📢New publication: "Globalization of Environmental Justice: A Framework for Comparative Research," which compares Indigenous Peoples' struggles in the United States & India. @OUPAcademic Handbook of Comparative Env Politics Ed. by Jeannie Sowers, @StacyDVanDeveer & Erika Weinthal
I build on the @Ostrom_Workshop IAD framework to compare the struggles of Apache activists opposed to proposed copper mining in Oak Flats (Tonto National Forest, Arizona) w/ the resistance of state-led mining in central India by Gond Indigenous Adivasis. #IndigenousPeoples 2/n
How do Indigenous Peoples' struggles in different sociopolitical & institutional context differ from one another? What can we learning from studying these movements comparatively? I adopt a comparative contextualization approach to broach the type of Qs that come up freqntly 3/n
First half of the chapter offers a synthetic review of the insights we gain from the U.S. environmental justice movement, which has gained strengthened from the longstanding struggles of EJ activists, scholar activists, & civil society institutions, within a specific context 4/n
These questions have come up in the context of the convergence of environmental justice & climate justice movements. And, as part of scholar activism advocating for a global environmental justice movement. Hugely imp for global solidarity with Indigenous Peoples' struggles. 5/n
Two pieces have fostered my thinking on Qs of comparative env justice.
2) Martinez-Alier et al. Is There a Global Environmental Justice Movement? Also see, Anguelovski & Martínez Alier. 2014. “The ‘Environmentalism of the Poor’ Revisited.” Kudos to the inspiring work of many scholars & activists as part of #EJAtlas@EnvJustice@ianguelovski 7/n
I seek to bring in the tools & conceptual architecture of comparative environmental politics, comparative institutionalism & political economy to these debates. There is a massive opportunity to forge engaged cross-disciplinary conversations on environmental & climate justice 8/n
EJ/CJ scholars engaging in self-critiques is challenging w/ potential political implications. A shared commitment to respect, learn from, & contribute to Indigenous Peoples' struggles across the vastly different political landscapes of global South vs North will keep us going 9/n
I'm fired up about engaging with EJ/CJ research communities. Such collaborations seem crucial to learn from diverse Indigenous Peoples of the world & advance the ongoing work of decolonizing environmentalism & environmental studies. In Solidarity✊🏽✊🏽 10/10 eu.patagonia.com/es/fr/stories/…
Should've mentioned that the two photos in the tweets above are not some random pictures - they represent the two case studies I use in this comparative analysis of Indigenous Struggles in India & the United States. 11/n #EnvironmentalJustice#Decolonization#IndigenousPeoples
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Not sure where to start this thread, but @Trevornoah
& @TheDailyShow have made a serious error of judgment in giving platform to a known charlatan. As others have pointed, we wish they'd spent more time researching this gentleman before having him on. 1/n
We've been thinking about this for long: "Scientists, corporations, mystics, and movie stars have convinced policymakers around the world that a massive campaign to plant trees should be an essential element of global climate policy." #TrillionTrees#Restoration 2/n
Dear @jack and everyone else reading this. Please stop funding hate in the times of corona. @SewaUSA is a well-known peddler of hate and bigotry. #COVID19#Covid19IndiaHelp
To better know the supporters of Sewa USA, one should look through the replies to the following tweet by @Profdilipmandal, who has had casteist and bigoted slurs hurled at him. Don't feed the hate machine, @jack.
Here is an investigative report by @nehadixit123 on the involvement of 3 #RSS affiliates in trafficking of 31 tribal girls from the state of Assam in eastern India to Punjab in north & Gujarat in west. #COVID19#Covid19IndiaHelp#StopFundingHate
India wants richer countries to adopt “net negative” emissions targets. Indian energy minister "launched a broadside against the climate goals of big emitters in the EU and China, in a sign of how climate negotiations are heating up ahead of a UN summit this year." A thread. 1/n
The Indian minister is correct about the lack of ambition among the industrially advanced countries, esp. the U.S., which is creating hurdles against the EU-led effort to introduce a carbon border tax, which would go a long way in curbing consumption. 2/n ft.com/content/d31ec6…
Let's be clear, nothing can replace the need for reducing luxury emissions linked to profligate consumption. The environmental impacts of net-negative are unknown – where are we going put all that carbon with what other environmental & social consequences (unknown unknowns!)? 3/n
On Thursday, Delhi Police registered a criminal case against Greta Thunberg to probe international conspiracy to defame India & promote enmity among groups". They cited her tweets as an evidence in the case! No Kidding! #RightToProtest#FarmersProtest 2/n deccanherald.com/national/farme…
Unfortunately @GretaThunberg is not the first climate activist to face the wrath of Delhi Police. In July 2020, they blocked the website of @FFFIndia, describing the contents of the website as “objectionable” & depicting an “unlawful or terrorist act”. 3/n thewire.in/environment/fr…
Prime minister of makes an emotional speech to ask people of India to stay home on a Sunday. He asks them to do it for the country and do it for him (because, you know, he has always gotten whatever he has asked for). So far so good 1/n
In the same emotional speech, he copies the Italian model of people expressing solidarity with doctors & health care workers. The difference? Well, in this case, it is happening because of the urging of a great leader. He reminds everyone that this is a sign of patriotism. 2/n
Well, you know what? Of course, people want to show their patriotism. The great leader asked them to stand in their balconies and bang plates & utensils to orchestrate a thumping tribute. Unfortunately, not everyone has balconies. Plus, people want to show their patriotism. 3/n