#SupremeCourt is hearing a plea by a lawyer who is aggrieved by alleged incorrect marking granted to him in the Advocate in Record examination #AoRExam
Justice DY Chandrachud: But this is not a maths exam that you will give a sum total. These are descriptive answers, they check English, the flair and other things too #AoRExam
Adv Vivek Sharma: Please see the answer papers. I got 10 marks.
DYC J: yes that's 10 marks
Sharma: Why should not I get 90 to 95 marks here ? Even the initials of examiner in some pages are different
DYC J: But you have got 15 marks
Sharma: in every question there are parts ..
DYC J: If you don't know that in a suit a party is called a plaintiff and defendant then perhaps you should prepare again and appear
Sharma: I don't want to show loopholes in the system. I just want justice in my case. Loopholes are clear in front of you
Justice AS Bopanna: we are on scope of litigation. We cannot enter brain of examiner and why you got less marks. We can simply dismiss it also. I am only hearing you because you are a lawyer. If there was provision for revaluation we could have ordered. But there is no such thing
Sharma: Under Article 145 and using SC rules, it is your administrative power to order this revaluation.
DYC J: Did you appear after 2019?
Sharma: there was no exam
DYC J: you appear again then. Sorry we cannot convince you. There is no provision for revaluation. Dismissed.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Justice AM Khanwilkar presents the welcome address and says how @rashtrapatibhvn had a long association with the #SupremeCourt where he practiced as a lawyer.
Justice AM Khanwilkar thanks Secretary General of Supreme Court of India, Virendra Kumar Bhansal for organizing the event
#SupremeCourt expresses disapproval in the manner which was adopted by NCDRC to breach orders of the top court directing disposal of cases relating to grievance of home buyers
Justice DY Chandrachud: The homebuyers had moved a plea before NCDRC in 2017. However the case was only adjourned and never decided. #SupremeCourt
DYC J: In an SLP filed before this court in 2020, this court in December 2020 had ordered the President NCDRC to hear the case and decide on merits and ensure expeditious disposal
#SupremeCourt to hear Center's challenge to #CalcuttaHighCourt order setting aside the CAT order transferring Alapan Bandyopadhyay, former West Bengal Chief Secretary's plea from Kolkata to Delhi Bench @MamataOfficial@DoPTGoI
@MamataOfficial@DoPTGoI SG: Can this be kept on Monday, We have to leave for Vigyan bhavan for Constitution Day function
SC: Okay adjourned to Monday
Dr AM Singhvi: I hope you have got my submissions
SC: We are waiting to hear you Mr Singhvi
Singhvi: I hope written submissions don't substitute oral arguments (laughs)
#SupremeCourt to hear a plea by NGO Centre for PIL challenging the the appointment of IPS officer Rakesh Asthana as Commissioner of Delhi Police @pbhushan1@DelhiPolice
Adv Prashant Bhushan: petition and the copies were served.
DYC J: We will issue notice
Sr Adv Mukul Rohatgi appears for Rakesh Asthana: we will file a reply
Bhushan: they had the opportunity to file a reply to the writ for a long time and centre has filed a reply in HC. Issues are same, they will not need much time
#SupremeCourt to shortly hear a plea seeking stay on amended reservation policy (27% OBC and 10% EWS in AIQ) and abolishment of the notice dated 29.07.21 vide which the amended policy was notified #NEET#Counselling@advocate_tanvi@indlawyer
BREAKING: SG Tushar Mehta: we will be revisiting the economically weaker section criteria reservation and take a call. Till then counselling will go on for the next four weeks.
Justice DY Chandrachud: the more we delay the admission the more it will drag. This is your call what to do with EWS then