I am aware that I may realize I was wrong over time but after thinking hard about it, I made the decision and I want to be transparent about it.
Here is why I made this decision ⬇️
$PINS did not have a great report last quarter.
Financial numbers where good (growth, margins, ARPU) but I did not like management talking about "web users" and "mobile users" to justify the user slow down.
However, I did see some truth in it, so I decided to hold and wait
During the quarter, it became clear that $PINS had decided to make a shift in the business they had built all this years to have an e-commerce experience and presence.
These type of transitions are always hard and require laser focus by management to execute correctly
And then we got the news that the co-founder Paul Sciarra was leaving. This was another potential red flag in my opinion.
Was this a personal decision? Was this based on different opinions on the future of the company? Who knows.
And finally, the Paypal potential acquisitions news.
"The companies have discussed a price of around $70 a share"
If management is discussing around this price and they feel that it is a fair price to sell, who am I to disagree?
Pinterest stock when to $65 on Wednesday. So I had a decision to make.
1. If the deal closes, shareholders get $70. That is the upside. (<10%)
2. If the deal does not closes, we can easily go back under $50 + now the market knows that management was considering selling.
3. If this was a company that I had high confidence in based on previous reports, I could hold long term and be fine.
But I decided this was not longer the case for me. Hence why I sold.
Unfortunately, I only sold half on Wednesday. The rest was sold after Snapchat report yesterday.
I decided that this was the final blow for me. I did not have the confidence to hold long term. In general, highly valued companies require near flawless execution.
Overall, $PINS was a good investment for me.
I may very well be proved wrong over time and I am at peace with that. I am just following my process.
And I wish all $PINS shareholders the best in the future.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Now that most companies have reported earnings, it is a good time to assess where current valuation multiples stand and the estimates of revenue CAGR for the next few years.
This is the consolidated graph with all the companies:
In this other one, I included some companies that I had to exclude in the first graph:
$AFRM
$SNOW
$DLO
$GLBE
This earnings season the market is adjusting post covid. Seems like we are back to a stock pickers market. One of the important variables to look for is multiple expansion.
The following graph is a comparison of this metric for some companies pre and post pandemic.
To calculate the multiple expansion of each company, I compared the average multiple of every quarter from 2018-2019 vs today, using the following metrics:
- EV/GP
- EV/EBITDA
- EV/FCF
This has some limitations as multiples in 2018-2019 may be considered high or low.
But I wanted to get an estimate of how the pandemic and its consequences have affected valuations.
I used only positive metrics, so if FCF or EBITDA multiples were negative, I excluded those from the average. Gross profit was always used.
I like to compare companies with different metrics. It helps me understand a little better each business. This time, I am sharing the metric Gross Profit / Employee.
Hope you find it interesting 🙂
This is the consolidated graph. The next graphs are grouped by industry 👇