Thread by @rjmarr

What we are seeing - here in #RVA and across the country - is the unraveling of the myth of law enforcement
Thread 1/

slate.com/news-and-polit…

I use "myth" here deliberately, in the sense of a widespread narrative that may be grounded in truths, past or present, but becomes a part of the broader culture
2/

The myth is this: POLICE PROTECT US. They are the #ThinBlueLine that divides civilized society and the criminals -- shadowy, amoral, even feral, probably ethnic - that threaten our property and families
3/

The myth is perpetuated by pop culture - police procedurals, films, the maverick cop who doesn't play by the rules - it's all justified because they are going to shoot the bad guys who threaten us
4/

But #BLM and now #GeorgeFloyd have helped undermine the myth, showing how little truth it holds for communities of color and especially Blacks in this country; whoever the "us" is that are protected, it ain't them
5/

Miraculously, the protests have opened up (at least some) white eyes also. Multiple accounts on social media and elsewhere have hammered home how the "us" of police myth doesn't even apply to most white folks, from victims of rape/sexual assault to petty theft
6/

In reality, we have allowed an (increasingly militarized) security force to set up shop in the middle of our communities, with the myth used to justify all kinds of authoritarian rules and thuggish behavior
7/

Privilege allows many to ignore the costs, both financial and human, of having what is essentially an occupying army in our communities. "Just be respectful and obey the law" and nothing bad will happen!
8/

Of course, tell that to #BreonnaTaylor or and so many others. One of #BLM 's goals, only partially realized, is forcing privileged Americans to confront the falsity of the police myth through #saytheirnames
9/

But that task has been made easier in recent weeks, as Americans watch geared-up "soldiers" wage war against their own citizens - chemical warfare, beatings, torture - without any consequences for the perpetrators
10/

https://twitter.com/GoadGatsby/status/1272406679846617088

Local political officials, especially mayors, are of little help, because they are either so steeped in the myth that they believe it; or afraid of violating it, because their (white, wealthy) donors/voters still believe, partially or wholeheartedly, in the myth
11/

These true believers still see videos like what happened in #RVA, they think "why didn't they get out of the way?" Police still deserve deference, special treatment - their need to get somewhere is more important, because THEY KEEP US SAFE etc.
12/

https://twitter.com/DebBRVA/status/1271993610880323584?s=20

Plus police departments themselves are the most insular of bureaucracies, protected by "law-and-order" politicians who want to appear strong to their (again, white and wealthy) constituents
13/

(if reforming a bureaucracy is like turning an oil tanker, reforming a police department is like turning an oil tanker that is controlled by a heavily armed military force that does NOT want to turn)
14/

That's why #DefundThePolice is so important - "reform" is slow, and easily frustrated by supporters of the myth. A few well-placed funding cuts can cripple a department's ability to enforce policies that actively harm citizens
15/

Why pay for surveillance tools like police planes and helicopters? Why fund military "tanks" and weapons? Why contract with police officers in healthcare and educational settings? The immediate goal should be to minimize the damage police can do
16/

It won't be easy, even here in #RVA, where it's clear the Mayor has zero control over #RPD. #DefundThePolice is gaining traction because more and more people have recognized that upholding the myth of law enforcement is absolutely not worth the tremendous cost
17/End

A version of this thread has been published as an op-ed on @RVAmag here: rvamag.com/politics/opini…