Notes on Democracy Part 2
Why should we need an opposition in the democratic system?

BJP is becoming an invincible force under @narendramodi and @AmitShah

If @BJP4India has mapped its leaders for the next 50 years including the reigns of @myogiadityanath and @annamalai_k ,
their so called opposition is shamefully struggling to figure out who their leader today is.

This being the context, our intellectuals start advising how we don’t have a robust ‘opposition’ and the importance of having an opposition.

This is the biggest collective delusion.
If judiciary can work without ideology and opposition, then why can’t the Legislature and Executive work without a political process which costs a fortune, forcing parties to be at war constantly?

What is ideology? Why should ideology lead a group of people?
Ideology should be personal. Dangerous if it becomes collective.

Indian Defence system is one of the most patriotic. They sit on arms, secret information, and skills. The leaders of defence don’t work well because there is opposition watching or there is an ideology.
Each humble Jawan who lays his life for the country is doing it for no ideology, but his personal value called patriotism.

The greatest of surgeons don’t operate well because there is an opposition in every hospital, nor an ideology that leads him.
No judge gives a fair judgment because there is opposition bench or ideology.

Our health, our defence, our economy, our justice, our infrastructure, our agriculture – we get medical help, we are protected, we have utilities and facilities, we have food on our plate -
and none of these came with a strong opposition watching. Why then we have the entity that govern all that must be any different?

Can it not be a different process based on meritocracy?

Doesn’t this inherently suggest that the political system lacks complete trust of people,
and therefore, the politicians need to be watched?

In a constituency, a candidate wins if she gets more vote than everyone else. She gets 30% and becomes their representative even though 70% of people opposed her.

Strange that this is sold to us as the system of democracy
that must govern us, and we are also told that this is the best system.

Who decided this is democracy?

This is simply collectivism – a form of transferring power from voter to the representative who becomes superior to common man with that power.
The moment he is elected, he becomes untrustworthy.

So, why at all have this system?

It has failed in every country. If the revolving door, the campaign money, the lobbying of corporatocracy spoilt the great American democracy, the political correctness and Hegelian equation
destroyed policy making of the West resulting in shifting chaos.

Gold, oil, and forest destroyed the stability of African and South American countries and created never ending unrest in the middle east.

Robbed India of our ability to rebuild after the millennium-long invasion
of aliens on our land.

Corruption is the face of the present democratic order of the world.

What inherent weakness led countries succumb to corruption?

It did not even spare a country like Japan before Abe – despite their world-renowned discipline.
What made India’s opposition sing the tunes of our hostile neighbours?

Which Congress frontline worker is happy to do that?

Still they are doing this under the collective hysteria of ideology.

It made a section of our people hate a patriot like Modi whom they have
absolutely no personal conflict with.

Enmity is always personal.

If we feel hatred towards someone we don’t know personally, then that is a conditioned state of mind.

Politics or manmade religions are the tools of conditioning.
It’s like what Jergović compared as the ‘pack of dogs in the park’. He said if a single dog chased you, it’s natural.

But if a pack did it, then they are conditioned.

If I can trust people in every other profession that directly affects my life, then I see nothing wrong in
trusting a leader like Narendramodi.

I say this toxic political system must stop.

We must start thinking what is best for our country and develop a system that works for all.

In Part 3, I analyse the flaws of democracy and suggest an alternative model.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sreevidya Balasubramaniam

Sreevidya Balasubramaniam Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @BaluSreevidya

9 May
Some hard facts on India's battle with Chinese Virus. This will disappoint @narendramodi haters. I will dismantle their narrative.

138 Cr people. That is 196 countries in the world from Morocco to Holy See.

Indian PM = 196 Prime Ministers of the world.

Let that sink in first.
~ Announced locked down early on, received severe criticism quoting economic impact

~ Provided guidance and funding for Oxygen plants to set up in states a year ago

~ In August last year, MoH provided guidelines and asked states to develop their own protocols for arrivals
~ Since 4 Dec 20, started sending states estimates (District wise) of future requirements of bed capacities

~ Created an online tool for states to record needs

~ Since 27 Feb 21, MoH sent warnings to states asking to reinforce Covid behaviours and 'deal firmly with violations'
Read 24 tweets
27 Apr
My note on the current Bio-war and international orchestrations of Big Pharma against India/ Modi

Let me start by saying this:
~ India has the strongest leadership it has ever had in your hands Hon PM @narendramodi Ji

Your's is not a personal choice. You are our collective will
There are three factors that are playing in the background:

1. The patent war which India initiated through it's groundbreaking judgement by the Supreme Court in 2013

2. China trying topple India from being the pharmaceuticals provider of the world

3. India's focus on building
Biowarfare under our security framework and strengthening of our defence mechanisms which helped us so much during the first wave of Covid19.

Keep these in the back of your mind while reading through.

First, let's examine a brief history of India's defensive position.
Read 18 tweets
4 Apr
My message on Kerala Battlefield - 2

This is a quick message before the polls. Will try to share my analysis in a few days.

During my discussion in Jaipur Dialogues a few months ago, I had speculated LDF win. Still see this the most probable scenario.

Kerala voters who support BJP show two clear trends:

1. Vote congress in a bid to keep LDF out
2. Vote for a winning party as BJP never had 'winning' image

We must stop this because this election is different.

No matter if you vote for Congress or BJP, LDF is likely to win
We are in a good situation now.

If LDF comes back to power, then in 5 years, BJP can grow as the main opposition and can go into 2026 elections as a winning party.

If UDF comes to power now, BJP will not only not have their voice strong in the assembly, but will be lost in the
Read 8 tweets
4 Apr
My Notes on Tamil Nadu Battlefield Part 5

This is a quick note. I normally do not indulge in poll speculations, but this time, I want to say with reasonable conviction that @AIADMKOfficial (NDA) will come back to power on May 2.

I just watched @KolahalasTV which referred to a
poll analysis published by @DemNetworkIndia predicting a clean win for NDA.

I support this analysis for the following reasons:

1. Stalin has done a stellar job since 2016, the election he had led from the front opposing JJ. Till date he has shown consistency with allies,
Kept his cadres energised, invested heavily in Social Media engineering.

To this end, support of 32 channels owned by his relatives and party helped.

2. However, losing Sunil Kanugolu put Stalin in great fear, and following his S-I-L Sabareesan, he hired PKP, which in fact
Read 17 tweets
31 Jan
My Notes on Democracy Part 1

MANUFACTURING Dl55ENT AND MODI'S RESPONSE - AN ANALYSIS

DlS5ENT is allowed in a democracy. Any democratic leader or government will uphold - and MUST uphold its citizens's right to DlS5ENT.

This thread analyses the recent Indian experience.
Some years ago, a western country displayed a movie on India in their visitor centre. Showed @Narendramodi the then Gujarat CM as a devil incarnate drinking the blood of MU5LlM.

A tough battle with the authorities resulted in taking down this video.
Lesson - this obscure country which Modi never visited till date has little to do with Indian politics. Yet, there is this need to stop Modi in his tracks of becoming the future PM by smearing him.

Most of you may have noticed Modi as a potential PM in the last decade.
Read 25 tweets
30 Dec 20
My Notes on Tamil Nadu Battle Field – Part 3

POST RAJINIKANTH POLITICS

My short thread on RK was focusing on the challenges RK will face. Key points.

1. I said that if Rajini couldn’t enter the “Rajini” style, hen he won’t enter at all. His announcement yesterday reflects it.
2. His followers are not united by a cause or ideology but by the mutual attraction towards a hero.

This will cause issues going forward as their bond will have to be a continuous guidance and inspiration from their leader who couldn't spare that energy or time due to his health
I had predicted in my first thread in November that Rajini won't form a third front.

So, when RK announced his political entry, I was surprised for two reasons:

1. when he announced his entry in 2017 there was a political vacuum in Tamil Nadu.
Read 34 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(