Valuation thread with heavy credit to @akramsrazor whose podcast highly recommend for insights. Lets take $zm. Everyone was in love with their earnings beat and higher guide and congratulating themselves for being long after the last q and then thr stock dropped 30% quickly..why?
$zm reported revs of 883M & guided to 902M revs for next q. The runrate of 902M per q1 guide if taken flat for rest of yr is 3.6B. They guided to 3.77B. Thats just a 5% increase for the yr from q1 run rate. That is a massive decline & implies negative billings growth 2H of 21..
A stock that at the time was trading 35x revs (now 28x) for negative growth second half of this yr is too much. $zm ended this yr at 2.65B revs so u could say well hey thats still 42% growth next yr which is great! Well not really because q1 and q2 are easy compares.
Again just by $zm’s run rate this past q4 at 882M if they just keep that & dont grow at all their rev next yr would be 3.528B which is 33% automatic growth. So they really only guided to 9% growth on top of that for the whole yr next yr. why pay 35 or 30 or 25x revs for that?
I think $zm likely ends this coming yr at 4B but even then multiple will come crashing down unless the following yr things reaccelerate meaningfully and that could be tough as many go back to the office. Now why are people buying hotels and airlines and cruise lines and retail?
All cyclicals had revs cut huge. For example lets say im a hotel chain and my revs fell from 5B to 1B (just to make it easy). So now economy reopns and i have 3B in revs. Thats 300% growth at a 20PE multiple vs a 25x revs for minimal growth for $zm. This is why ppl are rotating
This value outperformance could last all this yr and little next yr due to easy compares however after numbers are rightsized then likely goes away. Growth outperformance was always because growth was scarce and ppl had to pay a premium. Well now its not scarce in reopening names
Reopening names will look like they have faster growth than tech def this yr & prolly next at much lower valuations so if ur a portfolio manager which do u buy?Its all bs numbers games but thats why tech took off so much in 2020. Had huge growth while Everything else was cut down
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Bearish thesis thread: 1) there are so many ppl that have made SO much $ over the past year on stocks like $zm, $crwd, $roku, $pins and now a million spaqs. Many are first time investors who have no clue hoe much capital gains tax they are going to owe from all the $ they made
2) but thats NOT all the taxes u owe! Anyone trading in & out or selling anything this yr ALSO owes estimated payments for the first q on top of 2020 capital gains which many dont realize. For example im up 90% ytd already and given 2019 taxes were small i owe a ton on 21 already
3) i would think ppl need to pay taxes couple weeks beforehand but some will sell earlier and then others will make a play on this even earlier to front run it as history has shown selling to pay taxes HAS caused liquidity event drops before
Been doing a lot of thinking & honestly think $rkt could potentially be lining up for a mini $gme type moment:
1) $rkt tried to go public at 150M shares @ $20-22 however due to weak demand cut back to 100M shares @ $18. This also means pre lockup the float was just 100M or $2B
2) ive been monitoring short interest and ever since last q its gone up 5% every two weeks like clockwork with the latest info now showing 37% of shares held short. This is off the 100M ipo float not the total.
3) last q they announced a $1B buyback...now let that sink in, less than 3 months after going ipo they are buying back $1B out of the $2B total of shares they issued to go public at 18, when has anyone ever seen that happen ever?!
1) revenue growth expected to come in at 61% (last q was 58% so a slight acceleration)
2) next q guidance expected for 56% rev growth, little bit of an easy compare as covid started at the back of the q. Last yr grew 35% in q1
3) this yr rev expected to be 1.63B vs 1.143B last yr or 43% growth.
4) Last yr rev was 1.143B vs 755M in 2018 or 51% growth
5) next yr rev expected at 2.32B or 42% growth. Following yr 3.18B for 37% growth
6) stock trades at 21x next yr revs & 15x following yr revs
7) $pins has grown users tremendously this yr at 37% to 442M with 98M in US and 343M intl, however they have yet to monetize much of their intl users which is why arpu is so low
8) arpu:
Global: 1.03
Intl: .21
US: 3.85
These figures are very low (lot of room for improvement)
Overall thoughts on $amzn: 1) while aws growth missed little this q the backlog up to 50B (up 68%) implies acceleration 2) e-commerce internationally beat big & could be getting more entrenched there 3) $amzn on call said spent 48B in open last yr much of it on adding capacity
4) 2020 COVID costs were $11B, while these will continue as vaccine rolls out it will be less. Only guided to 2B this q 5) with COVID and investment costs of almost 60B last yr 2021 should be a much lower investment yr meaning EPS is about to beat big this yr and sky rocket imo
6) bezos is not stepping down or leaving as many clickbait articles would have u believe. He’s transitioning to exec chairman & as largest shareholder will still be heavily involved/in charge of new products which is where I’d want him to be, also this is happening in q3 not now
I think the largest oppty into earnings is $twtr on 2/9: 1) everyone and their mother is neg on it meaning sentiment and positioning is shit poor and expectations low (see $nflx reaction) 2) Everyone expects users to drop but no one understands that Twitter uses different metrics
3) Twitter uses monetizable daily active users versus every other platform using monthly active users or daily active users. What if Trump and many of the conspiracists who were removed never qualified as monetizable daily active user?
4) when Twitter changed their metrics they had 320 million monthly active users that turned into 112 million monetizable daily active users. Now they have 188 million monetizable daily active users which is likely comparable to 500 to 600M monthly active users of other platforms
Want to be tra soarent since ive been so vocal on $trit that last night i reached out again given some discrepancies in financial statements related to account receivables being so high and their platform costs not being in r&d but in investing cash flows (higher ebitda shown)
While the comoany has not gotten back to me on the details of my additional questions they did say that they dont plan to have any formal quarter results for the q they just provided estimates for... they said their press release saying 17M rev plus 10M net income is all we get
Said their auditor kpmg is “budy” till january and would take thrm 30 days to do and by Feb it will be old news and they think spending 50k on that doesnt make sense. The next formal financial results they will provide will be for year end in feb and they said they have 120 days