A rant: Those who are not interested in Indian classical music, and the wrong narratives that are being created may ignore the thread 1/n
This is specifically meant for those who fall in the performing arena and talk about "creating safe spaces for students".
Plenty of novices & those who are superficially/casually interested in music are listening to your clubhouse sessions because you have made a name. 2/n
So it makes sense to give a fair picture of the field. Painting a picture of abusive teachers is not going to help most of those. It may also turn away some people who are learning the art with interest. Don't call me insensitive. I have read those metoo tweets, & sympathize 3/n
About what they went through, and nobody should have to undergo such a situation.

These things may happen with some big names- generally there is a lot of hearsay about such folks. Common people may not be aware of, but such "predator" types are well known. Due diligence 4/n
Before whom you pick as the teacher whom you consider as a "gateway" to the performing arena.Don't tell me you got completely unaware.When there is smoke , there's often a fire. Doing the right checks & quitting at the very first instance of smelling something wrong is on you.5/n
There are bad apples everywhere in the society and some happen to be music teachers. But I guarantee , for every bad apple, there are a hundred good ones.
I am writing on behalf of all those thousands of music teachers who are passionately teaching music for years and decades 6/n
Who had the best intentions for their students & have passed on their knowledge to generations of students, with absolutely no blemish & no noise. Many are not even actively performing on stage. They are teaching music for the love of it and for the joy it brings to them d. 7/n
So before blaming all the music teachers & calling for "safe spaces in learning" as though music is the only area such things happen,stop for a minute and think. As always , when a 1:1 situation occurs, check for the obvious bad signals, they aren't hard to spot. And QUIT 8/n
Writing this as I happen to be the son of such a passionate music teacher.

End of rant.

If this thread resonated with you, do share. And help stop the vilification of Indian classical music and its teachers/ teaching system. 🙏

9/9

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with ಹಂಸಾನಂದಿ Hamsanandi

ಹಂಸಾನಂದಿ Hamsanandi Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @hamsanandi

28 Mar
@twistedlogix @TeamGSquare @MadhuraMandya @acharya2 @VVani4U @sathvik_nv @hmvprasanna Next pages .. Leaving apart what happened in the Tamizh lands of Hoysalas, Somanathapura temple having Vaishnava sculptures alone can not probably be taken as an example of rivalry.

The antagonism may have persisted in Srirangam ( back from Chola days)
@twistedlogix @TeamGSquare @MadhuraMandya @acharya2 @VVani4U @sathvik_nv @hmvprasanna Historian speak ;-)

*#Hoysala kings did not build many temples themselevs (just a handful, and majority by others)

*(Few pages later)Hoysalas spent all their money building temples (and thus cause the downfall, is you read betwen the lines)

How to assume these aren't biased?
@twistedlogix @TeamGSquare @MadhuraMandya @acharya2 @VVani4U @sathvik_nv @hmvprasanna #Settar How the Hoysala sculpures were stolen from in-situ at various temples in Hasana dist, taking advantage of the poverty and helplessness of villagers to create the "Best display of Hoysala Sculptures" anywhere in the world. 😡😡
Read 8 tweets
26 Mar
@KannadathiVidya @LeviAckerman119 @Djain87823794 There are many inscriptions where a king boasts destroying another king's capital - as far as I know, instances of destroying temples don't find a mention. Even when the inscriptions say "having burnt the town of xxx " , it is likely to be a literary figurative speak imo. 1/n
@KannadathiVidya @LeviAckerman119 @Djain87823794 I can cite some inscriptions of Chalukyas and Pallavas but will have to look up, to prove the above point. On the other hand , there are indications where the king who won the enemy's capital, actually made grants to the temples there, for further upkeep and improvements 2/n
@KannadathiVidya @LeviAckerman119 @Djain87823794 A famous example is the Chalukya inscriptions at the Rajasimhheshwara temple in Kanchi, after they won over the Pallavas. And why this temple was chosen, out of the many, many temples Kanchipuram had? Perhaps because it carried the name of the king Rajasimha - is my guess 3/n
Read 11 tweets
24 Mar
Why academicians don't do basic check & cross their ts and dot the is?😱. Here's a video of a professor from IIM, who hypothesizes river Ghaggar shouldn't be identified with Saraswati, based on a faulty translation & suspects Vedic hymn is changed!
1/3
One should look at the sources in original & not in translations. RigVeda text is available for all to check! Second, a word in a verse, confirming to a meter can't be randomly changed to something else without breaking the meter & Veda was never subject to change :-) 2/3
I wish people know this before making random allegations in the name of research😳.
Veda are called Sruti;They were not written down for millennia, because preserving them though sound was considered the best way to keep them intact, than to allow them to error prone writing. 3/3
Read 4 tweets
9 Mar
@csmspeak @vschanna Thanks for prompting me to take a look!Here #PundarikaVItthala (a contemporary of Tansen) specifically lists Parasika ragas. He says Rahai, born of dEvagAndhAra, Nishabara in KanaDa , Mahur in sAranga, Suha in Kedara etc-clearly indicating KAnada not of pArasIka origin/influence
Read 4 tweets
8 Mar
Girish Karnad claims in his play #Rakshasatangadi the temple destructon in Hampi was an "insider job"- citing still Virupaksha temple stands tall.

So can he explain why the #Nagareshwara temple in #Halebeedu is totally razed to the ground, while #Hoysaleshwara is mostly intact? Image
Here both shines were Shiva temples. There could be multiple reasons - Nagareswara for being the personal temple where the Kings worshipped was targeted first, and before they finished the job the Hoysala troups were able to guard Hoysaleshara? Your guess is as good as mine.
But the point is so called sahitis from Karnataka have normalized these to based on some random paper by one prof in Columbia. This is due to the white-skin-infliction. Where is thinking power when we need it?

Sorry to say the same trend in the latest historical novel as well.
Read 4 tweets
21 Feb
@karatalaamalaka I think the language families in India can be explained by multiple migrations in prehistoric times; By historic times ( i.e. earliest archeological remains are at Mehrgarh, IIRC - which are 9000 years ago) - the two families had already settled in with some intermingling
@karatalaamalaka The due-east-Krittikas description put parts of the Veda at least around ~3000 BCE. the 1500- 600 BCE span as imaginged by Max Mueller must go back by at least 1500 years imo.

We have Vedanga Jyotisha corresponding to the sky situation ~1400 BCE (give or take a century)
@karatalaamalaka And VJ was NOT written outside of Saptasindhu - Very likely at the upper reaches of it like in Kashmira or in around Kubha river (Kabul) by the latitude indication. Definitely not much north or south of that location.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(