On those who participated in the survey on the clinical case definition - Patient AND Researcher is a new category (requested by @Dr2NisreenAlwan and yours truly) :)
2/
The parts of the clinical case definition that have reached consensus:
3/
@Dr2NisreenAlwan up first! Doctors need to do better and avoid generating stigma. She shares excellent data showing that those without lab confirmation don't get enough time off or adequate rest, resulting in worsened #LongCOVID as measured by ability to care for themself 4/
@BrodinPetter talks about #LongCOVID in children and three possible explanations: persistent virus, autoimmunity, or an autoinflammatory response 5/
Dr. Anna Funk: few differences between pos and negative-tested child patients w/r/t number of symptoms 6/
Dr. Jonigk and Dr. Ackermann on vascular injury. There are ongoing vascular alterations and endothelial dysfunction! 7/
Three hypotheses for #LongCOVID: 1. Viral reservoir (would not be picked up by PCR) 2. Autoreactive lymphocytes 3. Tissue damage, including in vascular
(Not mutually exclusive!) 8/
@VirusesImmunity There is evidence for all of these hypotheses. Here is a screenshot showing that in 5 of 14 patients, COVID antigens were found in intestinal tissue.
She and her colleagues have looked at autoantibodies in severe patients but are expanding to #LongCOVID 9/
@VirusesImmunity Major point! Patients with autoantibodies to B cells had reduced B cell number and function.
"[Moderate] patients failed to mount an antibody response....not only do autoantibodies interfere with B cells, but they also interfere with their function." 10/
@VirusesImmunity Vaccines can both improve & worsen #LongCOVID patients & this could be a clue to the pathophysiology.
By the way, this study (which @patientled gave the patient perspective on) is still recruiting for non-vaccinated Long COVID patients within driving distance of New Haven! 11/
We're in the working groups now (I'm in the pathophysiology one).
Sooooooo excited to hear Dr. Jarred Younger here on neuroinflammation AND neuroimaging techniques.
Microglia activation causes an inflammatory state. He is talking about several neuro markers including elevated lactate in the brain and elevated brain temperature!
13/
The treatment goal would be getting microglia back into calm state.
14/
Phew, wrapping up. Now on to the working group summaries.
Care models working group:
-they make the very important point that even though #LongCOVID is more probable in hospitalized patients, the vast majority and count of LC patients are non-hospitalized
15/
Care Models working group:
-Services must be driven by patient-led perspectives
-need advocates to listen to listen to lived experiencee
-can't rely on physiological normal parameters (my side note - we haven't even figured out tests yet)
16/
-post infectious diseases/research, which are historically underfunded, need to be paid attention
-overwhelmingly a huge need especially in non-hospitalized patients
-urgent need for an acceptable level of holistic care
-need upskilling (medical provider ed) & bundled care
17/
-access to care pathways is vital especially to not exacerbate inequalities
-pathways need to be complex (multiple specialities, bundling services together)
-Many non-hospitalized patients weren't admitted to hospitals because of hospital capacity alone and we shouldn't be calling all non-hospitalized patients "mild"
19/
Pathophysiology working group:
-not sure we are any closer to pathophysiology, but many possible theories (including many not listed here, like neuroinflammation etc)
I missed a few slides here but will revisit when the recording is out
20/
Wrapping up from WHO's Mike Ryan:
In the US 18-49 year olds are the largest symptomatic group. With 91 million symptomatic cases - even a rare condition with these numbers is common. We need a societal approach to this.
[14% of 91 million is 13million people w' #LongCOVID]
21/
"There is a decay curve in society's concern. Sometimes people are made to feel like they should shut up & move on. We owe it to the people who are suffering to give them the best science possible. There is a danger in the moment like this that people stop talking about this" 22/
we need to keep this conversation going and keep it going in public, with policymakers.
We can't leave anyone behind. It's not just about vaccines, it's about leaving nobody behind FOREVER. And that takes a commitment."
@itsbodypolitic and @patientled worked together to give feedback on these and it's really emotional to see our research, including the first report we did back in April 2020, cited here. 1/
It's going to take a while to go through & see what ended up in here, but a few things stand out to me that we pushed hard for:
A) The inclusion of a comprehensive symptom list, including PEM (and a definition for PEM!) and lesser-discussed but common symptoms. 2/
B) Instructions not to use lab confirmation: "Objective laboratory/imaging findings shouldn't be used as the only assessment of a patient’s well-being; lack of laboratory/imaging abnormalities does not invalidate the existence, severity, or importance of a patient’s symptoms." 3/
These areas of research are less known, including metabolic profiling, antiviral response phenotypes, neuroimmunology, cerebral blood flow, mitochondrial fragmentation, viral persistence, hypermobility, craniocervical issues, altered T&B cells, metabolomics & proteomics, etc. 2/
These researchers have made astounding post-viral findings in the above areas. Everyone interested in #LongCOVID should stop treating this as an illness unlike any other and instead dive into the massive amount of research that has already been done. 3/
In a study of (mostly male) #LongCOVID patients in the military, those with lab-confirmed COVID diagnoses were 69% less likely to have anxiety/mood symptoms!
This supports the idea that LC patients w' false negatives have more anxiety bc they can't access the care they need. 1/
The study also found that a lack of lab-confirmed diagnosis led to a huge delay in #LongCOVID care: 8.5 weeks for those w' confirmation, 16 weeks (4 months!!) without.
Those without lab confirmation were also 63% more likely to have pain, likely because of lack of care. 2/
A thread on models for patient involvement in research! #LongCOVID
First up:
This paper on design strategies in citizen science highlights a scale of 5 levels of participation. From lowest to highest involvement (through a patient lens):
A) Contractual: members from the public (patients) ask scientists to conduct study; no direct involvement in the research process, apart from defining the problems & setting research priorities. 2/
B) Contributory: the lowest level of direct involvement consists of contributory projects, where patients assist academic scientists in data collection or processing according to neatly defined protocols (i.e. crowdsourcing).
3/
There are a lot of #LongCOVID gems in this webinar from HCA Healthcare UK. I'm going to try to tweet them succinctly:
1. Non-hospitalized COVID patients had a slower recovery than hospitalized patients.
2. At 12 months out, the majority of non-hospitalized #LongCOVID patients are still not back to work full time.
Next speaker is a cardiologist.
3. Cardiac MRIs are helpful. Even when they look normal from a functioning standpoint, supepicardial late gadolinium enhancement can be identified, showing post-viral myocarditis. (Screenshotted case was in a patient 200+ days out from onset).
The vagus nerve is a super important nerve (and is also the longest cranial nerve, running from the brainstem to the colon). Damage to it can impact many parts of the body (I find the decreased production of stomach acid interesting here) 2/
It can also cause a condition called gastroparesis, which may explain some #LongCovid symptoms 3/