Thread by @barandbench

Justice DY Chandrachud led bench hears an appeal by National Medical Commission in a case

Justice DY Chandrachud: This is a case where in a padeatric ward all children were admitted without any problems. Have you seen the Munnabhai MBBS movie counsel ?

#SupremeCourt

Sr Adv AM Singhvi: Please listen to my non Munnabhai MBBS submission points my lord

#supremecourt

Another observation by Justice DY Chandrachud:

DYC J: How did the hospital have fake patients ? Illness does not end on Makar Sankranti. This is a case of falsifying records Me Singhvi

#SupremeCourt

SC: NMC as well as Annasaheb Chudaman Patil Memorial Medical College is before this court against HC order. The order was by Bombay HC order of Jan 25, 2022

Justice Chandrachud observes in between of dictating order: what we have observed is shocking in terms of the inspection.

SC: The medical College which was established in 1992 with an intake capacity of 100 seats for MBBS course. The medical College submitted an application on Nov 2020 for increase in capacity to 150 for 2021-22

SC: On July 15 renewal license was granted that continuation of recognition will be in accordance with law. The assessors appointed by the NMC conducted a physical inspection on Oct 8/9 2021 and a letter on intent was issued

SC: College submitted a letter of undertaking and thereafter intake capacity was increased. On Jan 14, 2022, surprise inspection was conducted. Based on the report, on Jan 19 NMC withdrew increase in intake

SC: It directed admissions to stop for 2021-22. Writ was filed before Aurangabad bench of Bombay HC by college. By Jan 25 order, an option was given to medical College to either go for reinspection or avail of appellate remedy

SC: The college said it will go for fresh re-inspection. The HC order has been challenged by the NMC saying HC order has been passed without noticing provision of NMC act.

SC: It appears that medical College also filed a civil application to modify earlier Jan 25 order on the ground that grounds urged before HC was not dealt with.

SC: HC has recorded that medical College has accepted re inspection proposal. Both medical College and NMC is aggrieved by the HC order. NMC says gross negligence was observed during the inspection.

SC: Medical College says there cannot be any dispute about the original complement of 100 seats. HC has not dealt with submission by rival parties and thus we cannot intervene under Article 136. We set aside the impugned orders of HC and restore the plea before HC

SC: SG Tushar Mehta appeared for NMC, Dr Singhvi and MR Nishesh Gupta appeared for the medical College. All rights remain open before HC. #supremecourt

[Hospital admitting fake patients] Have you seen Munnabhai MBBS? Supreme Court to medical college

report by @DebayonRoy

#supremecourtofindia #SupremeCourt

Read story here: bityl.co/AurH