Since freedom of religion and equality before law have been called “Western” ideas in Sadanand’s piece (even though just ~75 years ago millions of Jews and others were killed in Germany FOR being Jews etc; Germany is as West as it gets)
@EdwardGLuce gives a “shabash!” to
@dhume
If the West means a particular civilisation - historically centred in Europe and including its offshoots of settler colonies, and having clear racial-religious characteristics though growing beyond it, then Germany has to be the West. If modern means time, 75 years ago is modern.
If on the other hand, what you are really trying to describe are what you think are universal “better” values you should not link it to just one civilisation though semantics retain path-dependence. After all, Fascism Marxism are also “modern Western” values based on origin/time.
Haha, Ed “In spite of the Gods” Luce couldn’t take his favourite “Western liberalism” being questioned and has blocked me. No “shabash!” for me, alas :) ImageImage

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Harsh Madhusudan

Harsh Madhusudan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @harshmadhusudan

31 Oct
Justice DY Chandrachud speaks so much about intersectionality - and all that means is subjectivity since the hierarchy of victimhood is not and can never be objective. One wishes that he just took one issue - free speech and consequent state capacity - and worked hard to push it.
But will that happen? I wouldn’t bet on it. The Indian judiciary has absolutely no first principles - most infamously with its completely arbitrary, ever expanding and invented concept of the basic structure doctrine - where a fundamental right can be read in but never read down.
Now one may think - well isn’t that great - except FRs of course also contradict each other. I am not saying everything can be reduced to an algorithm - not at all - but there is not even an attempt to be more consistent by our unelected judges, who still use contempt for speech.
Read 6 tweets
31 Oct
We should have grand Mandirs where Gods and Goddesses from around the world - Indian, Arab, European, African, Native American, East Asian - are worshipped even as one God(dess) is the central deity which changes from Mandir to Mandir. #Dharmatva #PanchayatanaPuja #Smarta #Dharma
What I find beautiful about the Panchayatana Puja is that by worshipping Vishnu, Shakti, Shiva, Ganesha, Surya (can vary) - we cover all life forms (male, female, human, non-human) as well as non-life forms or nature. So universal-yet allows for an Ishta Devata to be prioritised.
In fact an average Hindu family’s small home Mandir is likely to resemble the above concept broadly speaking (maybe more so in North India where Sampradaya affiliations seem less likely) - so this is broader than Smarta in that sense. This also forces us to reexamine “Hindu-ism”.
Read 5 tweets
29 Oct
To understand Rakesh Jhunjhunwala’s thinking, let us explore this article - includes the presentation that he apparently made in front of PM @narendramodi recently.

(Some graphs are created by TOI, and are not part of the presentation. Behind paywall)

m.timesofindia.com/india/why-indi…
First thing to notice is that RJ sees a clear trend towards faster growth in India over the last half century. One can quibble over the numbers but the trend is your friend (until it isn’t.)

I had a similar graph on my substack except it was on per capita growth rates.
The more important thing to notice is that RJ thesis is based on not some narrow financial understanding but a holistic economic history, geo-political and sociological-anthropological basis as well (again, quibbles aside.) That’s the only way to test a view and build confidence.
Read 7 tweets
20 Oct
No of airports, metros, dedicated freight corridors, semi high speed lines, expressways, highways, roads, ports, sanitation/sewage systems, electricity/drinking water last mile networks on top of “soft” infra, digital public goods is incredible. More to come #LongIndia #NewIndia
2015-2025 will be the decade when we connected the last billion Indians to national and global economy. It wouldn’t be something that only the rich or the middle classes can do anymore. The deluge of human productivity and aspirations that this is releasing is just mind boggling.
Imagine a now rural or ‘rurban’ household which within the next 3-5 years can afford a made-in-India AC, washing machine, microwave, EV 2W etc, can order for goods/food online. Imagine change in women’s lives especially- and if more of them are educated, decide to join workforce.
Read 4 tweets
19 Oct
RBI's Economic Activity Index (EIA) indicates that real GDP grew by 9.6 per cent in July-Sep 2021.

Q1FY22 was at 20.1%. So ~7.5% is already baked in cake; two quarters to go. Many estimates will be revised upwards. They overcorrected for second wave - and are conceptually wrong.
In fact, the second wave has all but guaranteed (along with other factors) that FY23 is also likely to see ~double digit real growth. Ultimately growth is both path dependent *and* based on factors of production. COVID is a unique (and tragic) macro-econ experiment in that sense.
“In the next fiscal year (FY2022-23), consensus expects output to be 8% higher than in FY2019-20, whereas output today might already be 13% higher” by @neelkanthmishra

tessellatum.in/?p=384
Read 4 tweets
19 Oct
Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy, Apartheid South Africa, Jim Crow America - these labels are being used to defame India, Sangh Parivar, PM Modi, BJP CMs, Hindutva, Dharma etc.

But nearly everyday actual killings happen in Bangladesh, Pakistan, Afghanistan and within India - Kashmir.
A peaceful boycott of a company - a right of all consumers - is termed terrorism, but actual physical-real, flesh-blood, life-death terrorism is not called so.

Words have no meaning, like they have not had under Gandhian-Nehruvian secularism for some time.

Truly it is all maya.
There is zero empathy to even try to understand another's point of view. Consider Bangladesh (originally East Bengal) where Hindus have been consistently driven out for decades. But in West Bengal the party which the majority of Hindus vote for doesn't get to form the government.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(