Marc Gayle Profile picture
28 Dec, 17 tweets, 7 min read
I am going to pull the curtain back a bit on some ‘inside baseball’ currently happening in our local financial markets around the Derrimon $DTL.ja APO.

This is ‘dot connecting’ on corporate maneuvering.

Read below, there is a lot going on.

//Mini-Thread

#FinanceTwitterJa
So let’s go back to the early days of 2013 when $DTL.ja initially went public.

The lead broker was Mayberry Investments at the time.

The listing was very successful and the offer closed within 3 minutes of opening.

jamaicaobserver.com/business/Overs…
Mayberry Jamaican Equities ( $MJE.ja) took a big position in $DTL.ja.

In fact, they are the second largest shareholder as of today.
Fast forward to this year and $DTL.ja wants to do an APO, and curiously Mayberry is no longer the lead broker, Barita is.

In fact, they aren’t even a selling agent.
At first glance, that feels a bit rough but such is life. Business is business.

Assuming it’s just business, $DTL.ja clearly believed they got a better deal from Barita.

Barita is fully underwriting the entire $3.5B offer....
Ie they are essentially guaranteeing $DTL.ja that they will buy the full $3.5B regardless. So Derrimon can rest assured that if it fails, they get their $3.5B.

So Barita has every incentive to sell it to investors to make sure other investors take it off their hands.
So far everything is fairly straightforward.

Fast forward to this sponsored post the other day, talking about the “best food & distribution company to invest in today” and they are referring to $GK.ja.

They publish an article outlining their thinking.

mayberryinv.com/the-best-food-…
When I first saw this I read the analysis and thought it seemed relatively reasonable, but the timing seemed a bit off.....errr....deliberate.

I found it strange that Mayberry would be pushing an alternative food & distro company in the same week/mth as the $DTL.ja APO.
But I shrugged it off and moved on.

Then today now, Mayberry drops this tweet and it’s clear there is a strategy behind this.

Remember I highlighted above that Mayberry isn’t a selling agent?!?

So what’s happening here?
If we look at the price, it is very...uhmmm....deliberate.

$2.38 offer by Mayberry of “Guaranteed Fills” is literally $0.02 below the General Public price of the APO.

Again...very deliberate.
Remember that $MJE.ja is the 2nd largest shareholder. They can guarantee fills up to 439M shares.

I took a look at the queues for $DTL.ja and the top sell order is ~5M units for $2.38.

We can’t know for certain if that’s $MJE.ja, but if it isn’t, it is having the same effect.
There are many aspects of this to be analyzed (which I won’t dive into), eg from the competitive perspective within the industry, or from DTL’s perspective, and others.

I just wanted to lay out the facts of what’s going on so you guys can have the data you need to be informed.
One last thing I would add to this is, watch the Top 10 Shareholders List for the next few reports.

That will tell us a more full story about what exactly happened then, and we can look back at this tweet and put 2 and 2 together.
Update: I got a tip from a birdie re: Mayberry’s transaction last September 2019.

They bought 420M shares.

This article says a price of $2.48 on Sept 3, but JSE’s website posts it on Sept 4 at a close price of $1.99.

See next tweet...

jamaica-gleaner.com/article/busine…
Here is the JSE price history for $DTL.ja.

So it’s unclear the exact price they got, but we know it’s somewhere in that range.

Chances are they are still making a profit at $2.38.

jamstockex.com/market-data/do…
Another Update:

So MJE’s top performing stock, and by their own admission the “Fastest Growing Distribution Company” which this APO will be used to drive further growth, is potentially being dumped?!?

Very curious. 🧐🤔

This is $MJE.ja ‘s holdings as at September 2020.
Yet Another Update:

My DMs are on fire 🔥 🔥 🔥 lol.

A few people pointed this out to me, that I missed in the first go around, the wording of the tweet today.

If Mayberry isn’t a selling agent, how can this language be accurate?

Keep the observations coming peeps.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Marc Gayle

Marc Gayle Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @marcgayle

16 Dec
This bill that Dr. Clarke introduced to, and got passed by, the House, basically gives all registered MSMEs (companies with annual revenues of $500M JMD or less), a tax credit on the first $1.5M of profits they earn.

//Mini-Thread

#FinanceTwitterJa
In other words, if your company makes $10M revenue and $1.5M profit, you effectively pay no corporate income taxes.

The corporate tax rate is 25% for non-financial firms. $1.5M x 25% = $375,000.

This is a tax credit, so effectively GOJ pays the tax for you.
You have to file your taxes though, to benefit.

Dr. Clarke initially introduced this idea in the opening of the budget debate in March.

See the tweet below:
Read 6 tweets
14 Dec
This article by @drnigelclarkeja is such an important article about the recent BOJ Amendments Act & establishing the Independent Fiscal Commission that I feel compelled to do a thread explaining some key components.

//Thread

#FinanceTwitterJa

jamaica-gleaner.com/article/commen…
GOJ has prioritised 2 complementary institutional reforms: (i) Tabling legislation for the establishment of an Independent Fiscal Commission to strengthen JA’s Fiscal Responsibility Framework; and (ii) creation of an independent BOJ with an explicit mandate for price stability.
The key takeaway here is the following:
- Two key initiatives have been wildly successful for JA’s economic reform across administrations over the last 11 years: Inflation Targeting by @CentralBankJA and the establishing of @EPOCJA to monitor GOJ’s progress.
Read 25 tweets
2 Sep
BREAKING: @CentralBankJA's F/X Sale of US$20M on Sept 1, 2020 only received US$7.8M in bids. In other words, of the total amount BOJ offered to sell to the market, the market only bought 39%.

boj.org.jm/uploads/news/b…

This is significant. I explain below.

#FinanceTwitterJa
First a brief summary of how the F/X market works.

Every day, buyers & sellers (i.e. Financial Institutions including Cambios) buy & sell foreign exchange with each other.

BOJ has begun publishing this activity daily, for example:
That market activity is simply showing how much each financial institution bought from the market (each other) and sold to the market (each other) every day.

It doesn't show any transactions with BOJ.

BOJ doesn't do regular, daily, transactions with the F/X market.
Read 21 tweets
30 Aug
Ok these two words uttered by Dr. Phillips need to be expounded on.

"DEFICIT FINANCING" is the act of allowing GOJ to spend more than they receive in taxes and then borrowing to pay for the difference.

This was the hallmark of the Omar Davies MoF.

britannica.com/topic/deficit-…
Deficit Financing has been VERY, VERY destructive to Jamaica.

It can create a negative cycle that is very hard to break where GOJ has to keep borrowing to effectively pay off debt. We were stuck in that cycle for at least 1.5 - 2 decades.
The ONLY thing that broke the cycle for us were:
- A global financial crisis in 2008 that prevented GOJ from being able to continue borrowing.
- The need for an IMF programme, where we are 'inconsequential' in the sense that we have to take the terms they insist.
Read 19 tweets
7 Jun
In this presser the PM @AndrewHolnessJM addressed many absurd comments about the reopening decision and he made some good points.

The main point is about food, that a lot of people seem to not understand/appreciate.

IMPORTANT ⚠️

But first my thoughts on minor issues.

//Thread
The most ridiculous comment I have seen floating around is that GOJ is reopening Tourism because of the donation that Sandals gave.

Firstly, that donation was $500K per constituency. It was given to all constituencies. Ie both parties. That didn’t just benefit GOJ.
Secondly, GOJ is reopening too soon.

The reality of this virus is two fold:
- No cure on the horizon.
- The recovery rate is higher and fatality rate lower than was initially expected.

The truth is that the fatality rate is likely much lower (%) than we currently know...
Read 24 tweets
10 Mar
In his opening budget speech, @DrNigelClarkeJa just recognized and acknowledged the tough decisions taken by Portia Simpson-Miller and Dr. Phillips along with the Bruce Golding Administration in our macroeconomic journey.

I love the intellectual honesty.

#FinanceTwitterJa
Tourism has grown for 16 consecutive quarters.

Manufacturing has grown for 13 of the 16 quarters.
Can I tell you, @DrNigelClarkeJa is on FIRE 🔥.

Man is so passionate about what’s happening.

New vocabulary for cranes is needed because we are seeing so many different types, from “telescopic” and many more.
Read 44 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!