitution" - Bolsonaro
The ex-president waited till the attack failed & his supporters been arrested & kicked out by riot squads before delivering this weak & evasive statement.
So familiar.
35/ Hashtag associated with #Bolsonaro supporters: "BrazilianSpring."
Very active today.
First, it's in English.
Second? Hard to imagine a Brazilian came up with the term...
Because it's the *middle of Brazil's scorching summer.*
Weird.
36/ Democratically-elected president @LulaOficial arrives.
"...The coup plotters who promoted the destruction of public property in Brasilia are being identified and will be punished. Tomorrow we resume work... Democracy always. Goodnight"
44/Wild. It took me thirty seconds find scores of Twitter accounts telling everyone exactly where to go to attack #Brasilia.
This was in plain sight.
46/ Another good follow, @msoares found accounts responding to coded tweets about the imminent #Brasilia siege tweeting questions like which "side" the military will be on during the attack.
47/ The sheer obviousness of tweets in the run-up is staggering.
Everything was spelled out in the thinnest of codes.
I think #Twitter was either willfully blind or utterly negligent as #Brazil careened towards an organized siege against the three branches of government.
48/ There appears to be a growing effort among #Bolsonaro supporters to construct a narrative that the ransacking was *actually* done by #Lula supporters / infiltrators.
A "PRO-ISRAEL TEAM WE CAN TRUST" designed to look like a #HarrisWalz campaign ad is micro-targeted to areas with a high muslim population around Dearborn, Michigan.
Meanwhile, same Musk-backed PAC has a "WHY PANDER TO PALESTINE?" ad micro-targeted to areas in Pennsylvania.
2/ Beyond targeting the national election, specific Senate & House races were also a focus of efforts. As were specific figures like @SenatorBaldwin, who was apparently a perennial target.
3/ @DarrenLinvill is absolutely right here.
This campaign exposed by the @ClemsonHub team still gives off early-day vibes.
It is only going to get more sophisticated from here.
Manufacturers of networking and phone gear must follow specific standards for 'lawful interception' in different jurisdictions (e.g. CALEA & ETSI's standards)
But as we learn time & time again, the scope of potential access & harm almost never matched by efforts to detect & block malicious use.
There's constant pressure from governments to bake-in systems for access.
Failure to comply with those demands is met with big sanctions. Just look at Durov.
Yet I predict that there will be zero meaningful accountability over this breach.
BREAKING: @Microsoft & @TheJusticeDept take simultaneous action against 🇷🇺Russian FSB-backed hacking group.
#StarBlizzard/ #ColdRiver has been targeting a wide swath of US officials & civil society.
Sweet moment because civil society played a key role in the lawsuit. Thanks to @NonprofitISAC & our partner @accessnow, voices of victims from our collaborative investigation into the spear phishing operation were included. 1/
2/ Back in August we @citizenlab alongside our partners
@accessnow w/@DeptFirst, Arjuna Team & RESIDENT.ngo published a collaborative investigation into Russian gov-backed phishing.👇
3/ Quick review of some ways that the Biden Harris administration has been tackling the problem of mercenary spyware proliferation:
Targeted Actions against bad companies:
Big headache
✅@CommerceGov Entity Listing
(Now US companies can't sell you products)
Migraine
✅ @StateDept Visa Bans
(You aren't coming to the US)
Cluster Headache
✅@USTreasury Dept Sanctions
(Your assets are blocked, good luck banking anywhere)
Executive Actions
✅ The 2023 Executive Order
(The big US market is closed to spyware companies enabling human rights abuse & natsec harms)
Diplomatic Efforts
✅ 2023 Joint State on Commercial Spyware
(Wide set of norms on stopping misuse, consequences for bad companies & transparency + oversight)
✅ Participation in other countries efforts (e.g. UK/FR-led Pall Mall Process)
Investigators will eventually identify any consumer product that persistently records people's activities.
One day, they'll show up, requesting access.
If the data is consistently helpful, they'll stop asking & start demanding.
Once this happens enough the company will probably create a law enforcement portal to simplify access & save customers the trouble...🧵
2/ So many companies build consumer products with inherent pervasive surveillance collection without planning for the inevitable moment when demands begin coming in.
If you collect it, the demands will always come.
When you don't anticipate this moment in how you balance your design decisions, you expose yourself & your consumers to a lot of pressure. And introduce society to new kinds of surveillance.
It's an ethical conundrum in societies with a rule of law and judicial oversight.
And it is entirely more ominous when your product reaches countries that have none of that.
3/ Transparency: reworked the thread since folks flagged that I'm not the only person that likes "if you collect it, they will come" to describe risks from data collection:
Some spots it shows up in, there are surely more I couldn't find with a quick search:
- ISC2 contributor mgorman discussing risks from Google's Sensorvault
-Whitney Merrill(@wbm312) discussing risks from COVID data collection👇
-The Irreal Blog, in an interesting post about search warrants
-Me, quoted in "Cybersecurity and Humanitarian Organizations - On a Collision Course?" (Amaral & Verity, 2018).