As someone raised in a Brahmnical (not just Brahmin) family, I relate so much with this thread. I came to Ambedkar through a long and torturous route -- having internalized many of the casteist prejudices very common in this community. 1/
Apart from the usual anti-reservation indoctrination, dismissal of mass conversions out of Hindu fold as "nav-buddha phenomenon", quite pejoratively, one of the most ironic things about this community is the belief in their own "modernism". I'm not even kidding. 2/
An average Maharashtrian Brahmin believes that they (I can't say we anymore, tho I have to, in all fairness, share the blame) are the most "reformed" of all castes, and that they "don't see caste". They will, as example, bring up some inter-caste marriage in extended family. 3/
Or how they now eat food cooked by "dalits", or such. And while, technically, some of this is true, this is just very surface level "reform" -- the only kind that most people are capable of. But even that is rare. And, worse, they are completely satisfied with their "reform". 4/
Imagine, this community, with a very high percentage of educated, even highly-educated, population, which has exposure to different cultures, languages, literature, setting the bar for themselves SO LOW. They are happy that they are not overtly bigoted (in their minds). 5/
But this is the group that has read the least of Dr. Ambedkar. They have, on average, a very low opinion of him ("he just copy pasted British constitution" -- is how they dismiss his contribution), and less said the better about his writings, which they rarely, read. 6/
Or encourage their children to read. You'd rarely see Ambedkar's books in Marathi brahmin households. Which is such a shame, given that he's such a towering figure -- not just as a political leader, but more importantly a social/socio-political thinker. 7/
So I had to learn about caste and casteism, of affirmative action and social justice, of endogamy, of structural inequalities and structural violence, and everything that is necessary in even a *basic* understanding of casteism through SM, and Wilkerson's book ... 8/
... Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents. And I'm ashamed to say that I picked up Annihilation of Caste last year. Started reading what Ambedkar had to say, not just what people around me said about Dr. Ambedkar. 9/
"Reading Dr. Ambedkar in Brahmin Heartland" could be an excellent title of a documentary about the experience of lot of so called savarnas like me -- being kept away from this great heritage. False idols like Savarkar are idolized in this heartland. 10/
But Dr. Ambedkar gets treated with distrust at best and derision more commonly. For a while, I struggled with this -- this exclusion of a great political and social thinker from our collective lives -- assuming it to be accidental. But reading him, one realizes ... 11/
... that it's deliberate. That the façade of "modernity" that this community has built will fall, like a pack of cards, after reading a few pages of AOC. That keeping Dr. Ambedkar out of the hands of their children is *essential* for the very existence of Brahmanism. 12/
The need of the hour is for Dr. Ambedkar study circles for the savarna, to at least make them read his writings, not writings about him. It won't be easy to find takers for it, because those at the helm of Brahmanism have done a fine job relegating him to obscurity. 13/
Even in the liberal savarna circles, one finds a lot more deification of Gandhi/Nehru than of Dr. Ambedkar. And as @gauravsabnis identifies in his thread, once you read Dr. Ambedkar, even a few pages of AOC, you realize how big a thinker he was, how far ahead of his time. 14/
If you're born in communities like mine, do yourself a favor: read AOC. It won't be easy. Years of conditioning will raise its ugly head. But persist, and read. You owe it to yourself. Believe me! END/

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Amit Kahi-pun-kar 📕🎷☕ 🍫👨‍🍳📺🎬

Amit Kahi-pun-kar 📕🎷☕ 🍫👨‍🍳📺🎬 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @asuph

Mar 6
My kid was less than a year old then. I sometimes feel many men miss out on these early moments of absolute bliss because they assume child-rearing is a predominantly mother's job.
Yes, the bigger problem with it is the asymmetric burden that it places on the new mothers, but I'm going to talk to the men about what some of *them* are missing out on. I want to share a tiring but rewarding period of my life, as a hands-on father.
The Indian tradition of sending a mother to be to her parents home for first delivery, for instance, denies many fathers the pleasure of holding their newborn baby, many times. Men sometimes don't even see their babies for week/months (thankfully changing).
Read 7 tweets
Jan 29
In the recent past, I've learned from two extremely independent, and mentally strong women, that they have this inferiority complex/imposter's syndrome thanks to the people around them -- family and friends, well-meaning, and good people. 1/
Our society doesn't validate achievements of women as much as it validates achievements of men -- even close friends/relatives, who, sometimes unconsciously, end up creating this sense of "I'm not good enough" (even for the partners who love them) or "I don't belong here" 2/
The point is, many of us, especially the men, do not realize that this is happening. That women around us, women we care about, women we look up to, are going through these micro-crises, and that we may be part of the culture that brought them on. 3/
Read 8 tweets
Oct 22, 2021
Warning: A long, rambling🧵.

Back in my teens, I read Sunita Deshpande's (Marathi) book Aahe Manohar Tari

Loosely translated as: it's all pleasant but) from a line of a poem that end with "gamate udaas" (feels sad).

It was an important book in many ways.

1/
Sunita Deshpande was the wife of P. L. Deshpande -- Maharasthra's much loved writer, and a multi-talented person. He was primarily a humorist, but an astute observer of human traits and frailties. The book, an autobiography, generated a lot of controversy (more later).

2/
To introduce Sunita tai as "wife" of someone is an injustice to her, but for many, that's how they know her. She was a firebrand woman, independent thinker, outspoken, and courageous. She joined freedom struggle when she was 17 yo.

[Photo of her from her youth]

3/
Read 20 tweets
Oct 21, 2021
"[O]ften inquisitors create heretics. [...] Inquisitors repress the heretical putrefaction so vehemently that many are driven, to share in it, in their hatred for the judges."

-Umberto Eco, The Name of the Rose.
I dearly miss #UmbertoEco with his clinical insights on everything, from religion/belief to fascism. The quote above also reminded me of Arthur Koestler's Darkness at Noon, and in turn the Stalinist purges it was based on. A must read book for our times, I you ask me.
It's ironic that Stalin, the militant atheist, used methods that the Spanish Inquisition would have been proud of, to break down dissidents, on random pretenses, just like the former. And although the scale of those two is probably incomparable to other such instances ...
Read 4 tweets
Jun 26, 2021
TW: #sucide #mentalhealth #depression

This is going to be the most difficult thread I've ever written. But I know I have to. For my own sanity, catharsis.

1/
In 2019, I lost a friend. He died of suicide. He was a classmate, and a colleague. We worked alongside each other for 8 years. We had lunches together. He was a gem of a person. Extremely intelligent, a 10x engineer (if there is such a thing). Soft-spoken. Without malice.

2/
No, I am not eulogising him. I know that most people who have known him would agree with this assessment. And in any case, it shouldn't matter if he wasn't all that I'm saying he was. Those are just details I could not not mention.

3/
Read 22 tweets
Jun 13, 2021
Another Sunday. Another thread. #caste #privilege #merit #prejudice

My primary school was a govt. aided vernacular medium school run by an ed. institute (one of the better ones in my home city). My first recall of #caste is from when I was in 2nd/3rd.

1/
One of our teachers that year was NOT upper-caste (unlike most teachers in the school), and the predominantly upper-caste parents (including mine) weren't happy with the "quota" teacher. The general mood was "our education system is going to collapse due to quota"

2/
The thing is, this was decided based on his "surname", and of course based on prejudice of all the upper-caste teacher's, who had an obvious grudge against "quota system" that the govt. grant mandated. I don't even remember if he was a good or bad teacher.

3/
Read 19 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(