Sadly, @CurseOfPolitics is down for the weekend so that we can attend to family and hangovers. But here's my take on yesterday's event. I thought it was by far the best and most effective outing we've seen yet from Trudeau. Starting with the message: which was a full-on bullseye
There is no issue of greater importance to Canadians than the preservation of public health, the need to combat a 4th wave and the crucial goal of preventing further lockdowns. Mandatory vaccines and vaccine passports are essential to meeting all those goals.
The annc't demonstrates that the federal government DOES have a key role to play here. By providing additional funds to incentivize passports, the PM is using the power of the federal treasury to prompt provinces into doing what most of them want to do. And most Cdns support
Even more importantly, we are reminded by the day that not everyone agrees. Some Canadians vigorously oppose passports. And so do some political leaders. Erin O'Toole has unvaccinated candidates. He reiterated last night he believes it should be up to the provinces to decide
That's a BIG difference. That's the kind of difference that many Canadians will see as a definitional matter when it comes to their choice for PM. And that's why it was smart - even overdue - for the Liberal campaign to hammer home this difference and put it on full display
As for the protesters, they cannot help but help the PM's message be heard. They underscore that there is no uniform consensus on this issue of mandatory vaccination. Which, in turn, legitimizes the importance of the issue as a federal voting matter.
What better mechanism to settle this difference of opinion than a full-throated debate and vote. And don't tell me it's not on the ballot. The two main party leaders disagree on the subject. And when something is this important to this many people, S.91/92 is not a shield
So, to those who say this is not a matter for the federal election: you're either being obtuse or criminally lacking in your analysis. Where leaders stand on an issue this important, this emotional and this essential to the public interest is FOR SURE a voting matter. It will be
Final point: last night, in response to the ugly, selfish horseshit of the protestors, Trudeau had his best moment of this campaign. He sounded real. He was talking from a place of personal conviction. And in a way that can connect with real people and their real concerns
It was a good reminder that this guy remains the best athlete on the floor. He hasn't shown it consistently throughout this campaign. But, cliche though it sounds, do not underestimate his talent. He can turn it on when needed. And people respond.
More importantly, what Trudeau put on offer yday - really for the first time - was a sharply defined choice, which is a way of explaining why this campaign is happening. A Liberal vote gets you one world view and set of priorities. A Conservative vote gets you another. So...pick.
That sharp, salient choice - which creates a cleavage between Trudeau and O'Toole and, for the Liberals, helpfully leaves aside the complicating and appealing Singh - is what this Liberal campaign has needed. And that's why yesterday was such a good day for Trudeau

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Scott Reid

Scott Reid Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @_scottreid

19 Apr
Three takeaways on #Budget2021 First, yes, it's chock full of spending but go back to that mandate letter Trudeau wrote for Freeland where he said, steer clear of new permanent spending. Some of these initiatives may create future pressures for renewal but... #cdnpoli
There's relatively little that obligates the federal government to ongoing structural spending. In fact, you have to assume that at some point provinces and territories will move to make boosted transfers a signature demand. It's an inevitable future fight #cdnpoli
On the revenue side, who the hell knows where this leave us. Appropriately, the focus is on getting Canadians completely free of the pandemic's blast zone. But that doesn't necessarily mean all these measures add up to a plan for higher growth in the longer term #cdnpoli
Read 16 tweets
12 Apr
WARNING: Loud angry rant incoming.
Travel with me back in time to six - count em, six! - whole days ago when Premier Ford, flanked by the Minister of Health committed to opening up vaccinations to those aged 18+ in Toronto's hotspot neighbourhoods. #onpoli #topoli
This was welcome news in my household. We are in a hotspot and prior to the announcement only those aged 50 and above (i.e. old-ass me) could receive the jab. I was even happier when the portal updated on the weekend and permitted bookings in the 18-49yo cohort. #onpoli #topoli
Three eligible members of my household booked online, punching in their dates of birth and receiving both appointments and confirmation codes. "We're set," we thought with relief as we watched the positivity rate rise like mercury in mid-July. Thank goodness. #onpoli #topoli
Read 13 tweets
30 Dec 20
In moving forward, the Ford government faces 3.5 problems. First, this PO statement means the Premier knew Phillips was in St. Barts at some point between Dec. 13 and Dec. 29. On what date? And when did PO know? Because ministerial travel is tracked/approved by PO/PMO #onpoli
More fundamentally, on the date that the Premier learned Phillips was out of the country - whenever it was - why wasn't Phillips ordered home immediately? Why was the Premier "disappointed" only after the public learned the news - Instead of when he learned it? #onpoli
These Qs are the most serious threat to Phillips because they raise the possibility that his interest might begin to conflict directly with the Premier's - and that usually spells your Waterloo. Ford will be reluctant to sack but he will if he must to make it all go away #onpoli
Read 10 tweets
29 Dec 20
Sometimes we ask too much of issues management. There's no "line" or comms strategy that erases the core judgement call: with cases exploding, hospitalizations rising + his govt advising ppl to sacrifice and stay home he chose to take a 3-4 week holiday trip out of country
And, yes, I grant you that he will have done many meetings online and much work. But there's no spinning away the basic decision. Scream Aga Khan all you like but the act itself is plainly at odds with everything his own govt has been urging upon others. That's irreconcilable
To those who argue there's nothing wrong with it - provided he's following rules & intends to quarantine, fair enough. So, why did he not publicly declare he'd be out of country for the better part of a month? Answer: it looks terrible. He knew it. But he hoped to slide it past
Read 6 tweets
24 Aug 20
A few observations re #CPCLeadership:

First, props to Erin O'Toole and his campaign. This thing should have been a foregone conclusion. MacKay entered with all the endorsements, all the name recognition, all the structural advantages. It should have been a slam for him #cdnpoli
But MacKay - who has always seemed better at politics than he's actually been at politics - made a ton of unforced errors and emerged blurry. Still, the more significant factor IMO is that O'Toole ran a better campaign: a clear strategy...#cdnpoli #CPCLeadership
…a clear message, gave SoCons a comfortable second stop and outhustled on organization. MacKay lost it. But that's not a complete telling of the real story. O'Toole won it. Sometimes you run the better campaign and it doesn't matter. This time it did #cdnpoli #CPCLeadership
Read 25 tweets
6 Jul 20
Here's why I like this appointment so much. And in case people think it's a partisan thing, remember that @BobRae48 was not a Liberal when I made my bones. And although I had some friends who were very close supporters, I didn't play in the leadership runs he contested. #cdnpoli
First and foremost, he's pure talent. Effortlessly competent. Curious about people, things and issues (such a necessary quality). Charming. And good at accomplishing things. So, no matter your politics we're lucky to have him. #cdnpoli
Second, he brings a particular blend of diplomatic and political experience. Lots of people think they're good at both. He's been proven to be good at both. And that's not common. Navigating this new job will require a heavy tug on each aptitude. #cdnpoli
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(