As per convention, Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman will sit with Chief Justice of India NV Ramana before demitting office as a Supreme Court judge today. Proceedings begin at 10.30 am #SupremeCourt #JusticeNariman
SG Tushar Mehta: today is a very special day. Not only for us but for me. The first-ever counsel i briefed in Supreme Court was Justice RF Nariman.
SG Mehta: Be it comparative study of religions, constitutions or whichever subject, Lordhsip's exceptional brilliance and integrity will be remembered for centuries to come.
SG: I wish your lordship a happy, healthy and fulfilling life ahead and in the third innings of his life.
Justice Nariman: Thank you Solicitor
Sr Adv Singh: To be here as a president of the Bar when Justice Nariman is there is a privilege. We should be grateful to Justice Lodha who recommended the name of Justice Nariman. seven years tenure is not enough. His tenure has brought glory
Sr Adv Singh: Now hopefully Justice Nariman will have time to pursue his passion in this phase of his life. He had a very hectic life as a lawyer and a judge.
Adv Shivaji Jadhav: Justice Nariman, a Parsi priest and a LLM from Harvard will be keenly missed. At the age of 37 he was designated as a senior Adv by then Chief Justice Venkatachaliah and rules were amended to make him senior
Jadhav: Justice Nariman has delivered more than 500 reported judgments and it is known that once the verdict was reserved he did not take more than two or three days to dictate the judgment as he was very sharp
Sr Adv Dushyant Dave, former President of SCBA: I am grateful to CJI to give me an opportunity to bid farewell to one of the most popular judges of the Supreme Court. He has served the country and constitution absolutely brilliantly.
Dave: Justice Nariman was an absolute symbol of a very very fair and compassionate judge who was equally kind to all lawyers and very encouraging to the young members. I am sure younger lawyers have learnt a lot from justice Nariman,
Sr Adv Dave: I wish you happy retired life and hope he continues to guide us
Justice Nariman: Thank you
Sr Adv Siddharth Dave: We thank him from the Supreme Court cafeteria group where he always joined us for Coffee
SCAC Jt Secretary Diksha Rai: everyone is talking about Justice Nariman's retirement. we always looked forward to surprises during the tenure of Justice Nariman. When he became a judge there was a complete transformation in him. He always gave chances to junior
Rai: He is a clear role model for all of us. AG Venugopal always retirement age should not be 65 and today we all feel so. He should continue to guide us and we are happy to be at the same time when he was a judge
Justice Nariman: Thank you
Sr Adv KV Vishwanathan: Justice Nariman has adorned the precincts of the bar for more than 42 years. As a judge your contribution is enormous and brought out what was best in the bar. If his contribution can be outshone can be by your own writing post retirement.
ASG Aishwarya Bhati: We thank him from the bottom of our heart to show how the transition can be from bar to the bench. We hope he has the time to relax now
Justice Nariman: Thank you
Hon Secy of SCBA, Ardhendumauli K Prasad: We are eager to see Justice Nariman at 3.30 Pm in Supreme Court lawns
SCAORA Secy Adv Dr Joseph Aristotle: He will be remembered for his mammoth memory and razor-sharp judgments, His rulings will withstand the sands of time and his authoritative voice will be missed by all of us.
Sr Adv PS Narasimha: there are five areas where you have set an example. We have seen you as a friend, lawyer, judge, and jurist. you have set an example in all these fields. whatever you have taken up, you have given your best to it.
Sr Adv R Besant: such a multi-faceted personality. I don't think I can say much. As a former judge All my salutations for Justice Nariman for a judge who thoroughly enjoyed his work.
Sr Adv Arijit Prasad: Justice Nariman has always encouraged the young members of the bar. We hope you will continue to bless us.
Justice Nariman: Thank you
Adv Puneet Jain: as a lawyer it was very difficult to brief his lordship, but as a judge it was very easy to argue before him. Justice Nariman as a lawyer was a completely different person. We welcome him to the bar again.
Justice Nariman: Thank you
Sr Adv Ranjit Kumar: It was such a change from a lawyer to a judge. The patience.. everybody was given time to be heard. Around 360 judgments rendered are based on such painstaking research-based subjects. I don't know how he got time to write books, I wish him all the best
Sr Adv Arijit Kr Sinha: In every aspect he is an all rounder. whenever we appeared before him we knew that it was a matter of notice or stay we don't have to labour hard as he was so good with the brief. He told us what the shortcoming was and what was in our favour
Adv Shirin Khajuria: It has been such a pleasure to appear before him especially in taxation cases. You have maintained the glory of this institution.
Adv Saurav Agrawal: Justice Nariman's contribution to IBC law and arbitration has been exceptional.
Adv Alshay Sapre: since rules were amended to designate him a senior, we only hope rules are amended to have him again join the bar
CJI NV Ramana: We just now saw the overwhelming response from lawyers of Supreme Court bar and High Court bar. I thank family members of Justice Nariman, Sr Adv Fali Nariman who are present here with us.
CJI Ramana narrates the academic and legal journey of Justice Nariman: he practiced law for 35 years before being elevated to the bar and was the 5th counsel to be directly elevated to the bar. as a judge of #supremecourt he has disposed of 13,565 cases !
CJI: His jusgments like the one in Shreya Singhal (66A IT Act) has left a permanent mark on legal jurisprudence. Personally i am little overwhelmed at expressing my thoughts. On his retirement i feel we are losing one of the lions of the indian judiciary
CJI: I look forward to his continued contribution to his immense contribution to the field of law.
The ceremonial bench rises.
SCBA farewell for Justice Nariman to commence at 3.30 pm. Stay tuned for more updates.
"We are losing one of the lions of Indian judiciary:" CJI NV Ramana, Bar pay tribute to Justice Rohinton Nariman on his retirement
#BombayHighCourt allows PIL seeking Court’s intervention in Maharashtra Governor Bhagat Singh Koshiyari’s inaction to nominate 12 members recommended by the Maharashtra Council of Ministers to the State Legislative Council.
Bench of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice GS Kulkarni: We have considered arguments and formed the following issues:
Petition maintainability - answered in affirmative.
Governor discretion under Art 171 r/w Representation of People’s Act
Governor’s duty to speak?
Order: It is not impermissible to read authorisation of Clauses 3 and 5 of Art 171 r/w with Representation of People’s Act respect to governor’s decision on nomination.
#SupremeCourt is hearing a plea by former Karnataka minister & mining baron, Gali Janardhan Reddy, accused in a multi-million illegal mining case(s) seeking permission to visit & stay in the District of Bellary in Karnataka for a period of 8 weeks
Additional Solicitor General Madhavi Divan makes submissions for CBI: He is the beneficiary of the Bribe - it was done to secure his Bail. His conditions for bail should not be diluted. There was a reason as to why this should not happen. He is a very serious threat to witnesses
ASG: He is a person who has been very seriously accused. Due to not acceptance of bribe, that judge died under very serious circumstances, these are all instances that weight against cancellation of any condition imposed
#MadrasHighCourt hears petitions challenging #ITRules2021. Earlier this week, the Court had pulled up the Central govt for delay in filing its counter affidavit in the matter.
Matter is before Chief Justice Sanjib Banerjee and Justice PD Audikesavalu.
UOI is yet to file a counter-affidavit: NB Joshi informs
ASG R Sankaranayaranan appears for Union of India, tells Court that he received written instructions last night, adds that counter is being prepared, seeks one last chance to file the counter. Adds that matter can be argued as well if Court sees fit
#BombayHighCourt to continue hearing pleas filed by Mumbai journalist and a digital news portal challenging recently notified IT intermediary rules of 2021.
Hearing before Bench of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice GS Kulkarni.
Justice (Retd.) Goda Raghuram, Justice (Retd.) Prabha Sridevan, Justice (Retd.) Pradeep Nandrajog, Partner at Samvad Partners Harish Narasappa and Senior Advocate Parag Tripathi will discuss, “Justice Delivery: New Frontiers” at the Law & Economics Policy Conference today.