Jason Nixon's reassurances are not credible. Look at the evidence, Albertans, and not at the pretty words. First, Alberta does not have a "robust" environmental regulatory system. Is there one environmental lawyer in Canada who would agree with this? 1/n #abpoli
One conservation biologist? One landscape ecologist? One conservation association? One environmental policy expert? One authority on the ecology of the eastern slopes? 2/n @Ablawg@ABWilderness@cpaws
Do you want to ask some of the landowners who have abandoned well sites on their properties? Indigenous communities living downstream of the oilsands? Or maybe have a look at the Cheviot mine site? 3/n
Or you could read some of the published research on environmental regulation in Alberta. At lot of this research is summarized in these books:
(and please, colleagues, feel free to add to this list) 4/n
For example, this agreement with Oros Coal dated December 1, 2020, which will impact the Big Horn Indian Reserve:
Or this one, that will engulf Fish Lake and Goldeneye Lake:
Jason Nixon has already bulldozed right over the provisions of the South Saskatchewan Regional Plan and the Alberta Land Stewardship Act and rescinded the 1976 Coal Policy without public consultation.
This is why the Kenney government is facing multiple judicial reviews of these actions. Why do you think, Albertans, that they have done these things without public consultation??
And who was it who opposed the creation of a provincial park in the Big Horn area?
And who is it who is auctioning oil and gas leases in the province's "natural areas"?
Jason Nixon is "reassuring" Albertans not to worry--UCP won't sell their eastern slopes to the highest bidder--because two much-loved country singers have come out against the UCP's plans to permit coal mining, and he is worried that Albertans might actually pay attention.
I assure you, if he could identify an environmental organization as the voice in the wilderness, and discredit its concerns as "anti-Albertan," that's what he would be doing now.
Unfortunately for Jason Nixon, a citizens' group rooted in the southwest of the province, with over 7,000 members, plus thousands more Albertans, are on to the UCP and are not going to let the mining of the eastern slopes happen. #WaterNotCoal
I could throw a lump of coal a lot further than I trust Jason Nixon, Sonya Savage, or Jason Kenney to protect the interests of Albertans. #StopTheBengaMine#MountainsNotMines
Benga/Riversdale says: "The company has developed wildlife and fish monitoring programs to sustain those populations, and also has a plan in place to safely and effectively manage selenium." 1/n calgaryherald.com/news/no-free-f… @ABWilderness@cpawssab
"Monitoring" does not protect fish from selenium poisoning. Benga promises a lot of measures, most of which amount to experimentation or monitoring. The stakes are too high to approve another open pit coal mine on this basis. 2/n
Why do I say this? Because I read the submissions of the scientists to the JRP. You should read these, too, before you decide to take the proponents' promises at face value. That's what @Corblund did. That's why he said "I'm 100% opposed" to coal mining on the eastern slopes. 3/n
One wonders if Alberta's Energy Regulator has any expertise about the costs of "restoring" open pit coal mines in mountain environments, or the past records of the companies being licensed to mine in this province. 1/n #Alberta#ableg@ReclaimAlberta@Pembina
Because the record of open pit coal mining in the US, Australia, Turkey, and elsewhere really isn't reassuring. I don't see any evidence that mountains & their unique ecosystems can be put back together the way they were before being blasted apart. 3/n @CorbLund@paulbrandt
This is a very informative and accessible (to non-scientists) explanation of how selenium gets into water, food, and animals, and how the Grassy Mountain coal mine would be likely to affect selenium levels in the Oldman River and throughout the watershed. 1/n #Alberta#aboli
"[T]he top three sources of man-made selenium contamination worldwide in order of greatest to least are: 1. Mining 2. Irrigation 3. Feedlots
The Oldman River and South Saskatchewan watersheds already have large feedlots and supply irrigation." 2/n
More than 16,000 have signed a petition to the federal minister of Environment and Climate Change Canada. petitions.ourcommons.ca/en/Petition/De…
(The petition closes Friday. Sign now!) 2/n
Nearly 2,000 have written comments to the Joint Review Panel, with about 98 per cent of these opposing the Benga coal strip mine and other mining in the Rockies. iaac-aeic.gc.ca/050/evaluation…
(Opportunity for comments also closes this Friday.) 3/n
About 1,000 Albertans have written to the Joint Review Panel that will make a recommendation to the federal minister of ECCC on whether or not to approve the proposed open pit coal mine on Grassy Mountain. 1/n @350Canada@RachelNotley@CBCCanada@JustinTrudeau@globeandmail
It is worth reading through these comments, which you can find here: iaac-aeic.gc.ca/050/evaluation… (You can also add your own comment, as a Canadian citizen.) 2/n
Many of the statements are very moving. Albertans feel very passionately about protecting this place, this land, this watershed, the trout, the pines, from the devastating effects of coal mining. 3/n
"Two-thirds of Canada's irrigated agriculture relies on waters from the Eastern Slopes, including the project region."
(Kevin van Tighem, landscape ecologist & conservation biologist, comment to the JRP for the Grassy Mtn coal mine project) 1/n #WaterNotCoal@JonathanWNV
Van Tighem lucidly sets out reason after reason why the coal mine on Grassy Mtn should NOT be approved. Read his statement here: iaac-aeic.gc.ca/050/evaluation…
3/n