Back in 2019, we finished an UG project creating a timeline of #HVDC projects πππ and also added the what was then the newly proposed π¦πΊπΈπ¬ #suncable project.
This just looked at one aspect (the most technically challenging of all βοΈ) the undersea cable.
1/x
This just looked at one aspect (the most technically challenging of all βοΈ) the undersea cable.
1/x
https://twitter.com/GeoKonstantinou/status/1155660645544579072
I also wrote a (very short) article for the #VSC #HVDC newsletter that @OfficialUoM Prof. Mike Barnes was editing on the news coming out of Australia
Here are some figures that might help put the #suncable project in context.
2/x
Here are some figures that might help put the #suncable project in context.
2/x
*These are from 2020 when the project was the Australia - Singapore Power Link (ASPL) and part of Yihong Li's UG thesis @eetunsw
1. Cable Length vs Capacity. The 2 π’at ~1400MW are the ~700km, 515kV & 525 kV π¬π§π©π°& π¬π§π³π΄projects commonly used as comparison
3/x
1. Cable Length vs Capacity. The 2 π’at ~1400MW are the ~700km, 515kV & 525 kV π¬π§π©π°& π¬π§π³π΄projects commonly used as comparison
3/x
2. Rated #solar farm capacity vs area
This was originally announced as 10GW, later revised to 14GW (this figure) and then again up to 20GW since then.
4/x
This was originally announced as 10GW, later revised to 14GW (this figure) and then again up to 20GW since then.
4/x
3. #Battery rated capacity (MW) vs stored #energy (MWh).
There have been quite a few #BESS projects developed since then but all within the bottom left box where all π’are.
5/x
There have been quite a few #BESS projects developed since then but all within the bottom left box where all π’are.
5/x
In fact, we had to redraw the #BESS part of the project on an log scale in the x-axis to make a bit more sense of it!
6/x
6/x
Back on the cable and based on 2021 costs and publicly available information, this provides a rough cost estimate (or at least an indication) for MW-km costs.
*Many of these cables do not go as deep as #suncable and Murraylink is underground, not undersea!
7/x
*Many of these cables do not go as deep as #suncable and Murraylink is underground, not undersea!
7/x
A lot of commentary focuses on the losses across the cable, which, yes are going to be high in % due to the length, but as such a system would operate continuously and not intermittently, only affect the unit economics of $/MWh delivered in Singapore.
8/x
8/x
Instead, here are some other technical challenges that need to be worked out
1. How to operate the #Solar & #BESS at that scale as an island?
2. The #Darwin connection? Does it taper as a multiterminal? Does it convert back to AC and then back to DC?
9/x
1. How to operate the #Solar & #BESS at that scale as an island?
2. The #Darwin connection? Does it taper as a multiterminal? Does it convert back to AC and then back to DC?
9/x
3. How do you operate whatever you choose as the option from 2?
4. πΈπ¬ contingency operation? How do you plan for N-1 when one link is 15% of your infeed?
5. #BESS in πΈπ¬?
6. Maintenance and Faults?
6. How do the economics of all of the above stack up?
7. Competing supply?
10/x
4. πΈπ¬ contingency operation? How do you plan for N-1 when one link is 15% of your infeed?
5. #BESS in πΈπ¬?
6. Maintenance and Faults?
6. How do the economics of all of the above stack up?
7. Competing supply?
10/x
Really interesting to see how any and all of the above play out in the next few days / months / years.
11/11
11/11
β’ β’ β’
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
γ
