The Sandyford clinic in Glasgow claimed puberty blockers were "fully reversible" even though they knew in 2017 of the risks. They join a list of those who have given false information to children, from NHS England to Polly Carmichael. This is a scandal. thetimes.co.uk/article/health…
Officials "recognised that the long-term impacts of hormones known as puberty blockers were not known but could affect bone density and stunt growth. Despite this, a leaflet published by the health board until last year said that taking blockers was considered “fully reversible”"
A Glasgow health official admitted that “Uncertainties also exist regarding the effect of puberty suppression on growth and adult height, the psychosocial problem of delayed puberty and possible effects on brain development."
Good work from @ForwomenScot: “We have been raising concerns about practices and record-keeping at the Sandyford for some time.”
“Despite evidence of serious side-effects and a dearth of evidence on the long-term impacts of stunting puberty, clinics have maintained that blockers were safe and fully reversible. The Scottish government should call a halt to these experiments now.”
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It is well understood that adolescent girls are susceptible to 'contagion' of sudden, new symptoms. This knowledge is not applied to the explosion in trans-identified teenage girls but the parallels are striking and unavoidable.
Thread. thetimes.co.uk/article/teenag…
Sudden onset tics and a doubling of referral rates. Sound familiar?
Inevitably, sharing information on social media sites reinforces and maintains symptoms. Teenage girls are particularly susceptible to developing similar symptoms out of empathy and emotional connection.
In the UK we have a good number of wise, thoughtful and experienced clinicians, psychologists and psychiatrists researching and writing on gender dysphoria in children and young people. Imagine if the GIDS model of care had been developed by the following professionals.
Thread.
In March 2018 Margaret McCartney wrote this for the BMJ. Back then you didn't see even cautious pieces like this.
"Yet playing with dolls and liking dresses doesn’t make children female, just as playing with trucks and liking mud doesn’t make them male."
James Caspian @jamesfreespeech is applying to the European Court of Human Rights for a hearing of his case against Bath Spa University for preventing his research into #detransitioners.
“Some of the people I spoke to said they were too traumatised to speak about their experiences, which proved it was even more important to research the issue, not less."
“I was astonished therefore that a university could censor a research project on the grounds that what people ‘might’ post on social media may be detrimental to the reputation of the university.”
A judicial review is a legal course of action whereby someone can challenge a decision of a public body on the grounds that it is unfair, illegal or irrational. Court doesn't look at the merits, but the process and legality of the policy.
Issue at heart of the case was consent, whether informed consent in the legal sense can be given. Court found children under the age of 18 do not have capacity to give informed consent, children under 13 never, older children need to apply to court of protection.
Now it's time for Feminist Perspectives. We have Susan Matthews chairing and speakers Selina Todd @selina_todd, Vaishnavi Sundar talking about erosion of women's rights in India, and Ziggy Melamed. #DoNotAdjustYourSet2021
Selina Todd now on Ideology and Academia. We are in a state where there is a great deal of fear around raising questions in UK universities, in relation to women as a sex. Threats, de-platforming, accusations of transphobia. Institutional policies strengthen their hand.
The attack is mainly on women, reflecting the misogyny of the movement and this can be interpreted as an attack on 2nd wave feminism, a backlash. How did those attacks come about and what does it mean for women in academia?
We require a shared sense of reality. What happens when we abandon this shared sense of reality? When we become unmoored from reality?
Lisa tells the story of Maya, a detransitioner. At 14 Maya announced to her mother she was trans, after looking online. It's a fairly typical story. Testosterone was offered at first appt, Maya dropped out of college, mental health deteriorated, hospitalised twice. Stopped T.