I was raped when I was inarguably among the strongest women in the 🌎… and he was just a guy.
When he grabbed my wrist, I quickly realized – in that slow-motion-adrenalin-awareness phenomenon – that I couldn’t move my arm in any direction: not even when using my lats in a downward motion, where swimmers excel.”
In law school, I learned to evaluate when the law considers women to be like men (“sameness feminism”), in an apples-to-apples comparison popularized by its famous proponent, Ruth Bader Ginsburg: places like the classroom and employment, generally. open.substack.com/pub/strongerwo…
I learned to contrast those with the places where it is permissible to formally sex-segregate, when men and women must be treated differently because they are different: “difference feminism.”
…Matters related to pregnancy and lactation, sports participation, and the permissibility of formal barriers erected to protect girls and women from male violence: All allow a “Separate and Equal” approach that would be prohibited in a racial context.
My academics helped me to understand rape as an expression of male power over women; to understand that there was no escape from the terrifying personal and political weapon known as rape. There would be no safety for me without safety for all of us.
Those 800 laps-per-day of our hard training were vital for calming my hyper-vigilant brain and PTSD.
Underwater I could safely vent socially unacceptable emotions: especially rage. I imagined a different ending, where I had a machete in my back pocket. 🗡️🩸
Women need sports.
Before the rape, men had felt like trustworthy peers. My male teammates and I goofed around in hotels, massaged each other’s muscles, stretched together. We relied on each other for inspiration & tips on form; we shaved each other’s backs. I even shaved some teammates’ heads.
Now I knew that men could employ their bodies as weapons.
I healed though:
- good friends who could listen to pain,
- accommodations from Duke,
- academic focuses,
- heavy workouts, that calmed my over-active brain, that wouldn’t listen to my scoldings: … “CALM THE F$CK DOWN.”
In class I saw how I’d unconsciously adopted the “just world fallacy,” which had kept me from being empathetic towards myself and other victims. (The fallacy includes the concept of karma: that rape victims must have done something to deserve their fate.)
It’s probably obvious that my personal history shapes my legal work at @iChampionWomen. It is a privilege to advocate for a better sporting environment for women, empowering them in ways that acknowledge our unique challenges. Thx @WSPWG & @TallMariah
Nonsense from non-athlete @feministgadfly, who confuses sex w gender identity, and argues that downplaying male/ female biological differences will address sexism:
#1: “We don’t really have much research-based evidence to say definitively that trans women have a disproportionate advantage in sports.”
— Yes we do, because TW are men, with or without testosterone suppression or surgery; both pre & post puberty. See citations:
#2: “Right now, we’re mostly working out of our deeply-held and rather largely unexamined assumptions about biology and gender”
— I graduated from Duke w a certificate in Women’s Studies in 1986, and the first class was the biology/ culture distinction. It’s examined.
#3: “The problem for Thomas and other trans women athletes is not trans bodies but rather the way we gender-segregate sports.”
- Sports are also segregated by age, by weight, by ability, and by sex.
The biggest performance gaps bt these categories? Sex.
If competing in Women’s sports, Thomas’ male body IS the problem,
.@iChampionWomen and the WSPWG submitted these comments to the @usedgov - asking them to promulgate clear rules: girls and women’s sports should be for girls and women.
No athlete gets to pick their competitive category. Facts, biology, science …not GI
The proposed regulations don’t provide clarity. Neighboring schools would undoubtedly. The physical safety risks to athletes, the school’s liability safety risks, would be untenable. #SportsLaw#SportsBiz
Instead, all eligibility rules must be easily understood and enforced nationally.
Sports teaches strategic thinking. But weirdly, the @NCAA is not listening; it’s doggedly pursuing a losing strategy: people are LESS empathetic to transgender athletes after they see males compete in our sports, denying female opportunities. #LosingStrategy@coachblade
NCAA leadership says the stated goal in policy-making is “not if transgender athletes are included, but how.”
We agree - of course those with diverse gender identities should compete in sports!
‼️Just not males in female sports‼️#OurBodiesOurSports 1/
“We want to have an environment that is fair, welcoming and inclusive for all of the athletes,”@IvyLeague’s Robin Harris said at the NCAA transgender session.
-Well then, allow science/ fact-based perspectives to present.
If that’s the goal… get males out of female spaces.2/
@CoachKiwi@lolobrollo@gwpurnell Oh @CoachKiwi - you’d have been so proud of @DukeU’s caring treatment of me - better than I was to myself. #Duke believed two things that altered my life: 1) THAT it happened. 2) THAT I was more emotionally broken than I was letting on. 1/
@CoachKiwi@lolobrollo@gwpurnell@DukeU •Duke allowed me to red-shirt from my full-athletic scholarship for a year.
◦I received full tuition, room, books, meal plan and student fees; I did not swim from the fall of 1981 until the start of fall 1982.
2/
@CoachKiwi@lolobrollo@gwpurnell@DukeU My dorm room required me to walk through woods, so Duke admin moved me onto the most desirable, most central location on campus, “Main West.”
•couldn’t sleep; Duke found me a single – again, on Main West.
•Duke allowed me to drop two classes immediately …
3/
Sally Jenkins @washingtonpost: July 27th, the same date #Simone got the twistes, 6 years ago @USAGym, Steve Penny and Scott Blackmun started actively #Gaslighting her.
— “If you think conduct like this is past tense for these organizations, think again. Throughout 2020 and 2021, the USOPC and USAG have perpetuated their coverup with civil court motions. They have hidden from accountability with bankruptcy proceedings.
…”They have demanded that in exchange for any civil settlement, Biles and others who suffered Nassar’s assaults issue blanket liability releases that would protect a rogue’s gallery of well-known abusers, as well as Penny.” 😱
I support @Simone_Biles 100%-protecting her emotional health & physical safety in a very dangerous sport. I'm in awe of her voice for Nassar survivors n the call for @USAGym transparency n reform - and grateful. And competing during #Covid19...1/ #Twistiesnytimes.com/2021/07/28/spo…
All the athletes are suffering from a year of lock-down #COVID19: "... the lack of regular competition for many athletes was the equivalent of a muscle atrophying, said Nancy Hogshead-Makar, a lawyer who won three gold medals and a silver in swimming at the 1984 LA Olympics." 2/
“It’s not that they’re choking; it’s not that they’re out of shape,” Hogshead-Makar said. “Almost no athlete goes for a year with no competition. There is no replacement, when all eyes are on you and you need to be able to perform when the time is right.” 3/