1/3. The UK #COVID19 testing data since September by different regions reveals a very close correlation between number of people tested and the proportion who test positive (i.e. the positivity rate)....
2/3 ...not clear what if any causal explanation there is to such a close correlation. But indications are that an increasing positivity rate may not be due to an increase in underlying infection rate... A full discussion is here .. probabilityandlaw.blogspot.com/2020/12/uk-cov…
3/3 ... and lockdown decisions could result purely from decisions to increase testing. All the usual caveats apply (and in this case this analysis has been done in a hurry to get it out, as the results seem so unusual and could not be seen from looking at the overall UK data)
@ClareCraigPath This possibly provides support for the hypothesis that when testing increases so does the false positive rate
1. Some people taking issue with my earlier plot of daily new covid hospital admissions as % of new cases don't seem to understand the fundamental limitations of ALL the analyses based on the daily data provided by the government - as summarised in this graphic...
2. They thought I didn't understand that the April peak was largely explained because then it was mainly hospitalized people being tested. As I work on CAUSAL modelling and analysis we were highlighting this very problem back in March ... theconversation.com/coronavirus-co…
We have produced numerous reports exposing the flaws of much published statistical analysis on Covid because of the failure to account of causal factors and explanations. My blog post from last week provides some context and links to much of this work. probabilityandlaw.blogspot.com/2020/10/why-we…
1. (This is a corrected version of tweet I just deleted). Some perspective on #CovidUK hospital admissions. Here's an update of another graph (using data from coronavirus.data.gov.uk) that never seems to be shown. Daily number of new covid admissions as % of new cases.
2. So 87% of 'cases' at March peak resulted in hospital admissions. Now it's just 4.6% and is actually decreasing. And that's despite: increased repeat hospital testing now (so more false positives), and hospital admissions always go up in October.
3. And note: a person entering hospital with a non-Covid condition who, for example, tests positive after 3 weeks and several negative tests, is counted as a Covid admission.