Treaty 8 First Nations have had to watch ancestral lands dug up for the future reservoir of the troubled #SiteC dam. To grasp the sheer size of that needless reservoir, a photo essay. Here is one of the shipping container huts full of archaelogical artefacts.. #bcpoli#bcelxn2020
Inside are bankers boxes - tens of thousands of them - full of artefacts dug up during #SiteC work. Box after box after box. They're being held by BC Archaeology Branch. I was sent these photos by a friend; these are his ancestral lands. What are we doing, BC? #bcpoli#bcelxn2020
..Shipping containers and bankers boxes full to the brim with a people's history and culture. The scale of the disruption is staggering. And it's all for a dam we did not need, & whose alternatives are cheaper & would not have violated Indigenous or Treaty rights. #SiteC#bcpoli
..What is not included in these photos from #SiteC are the more intangible traces of contemporary sacred places, places which, until they were recently destroyed, were still in use by First Nations in the Peace Valley. No more should be destroyed. #bcpolitheglobeandmail.com/news/british-c…
..That's the word that came to me too: horrific. #SiteC#bcpoli
A note on this archaeology: much of it was done by +/or with assistance of local First Nations & some will be housed with them. The point is not that it was done without them; it's that an unstoppable 100% unneeded megaproject was rammed thru desp opposition & this was the result
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Funny, I was just about to say something about sexism & misogyny around this dam project when this arrived. Dreck like this doesn't deter us, boys; we are dealing with far worse than you on #SiteC. Also, how many fallacies can you pack into one email?
I have a huge collection of these. It's hilarious & telling that he focuses on the woman who uploaded the petition (LeadNow just lists the name of whoever uploaded it - which is annoying) & imagines there isn't a whole group behind this. I guess he's calling us all the C word?
He has also managed to pack into this one sad message the sunk cost fallacy, the fallacy that the project is "half done," and... "billion dollar"? If only. Bud, you mean multibillion, right? You mean $20 billion, perhaps.
More intel from #SiteC that you won't hear in the media because no one will go on the record (& if I worked at the dam I wouldn't risk facing BC Hydro's $1500/hr lawyers either): the huge concrete buttress they've poured is moving at the rate of ~1mm per day.. #bcpoli#BCelxn2020
If @bchydro disagrees, perhaps it can rebut this intel by providing the public with detailed info including any LIDAR measurements they have taken at #SiteC? Their tardy reports of July 31 which admit to serious foundation problems seem deliberately vague. So please, correct me.
@bchydro ..The overwhelming secrecy around #SiteC - which has been remarked on by international dam experts - starts to look quite suspicious in itself & doesn't breed public confidence. This is OUR project after all; the billions being spent are ours. #bcpoli
Activism on an issue is almost always in conflict with political partisanship. I don't see why this is so difficult to understand, but the fact that it seems opaque to so many is sort of evidence of how much things have changed in the past few decades. This used to be understood.
This is a blunter version of an earlier thread.
If you're a political partisan but are fighting an issue - housing, Site C, whatever - your allegiances are split & your strategies will be different than if you weren't a partisan. You won't seek traction against your party.
This situation is particularly dire under First Past the Post, which is a system designed to support larger parties & pull them all to some sort of artificial "centre" while virtually disqualifying smaller parties. Many won't vote for 3rd parties due to FPTP's lesser evil logic.
More rumours from #SiteC: The Shaman property that Hydro specifically purchased because supposedly it had the perfect material (clay) to build the impermeable core of the dam & the river diversion coffer dams? Well, apparently the material is too sandy & not suitable.. #bcpoli
Locals shaking heads, saying it's hard to believe anyone could screw up that badly; that is what test holes are drilled for. Meanwhile, the expensive conveyor belt specifically built to move that material to the dam has only run a little bit to their knowledge... #bcpoli
I find that locals are usually the best sources. They're the ones who are most likely to hear what's really going on at this rushed & incompetent megaproject. And they're the ones who loudly warned BC Hydro & the BC govt from the *beginning* that this was no place to build a dam.
Even if there *were* such a thing as point of no return, this wouldn't be it. The dam itself, the wall, hasn't even been started at #SiteC. About $5.5bn has been spent, much of it coping with mud. The budget is estimated at $12bn now but most think it'll be far more than that.
The cost of alternatives is below $7bn and plummeting daily. By the time we need electricity it'll have dropped far further. (But we don't need electricity right now, period, as BC has a surplus & is paying IPPs not to produce.)
A pastime for #SiteC watchers is monitoring how unseasonably full the WAC Bennett dam's reservoir is above Site C.
Hydro can't build #SiteC unless the WAC Bennett dam can reduce the flow of the Peace River so Hydro can divert it away from the dam site. But WAC is full. #bcpoli
..WAC Bennett dam's reservoir is Williston Lake. For dam safety it must be kept below 672m or "full pond." WAC's been releasing lots of water to try & reduce levels so they can later hold back water to help divert river @ #SiteC. But it's stuck at 670m: bchydro.com/energy-in-bc/o…
...Normally at this time of year the WAC Bennett dam's Williston reservoir,--the world's 7th largest reservoir by volume--is low & so is the Peace River. But with climate change & unseasonably heavy summer rains, the reservoir & the river are as full as at spring freshet...