They got triggered by this but will we see similar anger when we find that this same Aamidi labelled the Imams of the Salaf as “Hashawiyyah”?
https://twitter.com/athariarnab/status/1432674209478680578
Al Aamidi says in his book Ghaayat Al Maraam:
وبهذا أيضاً يتبين فساد قول الحشوية أن الإيمان التصديق بالجنان والإقرار باللسان والعمل بالأركان
He says that he has shown the statement of the Hashawiyyah to be manifestly invalid
What is this statement of the Hashawiyyah?
وبهذا أيضاً يتبين فساد قول الحشوية أن الإيمان التصديق بالجنان والإقرار باللسان والعمل بالأركان
He says that he has shown the statement of the Hashawiyyah to be manifestly invalid
What is this statement of the Hashawiyyah?
That Iman is belief in the heart, statement of the tongue & action of the Limbs.
Damn! This is the statement of the Hashawiyyah??
What does this word Hashawiyyah mean?
See islamic-content.com/dictionary/wor…
Who are the Hashawiyyah who said this?
Oh…just the Imams of the Salaf
Damn! This is the statement of the Hashawiyyah??
What does this word Hashawiyyah mean?
See islamic-content.com/dictionary/wor…
Who are the Hashawiyyah who said this?
Oh…just the Imams of the Salaf
Before I list them, I’ll post the admission of Al Subki that this statement is the statement of the Salaf:
المعتزلة وافقوا السلف في أن الإيمان قول وعمل ونية ولكن أخرجوا العاصي عن الإيمان والسلف لا يخرجونه
المعتزلة وافقوا السلف في أن الإيمان قول وعمل ونية ولكن أخرجوا العاصي عن الإيمان والسلف لا يخرجونه
“The Mu’tazilah agreed with the Salaf in that Iman is statement [of the tongue], action [of the limb] and intention [action of the heart] however they [the Mu’tazilah] excommunicated the Sinner from Iman whilst the Salaf didn’t”
This thread gathers just a few illuminating lights from the Salaf & Khalaf that have been labelled Hashawiyyah by this Thawr.
Al Zuhri, both Sufyans, Al Awzaa’i, Al Shafi’i, Abu Ubayd, Ahmad, Ishaq, Al Bukhari etc.
Al Zuhri, both Sufyans, Al Awzaa’i, Al Shafi’i, Abu Ubayd, Ahmad, Ishaq, Al Bukhari etc.
https://twitter.com/almoslem70/status/1131250197902839809
رحم الله ابن قيم الجوزية إذ قال:
شرح مختصر لطيف لهذه الأبيات من @Mkashfah جزاه الله خيرا
https://twitter.com/Mkashfah/status/1438105399920578564
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
