What's happening? The @ecb has just published the outcome of its 18-month monetary policy strategy review! Including what it plans to do on climate 🌍🌳

Quick thoughts: A THREAD
(1/20) Image
Quick recap: shortly after @Lagarde became the ECB president, the bank announced its first review of monetary policy strategy since 2003, to focus on the fascinating topic of 'close to, but below 2%' inflation target, but also on 'new topics' for CBs such as #ClimateCrisis (2/20)
In response, @NEF together with civil society partners including @PositiveMoneyEU and @350Europe developed a blueprint for the ECB a - our '5 asks' on incorporating #ClimateActionNow into the #ECB monetary policy operations (3/20)

neweconomics.org/2020/04/the-ec… Image
And so - now we are here with the ECB publishing both the overall review and the specific statement & roadmap on what it'll do on #ClimateEmergency
Leaving the enchanting topic of the 2% inflation target to others, I'll focus on the climate part (4/20)

ecb.europa.eu/press/pr/date/…
1. corporate asset purchases and collateral framework:

@NEF and partners including @Greenpeace published two reports on greening both those measures - and the ECB review indeed outlines plans to green both!
Here's for some more detail on how those are shaping up.. (5/20) Image
On the Corporate Sector purchase programme (CSPP), ECB announced that it will adjust its purchases to 'incorporate climate change criteria' and - a welcome point - 'will include the alignment of issuers with, at a minimum, EU legislation implementing the Paris agreement. (6/20) Image
ECB will also consider climate risks 'when reviewing the valuation and risk control frameworks for assets mobilised as collateral'. Given the importance of col. framework in financial markets, this is important. But as @DanielaGabor points out.. (7/20)
..in this excellent thread, ECB approach leaves gaps, as it only looks at climate risks (to financial actors) and not carbon footprint nor risks from finance to nature (double materiality). This raises some serious doubts about real-world impacts.. (8/20)

2. refinancing operations - a major omission in the review. There is no mention of moving to green the TLTROs (Targeted longer-term refinancing operations) which evolved into a major tool of how the ECB steers credit & aims to stimulate economic activity (9/20) Image
This is a major miss, as TLTROs, utilising 'monetary rocket fuel' (aka dual interest rates) could provide effectively limitless stimulus to fund economic recovery and green investment, as argued by @ericlonners and @economistmeg (10/20)
3. supporting sustainable investments - the announcements offer little promise of ECB acting in a major way to boost amounts of sustainable investments across the EU. Yet one could hope that should @EUCouncil and @EIB resolve to implement a major green investment plan.. (11/20) Image
.. the @ecb would - in its newly found recongition of climate responsibilities - act to support the @EIB through bond purchases, as recently argued for by @yanisvaroufakis in this piece for @greenCB (12/20)

greencentralbanking.com/2021/07/07/cen…
4. implementing prudential measures to increase climate risks resilience & curbing dirty finance - the approach outlined by the ECB focuses on developing more metrics, scenario analyses, macroeconomic modeling, & conducting more climate stress tests of fin. institutions (13/20) Image
These steps, while reflecting a welcome ambition to develop more analytical capabilities on climate, fail at directly targeting measures to reduce real-economy dirty investments and emissions, which fuel #ClimateCrisis and thus undermine financial and price stability (14/20)
The ECB needs to be more proactive in correcting the market failures, taking a precautionary approach now with the data we have, rather than relying so strongly on disclosures and new risk assessment metrics
sciencedirect.com/science/articl…
(15/20)
5. climate disclosures and transparency - it is welcome that the ECB will begin to disclose the climate impacts of its corporate QE, following in the footsteps of @bankofengland. But we need more transparency & accountability from the @ecb - such as public targets on ..
(16/20) Image
.. shifts in financial flows from dirty to green, and on the progress of European finance in becoming alinged with the Paris Agreement, @EU_Commission Green Deal and #netzero (17/20)
Where does that leave us? The @ecb has moved a lot since its pre-review stance: credit to @Lagarde, @Isabel_Schnabel, @FrankElderson & others at the bank that pushed for this change. But there remains much more to be done, from green TLTROs through to.. (18/20)
.. robust measures to directly curb dirty financial flows & new fossil investments (the latter incompatible with #netzero as pointed out by @IEA). A roadmap to act is welcome, but #ClimateEmergency isn't playing to our timelines. We need: real-economy actions & targets (19/20)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Lukasz Krebel

Lukasz Krebel Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @lukasz_krebel

7 Jul
A thought-provoking intervention by @yanisvaroufakis on greening the @ecb debate. He highlights valid issues with to what extent an independent (aka 'unaccountable') central bank should be making key decisions reshaping the economy. (1/7)
He argues that for ECB to green its policies - such as the collateral framework, would be 'too political' & argues instead for an @ecb @EIB 'alliance' instructed by the European Council, whilst calling for 'democratising' the ECB in some longer-term. (2/7)
But my take is that 'better' - if the latter was indeed better - can be the enemy of the 'good'. Varoufakis argues that the governments - EU council - should develop green policy, rather than the ECB. And if they did (going much beyond the EU Green Deal) it'd be great yes (3/7)
Read 7 tweets
18 Mar
Beyond #Megxit: @sjwrenlewis powerful analysis warning about the "invisible contract" between some of the public/politicians and the right-wing press that 'threatens meaningful democracy in the UK'.

TLDR: 'Permanent power is achieved in four ways': (1/5)
'The first, taking its cue from the US Republican party, is to make any election battleground about this socially conservative/liberal divide that was at the core of Brexit. The right wing press and this government’s ‘war on woke’ is designed to achieve exactly that.' (2/5)
'The second means to permanent power, again borrowed from the US right, is to make it more difficult to vote, and to saturate elections with social media ads paid with uncontrolled amounts of money.' (3/5)
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(