Been thinking a lot about this, especially the “for a paycheck” part. I have many relatives working in jobs where it’s impossible to distance, avoid closed spaces, etc. It is 100% a failure of govt (US senators esp) to provide money for businesses & workers to stay home...1/
But me getting on a soapbox about
the stimulus bill US should have passed this summer is neither here nor there for my relatives who need to make decisions today about work, even when they know perfectly well (thanks to yours truly!) that their work environments are not safe 2/
If I sat in my home office or in my empty campus office typing away about how “everyone should just stay home & this would all be over, The End,” I’d have no credibility with them. (They love me though, so they’d just 🙄 & quietly ignore my posts. 😂) 3/
When I talk with my family and community* or consider rhetoric from others, I hold several things in my mind at once: 1) we know ideal conditions to stop #SARSCoV2 spread 2) those conditions don’t exist in most of US; our fed govt has actively blocked them; this is enraging...4/
3) smug people who’ve made little bubbles of safety for themselves but still find time to lecture strangers whose lives they don’t know are annoying, yes, but also they’re breaking chains of transmission, we should give them props. Also they are scared like the rest of us 5/
4) people who are engaging in behaviors that I think are risky may have made a very rational and considered choice given the options they have. My biggest impacts are in how I behave & in helping others manage risk 6/
As usual, Black scholars have been thinking about these issues presciently & insightfully... 7/
“As someone who wants desperately for as many people as possible to survive this pandemic, I need to know how to make the agreements and take the precautions necessary given the reality of my life.” @drmcclain published this is April, y’all. thenation.com/article/societ…
Back in the spring, I felt self-conscious about the perspective I was giving in this article. It was more permissive (read: practical) than the standard, Just Stay at Home, #epitwitter party line. I didn’t publicize the article much. That was a mistake. I sold myself out.
Yes, I feel like I’m living in a horror show. Yes, I cry when I remember the horrifying crush of sickness & pain heading towards us like a tsunami. I can’t stop the tsunami, but I can be a life raft. I can point to the high ground. Most of us are just doing the best we can do.
* The direct public health communication work I’ve done in my extended family and neighborhood is the most rewarding & important work I’ve done in my career. Despite it all, we are doing ok for now. 🙏🏾 If my career stopped tomorrow, this work would have made it worth it. 11/
from @drmcclain in April: “As we’ve settled into our new routine, it’s become clear to me that public-health messaging around the pandemic assumes that everyone...can simply retreat into a home, be self-sufficient, & survive the weeks or months that this intervention will last.”
👆🏾 Also @drmcclain is a national treasure. That’s the tweet.
Also, when I lay out options for people, describing spectrum of risk & possible precautions to reduce risk, people often surprise me, backing out of risky situation entirely. Not always, but enough so that I know it’s a thing. I’m sure #harmreduction folks knew this from way back
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Recent paper published on impacts of #COVID19#K-12 school closures on well-being of students over the very longterm. This topic of major interest to me, but paper not great. Thread critiques methods & interpretation informatively & constructively!
I particularly appreciated @ikashnitsky’s critique. I believe her use of “deterministic” corresponds to #epitwitter term, “causal”. @MariaGlymour What do you think of her assessment of this literature?
Ok, LOL. Looking back, @jburnmurdoch’s tone is more acerbic than I recalled. I only note this bc I posed this thread as a model of constructive critique in tweet 1 but some of the tone spicier than my personal ideal. 😂
Someone close to me is in this vaccine trial. I am so moved by every single volunteer for these trials. They took a risk to give the world a tremendous gift. I’m literally crying. The world owes them so much...
And it looks like all the severe cases were in placebo group, so vaccine may not just reduce risk of getting sick overall but also prevent severe illness. 🙏🏾
Also some promising news about placebo arm folks: “Dr. Zaks said Moderna’s study results were so strong that the company felt an ethical obligation to offer the vaccine to the placebo group as soon as possible.” From @nytimes. Stay tuned
.@ER_Mayeda cautions, Methods of correcting for selection bias, eg, IPW, only as good as understanding of selection processes that gave rise to data. Reminds me of polling in 2016 & 2020 US elections. When system is dynamic, can’t rely on past trends; need other ways of knowing
Reading this article (in which I'm quoted near the end), I realized why I have such a strong visceral reaction to some of the negative coverage of @ProfEmilyOster's work on #COVID19 and schools...prospect.org/coronavirus/wh… 1/
..The treatment of @ProfEmilyOster reminds of 2016 press coverage of @HillaryClinton! An outsized focus on that woman's flaws had big long-term consequences.(I'm not a media studies or communications person, so I may be totally off, but I swear there's a PhD thesis in here! 2/
On to my promised tweets on #epitwitter data about #SARSCoV2/#COVID19 among children and particularly in school settings. It's less comprehensive than I hoped, but I'm trying not to let the perfect be the enemy of the good... 3/
Again, many great quotes but this one deeply resonated with my personal experience: “Yet when Black women ‘do say no to additional projects, we are seen as anti-team player, unwilling to be collegial,’ Lima-Neves said...”2/
The most galling thing said to me in 2020 was from a senior leader in response to my asking him why his leadership team was all-White over many years despite the presence of talented non-White faculty (like myself)...
So THEN someone in our “You’re on yr own” US executive says, “Actually I do have some thoughts!”
and bullies the actual *CDC* (the home of elite force of disease detectives who live to identify and squash outbreaks) into saying...2/
“Hey school districts, in case you were thinking about doing the extraordinary & forward-thinking work of standing up a whole #SARSCoV2 surveillance system in your K-12 schools bc yr federal govt has abandoned you...3/